Kentucky Case Commentaries

Corroborated Firsthand Tips and Descriptive Particularity Can Sustain a Search Warrant Despite Informant-Label and Address Challenges

Date: Oct 24, 2026

Corroborated Firsthand Tips and Descriptive Particularity Can Sustain a Search Warrant Despite Informant-Label and Address Challenges Case: Terry Gonterman v. Commonwealth of Kentucky Court: Supreme...

Repeated Client Abandonment and Retention of Unearned Fees Support a One-Year Suspension with Reinstatement Conditions

Date: Sep 27, 2026

Repeated Client Abandonment and Retention of Unearned Fees Support a One-Year Suspension with Reinstatement Conditions Case: In Re: Jon Rhyan Fritz Court: Supreme Court of Kentucky Date: September...

Knowing Video-Recorded Assent Is an Electronic Signature Satisfying Kentucky’s Statute of Frauds

Date: Sep 26, 2026

Knowing Video-Recorded Assent Is an Electronic Signature Satisfying Kentucky’s Statute of Frauds Case: Jacob Dotson v. CIA Drug, LLC Court: Supreme Court of Kentucky Date: September 24, 2026...

Alcohol Use Does Not Bar Kentucky Workers’ Compensation Under KRS 342.610(4)

Date: Sep 26, 2026

Alcohol Use Does Not Bar Kentucky Workers’ Compensation Under KRS 342.610(4), and a Safety Reduction Requires Proof of Hazardous Conduct Case: Safe Zone v. Donnell Perry Court: Supreme Court of...

A Police Officer’s Plain Reading of a Cellebrite Report Is Lay Testimony and Requires No Digital-Forensics Expert Qualification

Date: Sep 26, 2026

A Police Officer’s Plain Reading of a Cellebrite Report Is Lay Testimony and Requires No Digital-Forensics Expert Qualification Case: Sylvanus Joseph McBride v. Commonwealth of Kentucky Court:...

Compliance Does Not Moot a Stay Request When Effective Relief Remains Available, but Speculative Harm Cannot Justify a Stay

Date: Sep 26, 2026

Compliance Does Not Moot a Stay Request When Effective Relief Remains Available, but Speculative Harm Cannot Justify a Stay Case: Commonwealth of Kentucky Ex Rel. Attorney General Russell Coleman v....

Ignoring Discovery Orders, Misleading a Client and Tribunal, and Defaulting in Bar Discipline Warrants a 181-Day Suspension

Date: Sep 26, 2026

Ignoring Discovery Orders, Misleading a Client and Tribunal, and Defaulting in Bar Discipline Warrants a 181-Day Suspension Case: In Re: Jay Michael Dade Court: Supreme Court of Kentucky Date:...

Kidnapping Sufficiency Is Measured Against Statutory Intent Alternatives, Not Narrower Jury Instructions

Date: Sep 26, 2026

Kidnapping Sufficiency Is Measured Against Statutory Intent Alternatives, Not Narrower Jury Instructions Case: Tristan Mitchell v. Commonwealth of Kentucky Court: Supreme Court of Kentucky Date:...

Post-Judgment Finality and Satisfaction Do Not Divest a Kentucky Circuit Court of Subject-Matter Jurisdiction

Date: Sep 26, 2026

Post-Judgment Finality and Satisfaction Do Not Divest a Kentucky Circuit Court of Subject-Matter Jurisdiction Case: Shawn Huffman v. JHPDE Finance I, LLC Court: Supreme Court of Kentucky Date:...

Undisclosed Defendant Statements Do Not Require a Mistrial Absent a Reasonable Probability of a Different Result

Date: Sep 26, 2026

Undisclosed Defendant Statements Do Not Require a Mistrial Absent a Reasonable Probability of a Different Result Case: Tyler Austin Jordan v. Commonwealth of Kentucky Court: Supreme Court of Kentucky...

Mandamus Cannot Compel Advisory Clarification of an Injunction to Influence a Governor’s Death-Warrant Decision

Date: Sep 25, 2026

Mandamus Cannot Compel Advisory Clarification of an Injunction to Influence a Governor’s Death-Warrant Decision Case: Commonwealth of Kentucky v. Hon. Phillip J. Shepherd Court: Supreme Court of...

Concrete Proof Is Required to Pierce Kentucky’s Rape Shield, and County Venue Objections Must Be Raised Before Trial

Date: Sep 25, 2026

Concrete Proof Is Required to Pierce Kentucky’s Rape Shield, and County Venue Objections Must Be Raised Before Trial Case: Steven Minton v. Commonwealth of Kentucky Court: Supreme Court of Kentucky...

A Testifying DNA Analyst May Interpret Non-Testimonial Raw Laboratory Data Without Calling Every Testing Technician

Date: Sep 25, 2026

A Testifying DNA Analyst May Interpret Non-Testimonial Raw Laboratory Data Without Calling Every Testing Technician Case: Timothy McQueary v. Commonwealth of Kentucky Court: Supreme Court of Kentucky...

Asking a Captured Suspect Why He Fled Constitutes Miranda Interrogation, but Erroneous Admission May Be Harmless

Date: Sep 25, 2026

Asking a Captured Suspect Why He Fled Constitutes Miranda Interrogation, but Erroneous Admission May Be Harmless Case: Cruz Frescas v. Commonwealth of Kentucky Court: Supreme Court of Kentucky Date:...

Wantonly Creating an Emergency Bars a Choice-of-Evils Defense to Wanton Criminal Mischief

Date: Sep 25, 2026

Wantonly Creating an Emergency Bars a Choice-of-Evils Defense to Wanton Criminal Mischief Case: Mark West v. Commonwealth of Kentucky Court: Supreme Court of Kentucky Date: September 24, 2026...

Supervised Practice May Establish Fitness for Conditional Attorney Reinstatement

Date: Sep 25, 2026

Supervised Practice May Establish Fitness for Conditional Attorney Reinstatement Case: In Re: Allison Coffeen Mohon Court: Supreme Court of Kentucky Date: September 24, 2026 Decision: Conditional...

Intentional Assistance in Leading or Restraining a Victim Supports Complicity to First-Degree Sodomy

Date: Sep 25, 2026

Intentional Assistance in Leading or Restraining a Victim Supports Complicity to First-Degree Sodomy Case: Demaurion Moore v. Commonwealth of Kentucky Court: Supreme Court of Kentucky Date: September...

Kentucky’s Structural Accountability Rule: The General Assembly May Not Fragment Executive Appointments to Dissolve Gubernatorial Supervision (HB 334 & HB 518)

Date: Jun 30, 2026

Kentucky’s Structural Accountability Rule: The General Assembly May Not Fragment Executive Appointments to Dissolve Gubernatorial Supervision (HB 334 & HB 518) Case: Andy Beshear, in His Official...

Specialty-Specific Standard-of-Care Proof Is Mandatory; Res Ipsa in Retained-Object Cases Requires Control Over the Retention-Causing Decision

Date: Jun 30, 2026

Specialty-Specific Standard-of-Care Proof Is Mandatory; Res Ipsa in Retained-Object Cases Requires Control Over the Retention-Causing Decision I. Introduction This published decision of the Supreme...

Post-Deadline CLE Compliance and Failure to Update Bar Roster Contact Information Do Not Constitute “Good Cause” to Revoke an SCR 3.675 Suspension

Date: Jun 30, 2026

Post-Deadline CLE Compliance and Failure to Update Bar Roster Contact Information Do Not Constitute “Good Cause” to Revoke an SCR 3.675 Suspension 1. Introduction Case: In Re: Charles Frederick...