Missouri Case Commentaries

Municipal “DWI” Record Must Prove Physical Driving/Operating to Count as an IRTO for Chronic-Offender Enhancement

Date: Feb 27, 2026

Municipal “DWI” Record Must Prove Physical Driving/Operating to Count as an IRTO for Chronic-Offender Enhancement Introduction In State v. Peters (Mo. banc Feb. 24, 2026), the Supreme Court of...

Section 452.375.5(5) Does Not Create an Independent Third-Party Visitation/Custody Cause of Action Absent a Pending Custody Dispute

Date: Feb 27, 2026

Section 452.375.5(5) Does Not Create an Independent Third-Party Visitation/Custody Cause of Action Absent a Pending Custody Dispute Case: In re A.L.P. and S.H.P. (Supreme Court of Missouri, en banc)...

Hanshaw v. Crown Equipment Corp.: Reliability Proof Required for Expert Design-Defect Opinions Under § 490.065; Exclusion Can Compel Summary Judgment

Date: Feb 27, 2026

Reliability Proof Required for Expert Design-Defect Opinions Under § 490.065; Exclusion Can Compel Summary Judgment 1. Introduction In Hanshaw v. Crown Equipment Corp. (Mo. banc Feb. 24, 2026), the...

Unreported Attorney-Discipline Orders Are Not Citable Precedent; Intentional Client-Fund Deception Warrants Disbarment

Date: Jan 29, 2026

Unreported Attorney-Discipline Orders Are Not Citable Precedent; Intentional Client-Fund Deception Warrants Disbarment 1. Introduction In re: Brian Todd Goldstein, Respondent (Supreme Court of...

Apperson v. Kaminsky — Plaintiff Testimony May Prove Actual Reputational Harm; “Independent Evidence” Not Required

Date: Jan 29, 2026

Apperson v. Kaminsky: Plaintiff Testimony May Establish Actual Reputational Injury in Missouri Defamation Actions (and Unstated Directed-Verdict Grounds Cannot Support Affirmance) Introduction...

Nicholson v. State — “Germanness” Limits Floor Amendments: Non‑Severable Invalidity for Original‑Purpose Violations (and Taxpayer Standing via State Litigation Expenditures)

Date: Jan 29, 2026

Nicholson v. State — “Germanness” Limits Floor Amendments: Non‑Severable Invalidity for Original‑Purpose Violations (and Taxpayer Standing via State Litigation Expenditures) 1. Introduction Case:...

Missouri’s Solar Access Rule: §442.404.3 Voids Pre-Existing HOA Solar Bans and Bars Placement Rules that Adversely Affect Cost or Efficiency

Date: Jan 29, 2026

Missouri’s Solar Access Rule: §442.404.3 Voids Pre-Existing HOA Solar Bans and Bars Placement Rules that Adversely Affect Cost or Efficiency Case: Eikmeier v. Granite Springs Home Owners Association,...

Missouri Upholds SAFE Act and Medicaid Funding Ban Under Rational-Basis Review as Age-and-Medical-Use Classifications

Date: Jan 15, 2026

Missouri Upholds SAFE Act and Medicaid Funding Ban Under Rational-Basis Review as Age-and-Medical-Use Classifications Case: E.N. v. Kehoe (Supreme Court of Missouri, Jan. 13, 2026) Holding in brief:...

Missouri Attorney Discipline: Supreme Court Not Bound by Mental-State Stipulations; Knowing Facilitation of Fraudulent Asset-Reduction Triggers Suspension (Stayed with Probation)

Date: Jan 15, 2026

Missouri Attorney Discipline: Supreme Court Not Bound by Mental-State Stipulations; Knowing Facilitation of Fraudulent Asset-Reduction Triggers Suspension (Stayed with Probation) 1. Introduction In...

Missouri Persistent-Offender DWI: “Separate Occasions” Must Be Found by a Jury, Yet § 577.023.2 Survives Facial Challenge Through Second-Stage Jury Findings

Date: Jan 15, 2026

Missouri Persistent-Offender DWI: “Separate Occasions” Must Be Found by a Jury, Yet § 577.023.2 Survives Facial Challenge Through Second-Stage Jury Findings 1. Introduction In State ex rel. Catherine...

