Kentucky Case Commentaries

Voluntary Intoxication and Directed Verdicts: Intent and “True Threats” May Be Inferred from Conduct and Context During Resistance to Arrest (Oakley v. Commonwealth)

Date: Apr 24, 2026

Voluntary Intoxication and Directed Verdicts: Intent and “True Threats” May Be Inferred from Conduct and Context During Resistance to Arrest (Oakley v. Commonwealth) Publication status: The Supreme...

When the Victim’s State of Mind Is Not “At Issue”: Limiting Uncommunicated Threats, Admitting Prior DV to Rebut “Crossfire,” and Permitting Foreseeable Expert Nuance

Date: Apr 24, 2026

When the Victim’s State of Mind Is Not “At Issue”: Limiting Uncommunicated Threats, Admitting Prior DV to Rebut “Crossfire,” and Permitting Foreseeable Expert Nuance Introduction In Christopher...

Kentucky Rejects Derivative Sovereign Immunity for Highway Design Consultants; “Mandated Design” and Federal Standards Do Not Bar Parallel Negligence Claims

Date: Apr 24, 2026

Kentucky Rejects Derivative Sovereign Immunity for Highway Design Consultants; “Mandated Design” and Federal Standards Do Not Bar Parallel Negligence Claims I. Introduction In Hdr Engineering, Inc....

Kentucky Rejects Automatic Immunity and Broad Federal Preemption for Highway Design Consultants

Date: Apr 24, 2026

Kentucky Rejects Automatic Immunity and Broad Federal Preemption for Highway Design Consultants Case: HMB Professional Engineers, Inc. v. Kristina L. Ives, Individually (consolidated appeals) Court:...

Joinder of Separately Committed Child-Sex Offenses in a Single Household; KRE 412 “Demonstrably False” Gatekeeping for Prior-Accusation Impeachment; No Confrontation Violation from Witness Seating

Date: Apr 24, 2026

Joinder of Separately Committed Child-Sex Offenses in a Single Household; KRE 412 “Demonstrably False” Gatekeeping for Prior-Accusation Impeachment; No Confrontation Violation from Witness Seating...

Hybrid Counsel Limits: Closing Argument Cannot Substitute for Testimony; Separate Victim Counts for Promoting a Sexual Performance by a Minor

Date: Apr 24, 2026

Hybrid Counsel Limits: Closing Argument Cannot Substitute for Testimony; Separate Victim Counts for Promoting a Sexual Performance by a Minor Introduction In John Taylor v. Commonwealth of Kentucky,...

Workers’ Compensation Fee Appeals After Mahl: KRS 342.320 Counsel Must Be Joined, but Nonjoinder Is Not Automatically Jurisdictional

Date: Apr 24, 2026

Workers’ Compensation Fee Appeals After Mahl: KRS 342.320 Counsel Must Be Joined, but Nonjoinder Is Not Automatically Jurisdictional Introduction In Kelly Porter v. Axelon, Inc. (Ky. Apr. 23, 2026)...

Kendra Russell v. International Automotive Components — Three-Multiplier Requires Specific Findings Linking Work Injury to Inability to Perform Pre-Injury Job

Date: Apr 24, 2026

Three-Multiplier Requires Specific Findings Linking Work Injury to Inability to Perform Pre-Injury Job (KRS 342.730(1)(c)1); Board May Vacate and Remand When ALJ’s Explanation Lacks Record Support 1....

Kentucky ORA “Custody-and-Status” Rule: Volunteer Commission Members’ Private Emails/Texts Are Not Public Records Absent Public-Agency Custody

Date: Apr 24, 2026

Kentucky ORA “Custody-and-Status” Rule: Volunteer Commission Members’ Private Emails/Texts Are Not Public Records Absent Public-Agency Custody Case: Kentucky Open Government Coalition, Inc. v....

Palpable-Error Reversal for Moss “Liar-or-Truth-Teller” Cross-Examination in a Credibility-Dependent Controlled-Buy Case

Date: Apr 24, 2026

Palpable-Error Reversal for Moss “Liar-or-Truth-Teller” Cross-Examination in a Credibility-Dependent Controlled-Buy Case I. Introduction In Paul Jones v. Commonwealth of Kentucky (Ky. Apr. 23, 2026),...

