Minnesota Case Commentaries

Minnesota Supreme Court Affirms MPCA's Authority to Apply Secondary Drinking Water Standards to Groundwater in NPDES/SDS Permits

Date: Feb 11, 2021

Minnesota Supreme Court Affirms MPCA's Authority to Apply Secondary Drinking Water Standards to Groundwater in NPDES/SDS Permits Introduction In the landmark case State of Minnesota v. United States...

Minnesota Supreme Court Reaffirms Notice-Pleading Standard and Rejects Private Cause of Action under Official Records Act in Tyler Hal v. MnSCU

Date: Jan 21, 2021

Minnesota Supreme Court Reaffirms Notice-Pleading Standard and Rejects Private Cause of Action under Official Records Act in Tyler Hal v. Minnesota State Colleges and Universities Introduction The...

Reversing Overbreadth: Minnesota's Statute on Nonconsensual Image Dissemination Survives Strict Scrutiny

Date: Dec 31, 2020

Reversing Overbreadth: Minnesota's Statute on Nonconsensual Image Dissemination Survives Strict Scrutiny Introduction In State of Minnesota v. Michael Anthony Casillas, the Minnesota Supreme Court...

Interpretation and Application of Minn. Stat §611.02 in Multiple Guilty Verdicts: The Steward v. State Decision

Date: Nov 13, 2020

Interpretation and Application of Minn. Stat §611.02 in Multiple Guilty Verdicts: The Steward v. State Decision Introduction Raymond Cortez Steward v. State of Minnesota, 950 N.W.2d 750 (Minn. 2020),...

Effective Assistance of Counsel in Plea Negotiations: An Analysis of State v. Jamil Joshua Eason

Date: Oct 29, 2020

Effective Assistance of Counsel in Plea Negotiations: An Analysis of State v. Jamil Joshua Eason Introduction In the landmark case of State v. Jamil Joshua Eason, the Minnesota Supreme Court...

Sha v. Chavez-Nelson: Affirming Strict Standards for Ineffective Assistance Claims in Postconviction Relief

Date: Sep 17, 2020

Sha v. Chavez-Nelson: Affirming Strict Standards for Ineffective Assistance Claims in Postconviction Relief Introduction Sha v. Chavez-Nelson (948 N.W.2d 665) is a pivotal decision by the Minnesota...

Protecting Victim Privacy: Minnesota Supreme Court’s Landmark Ruling in In re B.H.

Date: Jul 30, 2020

Protecting Victim Privacy: Minnesota Supreme Court’s Landmark Ruling in In re B.H. Introduction The Minnesota Supreme Court’s decision in In re B.H., Appellant, State of Minnesota, intervenor, v....

Minnesota Supreme Court Recognizes Unpaid Practicum Students as Employees Under the Minnesota Human Rights Act

Date: Jul 30, 2020

Minnesota Supreme Court Recognizes Unpaid Practicum Students as Employees Under the Minnesota Human Rights Act Introduction The Minnesota Supreme Court in Meagan Abel v. Abbott Northwestern Hospital,...

Comprehensive Commentary on State of Minnesota v. Darren Heath Degroot: Establishing Standards for Criminal Attempt and Offense Inclusion

Date: Jul 16, 2020

Comprehensive Commentary on State of Minnesota v. Darren Heath Degroot (946 N.W.2d 354) Court: Minnesota Supreme Court Date: July 15, 2020 Introduction The case of State of Minnesota v. Darren Heath...

Voluntary Petitions for Termination of Parental Rights Do Not Supplant Involuntary County Petitions: Minnesota Supreme Court Clarifies

Date: Jul 16, 2020

Voluntary Petitions for Termination of Parental Rights Do Not Supplant Involuntary County Petitions: Minnesota Supreme Court Clarifies Introduction The Minnesota Supreme Court's decision in In re the...

Reaffirming the Necessity of 'Reasonable Probability' in Strickland's Second Prong: Peltier v. State of Minnesota

Date: Jul 16, 2020

Reaffirming the Necessity of 'Reasonable Probability' in Strickland's Second Prong: Peltier v. State of Minnesota Introduction Amanda Lea Peltier v. State of Minnesota, 946 N.W.2d 369 (Minn. 2020),...

Defining the Threshold for Criminal Attempt in Sexual Offenses: State v. Wilkie

Date: Jul 16, 2020

Defining the Threshold for Criminal Attempt in Sexual Offenses: State v. Wilkie Introduction State of Minnesota v. Brian James Wilkie, 946 N.W.2d 348 (Minn. 2020), is a pivotal case that elucidates...

State of Minnesota v. Ezeka: Establishing the 14-Day Rule for Counsel Invocation and Implications for Post-Miranda Statements

Date: Jul 16, 2020

State of Minnesota v. Ezeka: Establishing the 14-Day Rule for Counsel Invocation and Implications for Post-Miranda Statements Introduction The case of State of Minnesota v. Joshua Chiazor Ezeka (946...

Adjudicated Juvenile Felonies Recognized as "Crimes of Violence" Under Minnesota Law

Date: Jul 9, 2020

Adjudicated Juvenile Felonies Recognized as "Crimes of Violence" Under Minnesota Law Introduction In the landmark case of Dennis Charles Roberts, Appellant, v. State of Minnesota, Respondent (945...

Indefinite Suspension of Attorney Ignatius Chukwuemeka Udeani for Systematic Misconduct

Date: Jul 2, 2020

Indefinite Suspension of Attorney Ignatius Chukwuemeka Udeani for Systematic Misconduct Introduction The case of In re Petition for Disciplinary Action Against Ignatius Chukwuemeka Udeani (945 N.W.2d...

Esther Schmalz v. Commissioner of Minnesota Department of Human Services: Clarifying Asset Assessment in MA-LTC Eligibility

Date: Jun 25, 2020

Esther Schmalz v. Commissioner of Minnesota Department of Human Services: Clarifying Asset Assessment in MA-LTC Eligibility Introduction The case of In re the Matter of: Esther Schmalz and the...

Assata Kenneh v. Homeward Bound, Inc.: Upholding the 'Severe-or-Pervasive' Standard in Sexual Harassment Claims

Date: Jun 4, 2020

Assata Kenneh v. Homeward Bound, Inc.: Upholding the 'Severe-or-Pervasive' Standard in Sexual Harassment Claims Introduction The case of Assata Kenneh v. Homeward Bound, Inc. serves as a pivotal...

Implicit Waiver of Miranda Rights and Application of Minnesota Statute 609.04 in State v. Balandin

Date: Jun 4, 2020

Implicit Waiver of Miranda Rights and Application of Minnesota Statute 609.04 in State v. Balandin Introduction State of Minnesota v. Sergey Nikolae Balandin, 944 N.W.2d 204, was adjudicated by the...

Minnesota Supreme Court Establishes Reasonable Suspicion Requirement for Hotel Guest Registry Searches

Date: May 14, 2020

Minnesota Supreme Court Establishes Reasonable Suspicion Requirement for Hotel Guest Registry Searches Introduction In the landmark case of State of Minnesota v. John Thomas Leonard, the Minnesota...

Expanding Administrative Authority: Minnesota Supreme Court Upholds Commissioner’s Power to Rename Lakes Beyond 40-Year Limit

Date: May 14, 2020

Expanding Administrative Authority: Minnesota Supreme Court Upholds Commissioner’s Power to Rename Lakes Beyond 40-Year Limit Introduction The Minnesota Supreme Court, in the landmark decision of Sa...