Idaho Case Commentaries

Bell v. State: Idaho Supreme Court Clarifies Preservation Requirements and Specificity Standards for Incorporating Claims in Amended Post-Conviction Petitions

Date: Jul 15, 2025

Bell v. State: Idaho Supreme Court Clarifies Preservation Requirements and Specificity Standards for Incorporating Claims in Amended Post-Conviction Petitions 1. Introduction Bell v. State, 52104...

“Jurisdiction vs. Remedy”: Idaho Supreme Court Affirms Its Authority to Hear Appeals from Void Intermediate Decisions – Comment on State v. Moore (2025)

Date: Jul 15, 2025

“Jurisdiction vs. Remedy”: Idaho Supreme Court Affirms Its Authority to Hear Appeals from Void Intermediate Decisions – Comment on State v. Moore (2025) Introduction State v. Moore, decided by the...

“Solicitation Requires an Overt Act” – A Comprehensive Commentary on Insure Idaho v. Horn (Idaho 2025)

Date: Jul 13, 2025

“Solicitation Requires an Overt Act” Idaho Supreme Court Clarifies Enforcement of Non-Solicitation Covenants, Preliminary Injunction Standards, and Contempt Procedure (Insure Idaho, LLC v. Horn, 173...

Expanding the Idaho Attorney General’s Investigatory Reach: The “Reason-to-Believe” Standard and Charitable-Asset Oversight after Children’s Home Society v. Labrador (Idaho 2025)

Date: Jul 13, 2025

Expanding the Idaho Attorney General’s Investigatory Reach: The “Reason-to-Believe” Standard and Charitable-Asset Oversight after Children’s Home Society v. Labrador (Idaho 2025) Introduction The...

“Amount Paid on Redemption” Includes Interest & Late Charges: East Side Highway District v. Kootenai County (2025)

Date: Jul 13, 2025

“Amount Paid on Redemption” Includes Interest & Late Charges: East Side Highway District v. Kootenai County (Idaho 2025) 1. Introduction In East Side Highway District v. Kootenai County, the Idaho...

“Effective Upon the Date of Application” – The Idaho Supreme Court Establishes Retroactive Homestead Exemption & Affirms Broad Enforcement Powers of the State Tax Commission

Date: Jul 10, 2025

“Effective Upon the Date of Application” Retroactive Homestead Exemption & Broad Enforcement Authority of the Idaho State Tax Commission (Latah County v. Idaho State Tax Commission, 2025) 1....

“Sole-Discretion Easement Termination” Doctrine Established in Radford v. Van Orden (Idaho 2025)

Date: Jul 4, 2025

“Sole-Discretion Easement Termination” Doctrine Comprehensive Commentary on Radford v. Van Orden, Supreme Court of Idaho (2025) 1. Introduction Parties. Mark Radford and his entity, Hallo Properties,...

State v. Crist – Idaho Supreme Court Confirms Judicial Authority to Decide “Substantial Equivalency” Under SORA

Date: Jul 4, 2025

“We Do, the Bureau May”: State v. Crist and the Court-Centric Rule for Determining Substantial Equivalency Under Idaho’s Sex Offender Registration Act Introduction State v. Crist, 50737 (Idaho July 1...

“Meaningful Review Revisited” – South Hill Meat Lockers Inc. v. Idaho Transportation Department (Idaho 2025)

Date: Jul 4, 2025

Meaningful Review Revisited: Idaho Supreme Court Narrows “Plan-or-Design Immunity” to Government Plans & Change Orders that Receive Actual, Documented Scrutiny South Hill Meat Lockers Inc. v. Idaho...

“Any Means Any”: Idaho Code § 49-456 Applies to All Vehicles Driven in Idaho — An In-Depth Commentary on State v. Sherwood (2025)

Date: Jul 4, 2025

“Any Means Any”: Idaho Code § 49-456 Applies to All Vehicles Driven in Idaho — A Comprehensive Commentary on State v. Sherwood (Idaho 2025) 1. Introduction Background. In State v. Sherwood, the Idaho...