Richard Tower v. Commonwealth of Kentucky — No “Per Se” Conflict or Plea Withdrawal Where Coercion Claims Target the Mediator/Prosecutor, Not Defense Counsel

Date: Apr 24, 2026

No “Per Se” Conflict or Plea Withdrawal Where Coercion Claims Target the Mediator/Prosecutor, Not Defense Counsel Introduction In Richard Tower v. Commonwealth of Kentucky (Ky. Apr. 23, 2026) (Not to...

Kentucky Whistleblower Act Retaliation Requires a “Materially Adverse” Employment Action (KCRA/Burlington Standard Adopted)

Date: Apr 24, 2026

Kentucky Whistleblower Act Retaliation Requires a “Materially Adverse” Employment Action (KCRA/Burlington Standard Adopted) 1. Introduction In Sgt. Kevin Burton; Lt. Frank Chad Taylor; and Sgt. Mike...

Highway Design Consultants Are Not Cloaked with the Commonwealth’s Immunity; “Mandated Design” Is a Fact Question; FHWA/AASHTO Standards Do Not Preempt Parallel Kentucky Negligence Claims

Date: Apr 24, 2026

Highway Design Consultants Are Not Cloaked with the Commonwealth’s Immunity; “Mandated Design” Is a Fact Question; FHWA/AASHTO Standards Do Not Preempt Parallel Kentucky Negligence Claims...

Supervisory Writ Voids Judicial Impeachment Based on Case Rulings: Verified-Petition Compliance, Separation of Powers, and Due Process Limits

Date: Apr 8, 2026

Supervisory Writ Voids Judicial Impeachment Based on Case Rulings: Verified-Petition Compliance, Separation of Powers, and Due Process Limits Introduction In Julie Muth Goodman v. Jason Nemes, in His...

Supervisory-Writ Limits on Legislative Impeachment of Sitting Judges for Judicial Rulings

Date: Apr 8, 2026

Supervisory-Writ Limits on Legislative Impeachment of Sitting Judges for Judicial Rulings Commentary on Julie Muth Goodman v. Jason Nemes, in His Official Capacity as Chair of the House of...

Waiver by Affirmative Approval of Jury Instructions and Limits on Speculative Digital-Extraction Challenges

Date: Mar 21, 2026

Waiver by Affirmative Approval of Jury Instructions and Limits on Speculative Digital-Extraction Challenges (Hatfield v. Commonwealth) Introduction In Ryan Hatfield v. Commonwealth of Kentucky, the...

Hall v. Commonwealth: Defendant Bears Burden to Disqualify Entire Prosecutor’s Office When Former Defense Counsel Joins That Office; Broad Admissibility of Crime-Context Evidence in Penalty-Phase-Only Trials

Date: Mar 21, 2026

Hall v. Commonwealth: Defendant Bears Burden to Disqualify Entire Prosecutor’s Office When Former Defense Counsel Joins That Office; Broad Admissibility of Crime-Context Evidence in...

Combined Penalty-Phase Misinstructions on Offense Class and Maximum Sentence Constitute Palpable Error Requiring Resentencing

Date: Mar 21, 2026

Combined Penalty-Phase Misinstructions on Offense Class and Maximum Sentence Constitute Palpable Error Requiring Resentencing Case: Christopher T. Thrasher v. Commonwealth of Kentucky Court: Supreme...

When the Defense Calls the KCPC Competency Evaluator: No Conley “Wall” Violation from Wide-Open Cross on Criminal Responsibility; Surprise Expert Diagnosis Changes Permit Exclusion

Date: Mar 21, 2026

When the Defense Calls the KCPC Competency Evaluator: No Conley “Wall” Violation from Wide-Open Cross on Criminal Responsibility; Surprise Expert Diagnosis Changes Permit Exclusion I. Introduction In...

Mandamus Unavailable to Compel Privilege Ruling or Disqualify Counsel After Inadvertent Disclosure When Ordinary Evidentiary Remedies Exist

Date: Mar 21, 2026

Mandamus Unavailable to Compel Privilege Ruling or Disqualify Counsel After Inadvertent Disclosure When Ordinary Evidentiary Remedies Exist Case: City of Prospect, Kentucky v. Ann Bailey Smith (Ky....