Montana Case Commentaries

Montana ODC’s Complaint in In re Terry F. Schaplow: A Strong Warning Against Unsubstantiated Attacks on Judicial Integrity and Ex Parte Threats Under MRPC 3.1, 3.3, 3.5, 8.2, and 8.4

Date: Feb 21, 2025

Montana ODC’s Complaint in In re Terry F. Schaplow: A Strong Warning Against Unsubstantiated Attacks on Judicial Integrity and Ex Parte Threats Under MRPC 3.1, 3.3, 3.5, 8.2, and 8.4 Court: Supreme...

Recalibrating Credited Time and Treatment Court Violations: A New Precedent on Habeas Corpus Relief

Date: Feb 20, 2025

Recalibrating Credited Time and Treatment Court Violations: A New Precedent on Habeas Corpus Relief Introduction The Judgment in the case of Bill B. Bokma v. Bob Olson, Program Administrator,...

Affirming Administrative Discretion in Floodplain Permit Review and Public Participation

Date: Feb 20, 2025

Affirming Administrative Discretion in Floodplain Permit Review and Public Participation Introduction The Supreme Court of Montana recently rendered a pivotal decision in the case of Protect the...

Establishing the Requirement of Devisee Consent and Equitable Estoppel in Estate Claim Extensions

Date: Feb 20, 2025

Establishing the Requirement of Devisee Consent and Equitable Estoppel in Estate Claim Extensions Introduction The Montana Supreme Court’s decision in the matter of the Estate of Warren Dan Eddleman...

The Equivalence of Unsworn Declarations and Affidavits: A New Standard for Summary Judgment in Debt Collection Cases

Date: Feb 20, 2025

The Equivalence of Unsworn Declarations and Affidavits: A New Standard for Summary Judgment in Debt Collection Cases Introduction In the case of CB1, d/b/a CBB COLLECTIONS v. Hove, the Supreme Court...

Clarifying Standing and Discretion in Sentencing Enhancements for Sexual Abuse Cases

Date: Feb 12, 2025

Clarifying Standing and Discretion in Sentencing Enhancements for Sexual Abuse Cases Introduction The case of State of Montana v. Garrett Alan Lee, 2025 MT 30 introduces a significant precedent...

The Evidentiary Threshold for Lesser-Included Offense Instructions in Criminal Trials

Date: Feb 12, 2025

The Evidentiary Threshold for Lesser-Included Offense Instructions in Criminal Trials Introduction The case of State of Montana v. Beau Avidiya (2025 MT 31) before the Montana Supreme Court centers...

Prospective Limitations in Title Insurance: No Duty to Defend Post-Policy Actions

Date: Feb 12, 2025

Prospective Limitations in Title Insurance: No Duty to Defend Post-Policy Actions Introduction The case of ROGER and THERESE HUTCHINSON v. OLD REPUBLIC NATIONAL TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY and JOHN HOLT...

Distinction in Dangerous Drug Counts and Sentencing Inconsistencies: A Montana Supreme Court Analysis

Date: Feb 12, 2025

Distinction in Dangerous Drug Counts and Sentencing Inconsistencies: A Montana Supreme Court Analysis Introduction The Montana Supreme Court’s memorandum opinion in State of Montana, Plaintiff and...

Establishing a Reasonable-Belief Standard: New Precedents for HCQIA Immunity in Peer Review Actions

Date: Feb 12, 2025

Establishing a Reasonable-Belief Standard: New Precedents for HCQIA Immunity in Peer Review Actions Introduction The judgment in THOMAS C. WEINER, M.D. v. ST. PETER'S HEALTH et al. represents a...

Precluding Parental Inheritance Rights Under Montana's § 72-2-124 MCA

Date: Feb 8, 2025

Precluding Parental Inheritance Rights Under Montana's § 72-2-124 MCA Introduction The case of In re the Estate of M.A.C., Deceased Minor (2025 MT 23) presents a significant legal determination by...

Montana Supreme Court Upholds Discretion in Sexual Offender Tier Designation: State of Montana v. Joseph Eugene Garcia

Date: Feb 8, 2025

Montana Supreme Court Upholds Discretion in Sexual Offender Tier Designation: State of Montana v. Joseph Eugene Garcia Introduction In the landmark case State of Montana v. Joseph Eugene Garcia, the...

Montana Supreme Court Limits Scope of Public Access Easements in Subdivision Road Dispute

Date: Feb 8, 2025

Montana Supreme Court Limits Scope of Public Access Easements in Subdivision Road Dispute Introduction The Supreme Court of Montana recently adjudicated a pivotal case, GBSB Holding, LLC v. Flathead...

Montana Supreme Court Affirms Enforcement of Marital Property Settlement Agreement: No Additional Payments or Attorney's Fees Awarded

Date: Feb 5, 2025

Montana Supreme Court Affirms Enforcement of Marital Property Settlement Agreement: No Additional Payments or Attorney's Fees Awarded Introduction The case of In re the Marriage of Joseph Ghahari and...

Reinstatement of Conviction Post-Habeas Corpus Reversal: Insights from State v. Garding

Date: Feb 5, 2025

Reinstatement of Conviction Post-Habeas Corpus Reversal: Insights from State v. Garding Introduction State v. Katie Irene Garding is a landmark decision by the Supreme Court of Montana issued on...

Montana Supreme Court Establishes Strict Requirements for Termination of Parental Rights Under § 41-3-609(1)(f), MCA

Date: Feb 5, 2025

Montana Supreme Court Establishes Strict Requirements for Termination of Parental Rights Under § 41-3-609(1)(f), MCA Introduction The Supreme Court of Montana delivered a memorandum opinion in the...

Strict Enforcement of Restrictive Covenants in Residential Subdivisions

Date: Feb 5, 2025

Strict Enforcement of Restrictive Covenants in Residential Subdivisions Introduction The case of Scott Larsen and Karen Larsen v. Keith Sayers and Danielle Sayers addresses the enforcement of...

Montana Supreme Court Upholds Public Access to Junque Files and Enforces Appellate Procedural Compliance

Date: Feb 1, 2025

Montana Supreme Court Upholds Public Access to Junque Files and Enforces Appellate Procedural Compliance Introduction In the landmark case of Saslav v. Howe, decided on January 27, 2025, the Supreme...

Montana Supreme Court Sets Precedent on Legislative Access to Confidential Child Abuse Records Under MCA § 41-3-205

Date: Jan 23, 2025

Montana Supreme Court Sets Precedent on Legislative Access to Confidential Child Abuse Records Under MCA § 41-3-205 Introduction In the landmark case of William W. Mercer v. Montana Department of...

Supreme Court of Montana Affirms District Court's Parenting Plan Modification in Anderson v. Anderson

Date: Jan 23, 2025

Supreme Court of Montana Affirms District Court's Parenting Plan Modification in Anderson v. Anderson Introduction In the case of In Re the Marriage of Benjamin J. Anderson and Kristin C. Anderson...