Minnesota Case Commentaries

Affirmation of the Common Enterprise Exception under Minnesota Workers' Compensation Act: O'Malley v. Ulland Brothers

Date: Jul 9, 1996

Affirmation of the Common Enterprise Exception under Minnesota Workers' Compensation Act: O'Malley v. Ulland Brothers Introduction In the landmark case of Michael C. O'Malley v. Ulland Brothers, et...

Establishing Reasonable Suspicion Through Knowledge of Revoked License: STATE v. PIKE

Date: Jul 4, 1996

Establishing Reasonable Suspicion Through Knowledge of Revoked License: STATE v. PIKE Introduction State of Minnesota v. John Keith Pike (551 N.W.2d 919, 1996) is a landmark decision by the Supreme...

Termination of Parental Rights Based on Palpable Unfitness: In the Matter of the Welfare of S.Z.

Date: May 24, 1996

Termination of Parental Rights Based on Palpable Unfitness: In the Matter of the Welfare of S.Z. Introduction The case In the Matter of the Welfare of S.Z. (547 N.W.2d 886) adjudicated by the Supreme...

STATE v. ROBY: Upholding the Waiver Doctrine in Postconviction Relief

Date: Apr 27, 1996

STATE v. ROBY: Upholding the Waiver Doctrine in Postconviction Relief Introduction State v. Gary L. Roby, 547 N.W.2d 354 (Minn. 1996), is a landmark decision by the Supreme Court of Minnesota that...

Expansion of 'Terroristic Threats' to Include Physical Acts: Commentary on State of Minnesota v. John Patrick Murphy

Date: Apr 13, 1996

Expansion of 'Terroristic Threats' to Include Physical Acts: Commentary on State of Minnesota v. John Patrick Murphy Introduction The case of State of Minnesota v. John Patrick Murphy, decided by the...

LOLLING v. MIDWEST PATROL: Expanding Jurisdiction on Late Employer Protests in Reemployment Insurance Claims

Date: Mar 23, 1996

LOLLING v. MIDWEST PATROL: Expanding Jurisdiction on Late Employer Protests in Reemployment Insurance Claims Introduction LOLLING v. MIDWEST PATROL, Commissioner of Economic Security is a landmark...

Adequacy of Legal Remedies Precludes Equitable Claims: ServiceMaster v. Sentry Insurance

Date: Mar 9, 1996

Adequacy of Legal Remedies Precludes Equitable Claims: ServiceMaster v. Sentry Insurance Introduction The case of ServiceMaster of St. Cloud, Inc. v. Sentry Insurance, a Mutual Company (544 N.W.2d...

Minnesota Supreme Court Establishes Defendant's Right to Waive Sentencing Guidelines in State v. Givens

Date: Mar 9, 1996

Defendant's Right to Waive Sentencing Guidelines Established in State of Minnesota v. Givens Introduction State of Minnesota v. Steven Louis Givens, 544 N.W.2d 774 (Minn. 1996), is a landmark...

Reputation Matters: Minnesota's Upholding of Actual Harm Requirement in Defamation Cases

Date: Feb 24, 1996

Reputation Matters: Minnesota's Upholding of Actual Harm Requirement in Defamation Cases Introduction The Supreme Court of Minnesota, in the case of James RICHIE, et al. v. PARAMOUNT PICTURES...

Expanded Accomplice Liability: Minnesota Supreme Court Upholds First-Degree Murder Conviction

Date: Feb 17, 1996

Expanded Accomplice Liability: Minnesota Supreme Court Upholds First-Degree Murder Conviction Introduction The Supreme Court of Minnesota, in the case of State of Minnesota v. Tommie NMN Atkins,...

Silbaugh v. Silbaugh: Establishing the Standard for Interstate Child Relocation

Date: Feb 17, 1996

Silbaugh v. Silbaugh: Establishing the Standard for Interstate Child Relocation Introduction The case of Meredith Louise Silbaugh v. John Gerald Silbaugh, decided by the Supreme Court of Minnesota on...

Successor Judge Authority to Reconsider Predecessor Rulings: KORNBERG v. KORNBERG Analysis

Date: Jan 20, 1996

Successor Judge Authority to Reconsider Predecessor Rulings: KORNBERG v. KORNBERG Analysis Introduction The case In re the Marriage of Lela Diane Kornberg v. Harvey Kornberg (542 N.W.2d 379, Supreme...

Affirmation of Multiple Convictions in State of Minnesota v. Cole: Interpretation of Felony Murder and Conviction Consistency

Date: Jan 6, 1996

Affirmation of Multiple Convictions in State of Minnesota v. Cole: Interpretation of Felony Murder and Conviction Consistency Introduction In the landmark case of State of Minnesota v. Phillip Lewis...

Affirmation of Smith’s Conviction: Prosecutorial Duties and Sentencing Discretion under Minnesota Law

Date: Jan 6, 1996

Affirmation of Smith’s Conviction: Prosecutorial Duties and Sentencing Discretion under Minnesota Law Introduction The case of State of Minnesota v. Carlos Orlando Smith (541 N.W.2d 584) was...

Multiple Sentencing Permitted Under Minn. Stat. §609.035: Analysis of STATE v. Bookwalter

Date: Dec 9, 1995

Multiple Sentencing Permitted Under Minn. Stat. §609.035: Analysis of STATE v. Bookwalter Introduction STATE of Minnesota v. Thomas Joseph Bookwalter, 541 N.W.2d 290 (1995), is a landmark decision by...

Affirmation of State's Burden in First-Degree Murder and Upholding Domestic Abuse Homicide Statute in State v. Auchampach

Date: Dec 2, 1995

Affirmation of State's Burden in First-Degree Murder and Upholding Domestic Abuse Homicide Statute in State of Minnesota v. William J. Auchampach, Jr. Introduction State of Minnesota v. William J....

Proximate Cause and Summary Judgment in Snowmobile Accident: Supreme Court of Minnesota Decision in Lubbers v. Anderson

Date: Nov 18, 1995

Proximate Cause and Summary Judgment in Snowmobile Accident: Supreme Court of Minnesota Decision in Lubbers v. Anderson Introduction The case of Shawn Lubbers et al. v. Greg Anderson, Richard...

Use of Anonymous Juries in High-Stakes Criminal Cases: Implications from STATE of Minnesota v. A.C. Ford, Jr.

Date: Nov 16, 1995

Use of Anonymous Juries in High-Stakes Criminal Cases: Implications from STATE of Minnesota v. A.C. Ford, Jr. Introduction The case of STATE of Minnesota v. A.C. Ford, Jr. (539 N.W.2d 214)...

Ambiguity in Municipal Bond Agreements Affirmed: Bondholder Rights in In re Hennepin County Recycling Bond Litigation

Date: Nov 10, 1995

Ambiguity in Municipal Bond Agreements Affirmed: Bondholder Rights in In re Hennepin County Recycling Bond Litigation Introduction In the landmark case of In re Hennepin County 1986 Recycling Bond...

Sanction for Spoliation of Evidence in Product Liability: PATTON v. NEWMAR CORP.

Date: Sep 30, 1995

Sanction for Spoliation of Evidence in Product Liability: PATTON v. NEWMAR CORP. Introduction Mary Patton et al. v. Newmar Corporation, 538 N.W.2d 116 (Supreme Court of Minnesota, 1995), presents a...