Montana Case Commentaries

Ash v. Elliot: Recognizing Nonmonetary Contributions in Marital Asset Division

Date: Nov 23, 2024

Ash v. Elliot: Recognizing Nonmonetary Contributions in Marital Asset Division Introduction In the landmark case In re the Marriage of Ash and Elliot (2024 MT 273), the Supreme Court of Montana...

Parrot Ditch Co. v. Norman Ashcraft Jr.: Defining Service Areas and Procedural Requirements in Montana Water Rights Adjudication

Date: Nov 23, 2024

Parrot Ditch Co. v. Norman Ashcraft Jr.: Defining Service Areas and Procedural Requirements in Montana Water Rights Adjudication Introduction The case of Parrot Ditch Company (PDC) v. Norman Ashcraft...

Limitations on Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Claims in Direct Appeal: Analysis of STATE OF MONTANA v. MATTHEW M. MAYS (2024 MT 275)

Date: Nov 23, 2024

Limitations on Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Claims in Direct Appeal: Analysis of STATE OF MONTANA v. MATTHEW M. MAYS (2024 MT 275) Introduction The case of State of Montana v. Matthew M. Mays...

Montana Supreme Court Establishes Robust Application of Terry Stop Doctrine in Stanley v. State

Date: Nov 23, 2024

Montana Supreme Court Establishes Robust Application of Terry Stop Doctrine in Stanley v. State Introduction In State of Montana v. David Stanley (2024 MT 271), the Montana Supreme Court addressed...

Lodge Members Cannot Substitute Organizational Injury for Their Own Standing

Date: Nov 13, 2024

Lodge Members Cannot Substitute Organizational Injury for Their Own Standing Supreme Court of Montana | 2024 MT 264 | November 12, 2024 Central principle: A member challenging a voluntary...

Parenting-Plan Modification Requires Statutory Support: A Nonprecedential Montana Decision

Date: Nov 13, 2024

Parenting-Plan Modification Requires Statutory Support: A Nonprecedential Montana Decision Case: IN THE MARRIAGE OF: BENJAMIN DAVID MARTIN, Petitioner and Appellant, and BRANDI WILLIAMS, F/K/A BRANDI...

Sentence Credits Do Not Merge Across Consecutive Sentences: Custody Credit and Elapsed-Time Credit in Montana

Date: Nov 13, 2024

Sentence Credits Do Not Merge Across Consecutive Sentences: Custody Credit and Elapsed-Time Credit in Montana Case: TYILER RAFFERTY, Petitioner, v. JIM SALMONSEN, Warden, Montana State Prison, and...

Purging Contempt and Appellate Mootness: Montana Applies Settled Law in a Noncitable Family-Law Decision

Date: Nov 13, 2024

Purging Contempt and Appellate Mootness: Montana Applies Settled Law in a Noncitable Family-Law Decision Case: IN RE THE MARRIAGE OF: LISA SWIFT, Petitioner and Appellee, v. MATTHEW T. SWIFT,...

Continuing Protection Orders Without a New Hearing: Record-Based Discretion Under Settled Montana Law

Date: Nov 13, 2024

Continuing Protection Orders Without a New Hearing: Record-Based Discretion Under Settled Montana Law Case: ERIN A. BILLS, Petitioner and Appellee, v. KRISTIN C. COOPER, Respondent and Appellant....

Deferred-Prosecution Contract Claims Accrue Upon Final Favorable Termination of Criminal Proceedings

Date: Nov 13, 2024

Deferred-Prosecution Contract Claims Accrue Upon Final Favorable Termination of Criminal Proceedings Case: Laura Marie Obert v. State of Montana and Cory Swanson Citation: 2024 MT 270 Court: Supreme...

Montana Inmate Medical-Complaint Screening: No Statutory Right to Review Without a Cognizable, Redressable Injury

Date: Nov 7, 2024

Montana Inmate Medical-Complaint Screening: No Statutory Right to Review Without a Cognizable, Redressable Injury Decision: 2024 MT 256 | Court: Supreme Court of Montana | Date: November 6, 2024 |...

Waiver by Conduct of Objections to a Probate Settlement: Applying Settled Montana Law

Date: Nov 7, 2024

Waiver by Conduct of Objections to a Probate Settlement: Applying Settled Montana Law Case: IN THE MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF MARTIN W. MACLAY, Deceased. Court: Supreme Court of Montana Citation: 2024...

Montana’s Newly Discovered Evidence Exception Requires Affirmative and Unquestionable Proof of Actual Innocence

Date: Nov 7, 2024

Montana’s Newly Discovered Evidence Exception Requires Affirmative and Unquestionable Proof of Actual Innocence Case: BILLY LEE HENDERSON, III, Petitioner and Appellant, v. STATE OF MONTANA,...

Case-Specific Pandemic Risks May Justify Remote Testimony, and Material Memory Lapses May Permit Prior Statements

Date: Nov 7, 2024

Case-Specific Pandemic Risks May Justify Remote Testimony, and Material Memory Lapses May Permit Prior Statements STATE OF MONTANA, Plaintiff and Appellee, v. WES LEE WHITAKER, Defendant and...

Applying Settled Montana Criminal Law: Warrants, Self-Defense Voir Dire, Reasonable Doubt, and Sentencing

Date: Nov 7, 2024

Applying Settled Montana Criminal Law: Warrants, Self-Defense Voir Dire, Reasonable Doubt, and Sentencing Case: STATE OF MONTANA, Plaintiff and Appellee, v. AARON EUGENE McLAUGHLIN, Defendant and...

Witness Tampering May Be Proved Circumstantially Without Establishing the Truth of the Witness’s Original Account

Date: Nov 7, 2024

Witness Tampering May Be Proved Circumstantially Without Establishing the Truth of the Witness’s Original Account STATE OF MONTANA, Plaintiff and Appellee, v. TANYA TWOTEETH, Defendant and Appellant....

Substitute Counsel: A Separate Hearing Is Unnecessary When an Adequate Initial Inquiry Resolves the Defendant’s Complaints

Date: Nov 7, 2024

Substitute Counsel: A Separate Hearing Is Unnecessary When an Adequate Initial Inquiry Resolves the Defendant’s Complaints Case: STATE OF MONTANA, Plaintiff and Appellee, v. JOSE FRANK PATINA,...

Medical-Privacy Claims: Proof of Causation and the UHCIA Exclusion for HIPAA-Covered Providers

Date: Nov 7, 2024

Medical-Privacy Claims: Proof of Causation and the UHCIA Exclusion for HIPAA-Covered Providers Case: PATRICK A. MALLOY, III, Plaintiff and Appellant, v. BETTINA J. WEILER MALLOY HUNT, PROVIDENCE ST....

Affirmation of Community Caretaker Doctrine and Standards for Probationary Searches in Montana Supreme Court's Decision in State of Montana v. Jay Le Cleveland

Date: Sep 25, 2024

Affirmation of Community Caretaker Doctrine and Standards for Probationary Searches in Montana Supreme Court's Decision in State of Montana v. Jay Le Cleveland Introduction The Supreme Court of...

Montana Supreme Court Establishes Commercial Short-Term Rentals as Violation of Restrictive Covenants

Date: Sep 18, 2024

Montana Supreme Court Establishes Commercial Short-Term Rentals as Violation of Restrictive Covenants Introduction In the landmark case of April Myers et al. v. Joseph Kleinhans and Amanda Kleinhans,...