Wood v. State of Missouri: Capital Postconviction Limits—Victim-Impact Poetry Not Hearsay, Strategic Choices “Virtually Unchallengeable,” and Preservation Failures Not Cognizable Under Rule 29.15

Date: Jan 15, 2026

Capital Postconviction Review in Missouri: Strategic Trial Choices, Victim-Impact Evidence, and the Procedural Limits of Rule 29.15 1. Introduction Wood v. State of Missouri (Supreme Court of...

State v. Burkett: Discretion to Decline Plain-Error Review When the Defendant Contributes to Unpreserved Error or the Claim Likely Reflects Trial Strategy

Date: Dec 30, 2025

State v. Burkett: Discretion to Decline Plain-Error Review When the Defendant Contributes to Unpreserved Error or the Claim Likely Reflects Trial Strategy 1. Introduction State v. Burkett (Mo. banc...

Rule 30.20 Plain-Error Review Requires a Facially Substantial Showing; “Into” May Subsumes “At” in Variance Claims

Date: Dec 30, 2025

Rule 30.20 Plain-Error Review Requires a Facially Substantial Showing; “Into” May Subsumes “At” in Variance Claims 1. Introduction State v. Jones (Supreme Court of Missouri, Dec. 29, 2025) addresses...

Corroborated Medical Evidence Can Supply Probable Cause for Bodily-Fluid Testing Despite Hearsay Gaps: State v. Barrera (Mo. banc 2025)

Date: Dec 30, 2025

Corroborated Medical Evidence Can Supply Probable Cause for Bodily-Fluid Testing Despite Hearsay Gaps: State v. Barrera (Mo. banc 2025) Court: Supreme Court of Missouri | Date: 2025-12-29 1....

Political Campaigning from the Bench Warrants Immediate Removal; “Delayed-Resignation” Sanctions Rejected

Date: Dec 30, 2025

Political Campaigning from the Bench Warrants Immediate Removal; “Delayed-Resignation” Sanctions Rejected Case: In re: The Honorable Matthew E.P. Thornhill, Respondent (Mo. banc Dec. 29, 2025) 1....

Docket-Entry Suppression Orders Trigger the State’s Five-Day Interlocutory Appeal Deadline (Mo. Rev. Stat. § 547.200.4)

Date: Nov 5, 2025

Docket-Entry Suppression Orders Trigger the State’s Five-Day Interlocutory Appeal Deadline (Mo. Rev. Stat. § 547.200.4) Case: State of Missouri v. Mire (Supreme Court of Missouri, en banc) Date:...

General Partnership “Aggregate Theory” + AAA Delegation Clause: Partners’ Individual Signatures Can Compel Arbitration and Send Scope to the Arbitrator

Date: Nov 5, 2025

General Partnership “Aggregate Theory” + AAA Delegation Clause: Partners’ Individual Signatures Can Compel Arbitration and Send Scope to the Arbitrator 1. Introduction Parties and business...

Missouri Supreme Court Mandates the Houston Four-Step Framework for Against-the-Weight-of-the-Evidence Appeals

Date: Nov 5, 2025

Missouri Supreme Court Mandates the Houston Four-Step Framework for Against-the-Weight-of-the-Evidence Appeals 1. Introduction Weeks v. City of St. Louis (Supreme Court of Missouri, Nov. 4, 2025)...

No Shortcut to the Supreme Court: Missouri’s Clarified Rule on Appellate Jurisdiction over Preliminary Injunctions

Date: Aug 14, 2025

No Shortcut to the Supreme Court: Missouri’s Clarified Rule on Appellate Jurisdiction over Preliminary Injunctions 1. Introduction In Comprehensive Health of Planned Parenthood Great Plains v. State...

“The Rhodes Rule”: Missouri Supreme Court Re-Affirms that an Order Is Not Appealable Unless Every Requested Remedy—Legal and Equitable—Is Expressly Resolved

Date: Aug 14, 2025

“The Rhodes Rule”: Missouri Supreme Court Re-Affirms that an Order Is Not Appealable Unless Every Requested Remedy—Legal and Equitable—Is Expressly Resolved 1. Introduction Kevin Rhodes, a former...