Montana Case Commentaries

Implied Consent Does Not Bar Warrant-Based Blood Draws for First-Time DUI Suspects: State v. Clinkenbeard (Mont. 2025)

Date: Mar 26, 2025

Implied Consent Does Not Bar Warrant-Based Blood Draws for First-Time DUI Suspects: State v. Clinkenbeard (Mont. 2025) Introduction In State v. Clinkenbeard, 2025 MT 54, the Supreme Court of Montana...

Montana Confirms Agency Power to Decide Preemption; EO 14042 Expressly Preempted § 49-2-312 for Federal Contractors

Date: Mar 26, 2025

Preemption as Statutory Interpretation: Montana Agencies May Decide Federal Preemption; EO 14042 Expressly Preempted § 49-2-312 for Federal Contractors Introduction In Qlarant Integrity Solutions,...

Good Cause Means Diligence: Montana Supreme Court Affirms Limits on Backdating UI Claims and New Evidence on Board Appeal (Lake v. Montana DLI)

Date: Mar 26, 2025

Good Cause Means Diligence: Montana Supreme Court Affirms Limits on Backdating UI Claims and New Evidence on Board Appeal in Lake v. Montana Department of Labor & Industry Court: Supreme Court of...

No Per Se Reversal for Technical Jury-Selection Violations: State v. Hillious Clarifies Substantial Compliance, Strict Timeliness, and Treats TOP Petitions as Testimonial

Date: Mar 26, 2025

No Per Se Reversal for Technical Jury-Selection Violations: State v. Hillious Clarifies Substantial Compliance, Strict Timeliness, and Treats TOP Petitions as Testimonial Introduction In State v....

When Foreign Residence Interrupts “Home-State” Status: Montana May Assert Significant-Connection Jurisdiction and Impose Temporary Child Travel Limits (Parenting of A.H.S., 2025 MT 57)

Date: Mar 26, 2025

When Foreign Residence Interrupts “Home-State” Status: Montana May Assert Significant-Connection Jurisdiction and Impose Temporary Child Travel Limits (Parenting of A.H.S., 2025 MT 57) Introduction...

Nonprecedential Clarification: District courts abuse discretion by denying Rule 60(b)(3) relief without an evidentiary hearing when alleged forgery and notice are materially disputed

Date: Mar 26, 2025

Nonprecedential Clarification: District courts abuse discretion by denying Rule 60(b)(3) relief without an evidentiary hearing when alleged forgery and notice are materially disputed Case: In re the...

Non-Preclusive Standing Dismissals and Common-Injury Taxpayer Classes in Montana: Commentary on Gottlob v. DesRosier (2025 MT 56)

Date: Mar 26, 2025

Non-Preclusive Standing Dismissals and Common-Injury Taxpayer Classes in Montana: Gottlob v. DesRosier (2025 MT 56) Introduction In Gottlob v. DesRosier, 2025 MT 56, the Supreme Court of Montana...

Restitution Causation in Montana: Insurer Claim Testimony + Credibility Findings Can Satisfy the Preponderance Standard

Date: Mar 19, 2025

Restitution Causation in Montana: Insurer Claim Testimony + Credibility Findings Can Satisfy the Preponderance Standard 1. Introduction In State v. Raver, 2025 MT 51, the Montana Supreme Court...

Incorrect “Knowingly” Instruction in SIWOC Is Not Reversible Absent Prejudice When Consent Is the Only Disputed Fact

Date: Mar 19, 2025

Incorrect “Knowingly” Instruction in SIWOC Is Not Reversible Absent Prejudice When Consent Is the Only Disputed Fact Case: State v. P. Green (2025 MT 52N) | Court: Supreme Court of Montana | Date:...

Enhanced Evidentiary Standards and Procedural Discipline in Protective Order Hearings

Date: Mar 14, 2025

Enhanced Evidentiary Standards and Procedural Discipline in Protective Order Hearings Introduction The case of IN RE THE ORDER OF PROTECTION OF: TEDDEE HARRIS CUOMO, Petitioner and Appellant, v....

Affirming Judicial Discretion: Adequate Security and Supersedeas Bonds in Stay Orders

Date: Mar 14, 2025

Affirming Judicial Discretion: Adequate Security and Supersedeas Bonds in Stay Orders Introduction The case of Frank A. Apecella and Shirlynne Apecella versus Lillian A. Overman and Larry Robinson,...

Reaffirming the “Depiction” Standard in In-Person Child Sexual Abuse: Montana’s New Precedent in Brennan

Date: Mar 14, 2025

Reaffirming the “Depiction” Standard in In-Person Child Sexual Abuse: Montana’s New Precedent in Brennan Introduction The case of State of Montana v. Thomas Joseph Brennan (2025 MT 46) has now set...

Defendant’s Right of Allocution and the Limits of Plain Error Review in Sentencing: A Critical Analysis of STATE OF MONTANA v. DIETZ

Date: Mar 14, 2025

Defendant’s Right of Allocution and the Limits of Plain Error Review in Sentencing: A Critical Analysis of STATE OF MONTANA v. DIETZ Introduction The Montana Supreme Court issued a memorandum opinion...

Clarifying Appellate Burden and Evidentiary Standards: The Flathead High School Reunion Judgment

Date: Mar 14, 2025

Clarifying Appellate Burden and Evidentiary Standards: The Flathead High School Reunion Judgment Introduction The case of FLATHEAD HIGH SCHOOL CLASS OF 1973 REUNION COMMITTEE v. DEBORA STANDLEY...

Strict Adherence to the Two-Thirds Renewal Standard in Subdivision Covenants

Date: Mar 12, 2025

Strict Adherence to the Two-Thirds Renewal Standard in Subdivision Covenants Introduction In the case of CHARLIE'S WIN, LLC v. GALLATIN WEST RANCH HOMEOWNERS' ASSOCIATION, INC. (2025 MT 47), the...

New Precedent in Informal Domestic Relations Trials and Parenting Plan Formulation

Date: Mar 2, 2025

New Precedent in Informal Domestic Relations Trials and Parenting Plan Formulation Introduction The case of In re the Parenting of F.L.F.L.K. Christopher J. Lamm sets forth new principles regarding...

Clarifying Termination of Parental Rights in Substance Abuse Cases: A Comprehensive Analysis of A.R., A Youth in Need of Care (2025 MT 39)

Date: Mar 2, 2025

Clarifying Termination of Parental Rights in Substance Abuse Cases: A Comprehensive Analysis of A.R., A Youth in Need of Care (2025 MT 39) Introduction This commentary examines the Montana Supreme...

Clarifying the Application of Best Interest Factors in Parenting Plan Determinations under § 40-4-212, MCA

Date: Mar 2, 2025

Clarifying the Application of Best Interest Factors in Parenting Plan Determinations under § 40-4-212, MCA Introduction The case “IN RE THE PARENTING OF E.O. v. DANIEL T. O'GORMAN” involves a complex...

Enforcement of Easement Rights: Affirming Remedies for Water Misappropriation and Trespass

Date: Mar 2, 2025

Enforcement of Easement Rights: Affirming Remedies for Water Misappropriation and Trespass Introduction The case of Bradley C. Workman and Karen M. Workman v. Brian Kenneth Stainthorpe (2025 MT 38)...

Affirming Trial Court Discretion: Procedural Negotiations and Supplemental Verdict Forms in Justifiable Use of Force Cases

Date: Mar 2, 2025

Affirming Trial Court Discretion: Procedural Negotiations and Supplemental Verdict Forms in Justifiable Use of Force Cases Introduction The case of State of Montana v. Kevin Charles Walla (2025 MT...