State v. Fletcher: Idaho Supreme Court Declares Drug-Dog “Free-Air” Sniffs Non-Searches and Re-Affirms the Bright-Line Automobile Exception

Date: Jul 4, 2025

State v. Fletcher: Idaho Supreme Court Declares Drug-Dog “Free-Air” Sniffs Non-Searches Under Article I § 17 and Re-Affirms the Bright-Line Automobile Exception 1. Introduction State v. Fletcher,...

State v. Popp: Narrowing “Reasonable Suspicion” When the Predicate Offense is Littering under Idaho Code § 18-7031

Date: Jul 4, 2025

State v. Popp (2025): Narrowing “Reasonable Suspicion” When the Predicate Offense is Littering under Idaho Code § 18-7031 1. Introduction State v. Popp is the Idaho Supreme Court’s most recent...

“Beyond the Fine Print” – Idaho’s Supreme Court Confirms Broad Judicial Enforcement of Recreational Liability Waivers in Vaughan v. Gateway Parks, LLC (2025)

Date: Jun 27, 2025

“Beyond the Fine Print” – Idaho’s Supreme Court Confirms Broad Judicial Enforcement of Recreational Liability Waivers in Vaughan v. Gateway Parks, LLC (2025) 1. Introduction The Idaho Supreme Court’s...

Affirming Judicial Gate-Keeping: The Idaho Supreme Court Clarifies Standards for Vexatious-Litigant Prefiling Orders under ICAR 59

Date: Jun 27, 2025

Affirming Judicial Gate-Keeping: The Idaho Supreme Court Clarifies Standards for Vexatious-Litigant Prefiling Orders under ICAR 59 Introduction Smith v. Hippler, docket no. 51412-2023, is the Idaho...

State v. Best – Idaho Supreme Court Narrows the “Sufficiency-of-the-Evidence” Exception to Issue Preservation in Suppression Appeals

Date: Jun 27, 2025

State v. Best – Idaho Supreme Court Narrows the “Sufficiency-of-the-Evidence” Exception to Issue Preservation in Suppression Appeals Introduction In State v. Best, the Idaho Supreme Court confronted...

Ramlow v. Mitchell: Idaho Supreme Court Confirms Broad Trial-Court Discretion to Dismiss Parallel Proceedings under I.R.C.P. 12(b)(8)

Date: Jun 27, 2025

Ramlow v. Mitchell: Idaho Supreme Court Confirms Broad Trial-Court Discretion to Dismiss Parallel Proceedings under I.R.C.P. 12(b)(8) Introduction In Ramlow v. Mitchell, the Idaho Supreme Court...

Milus v. Sun Valley Company: Clarifying the Standard of Care and the Assumption-of-Risk Bar under Idaho’s Ski Area Liability Act

Date: Jun 26, 2025

Milus v. Sun Valley Company: Clarifying the Standard of Care and the Assumption-of-Risk Bar under Idaho’s Ski Area Liability Act Introduction On 25 June 2025 the Idaho Supreme Court issued its...

Unrecorded, Yet Unquestionably Public: Jutila v. Shoshone County Clarifies Idaho’s Road-Creation Rules and the Scope of “Public-Interest” Validation

Date: Jun 26, 2025

Unrecorded, Yet Unquestionably Public: Jutila v. Shoshone County Clarifies Idaho’s Road-Creation Rules and the Scope of “Public-Interest” Validation Introduction In Jutila v. County of Shoshone, No....

The “Reasonable-Basis & Distinctiveness” Doctrine: Idaho Supreme Court Re-defines Fiscal Impact Statements and Ballot Title Duties in Idahoans United for Women and Families v. Labrador

Date: Jun 25, 2025

The “Reasonable-Basis & Distinctiveness” Doctrine: Idaho Supreme Court Re-defines Fiscal Impact Statements and Ballot Title Duties in Idahoans United for Women and Families v. Labrador (2025) 1....

“Every Means Every”: Idaho Code § 59-901(1)(e) Applies to All Elected Offices, Making Vacancies Automatic Upon Moving Outside the Electoral District

Date: Jun 24, 2025

“Every Means Every”: Idaho Code § 59-901(1)(e) Applies to All Elected Offices, Making Vacancies Automatic Upon Moving Outside the Electoral District 1. Introduction Case: Sanchez v. City of Boise,...