Idaho Case Commentaries

Finality of Guilty Pleas and Jurisdictional Boundaries: Insights from STATE v. JAKOSKI

Date: Oct 30, 2003

Finality of Guilty Pleas and Jurisdictional Boundaries: Insights from STATE v. JAKOSKI Introduction State of Idaho v. Benjamin Jakoski, 139 Idaho 352, is a landmark decision by the Supreme Court of...

Idaho Supreme Court Affirms First-Degree Murder Conviction Reinforcing 'Beyond a Reasonable Doubt' Standard

Date: Aug 5, 2003

Idaho Supreme Court Affirms First-Degree Murder Conviction Reinforcing 'Beyond a Reasonable Doubt' Standard Introduction The case of State of Idaho v. Billy G. Sheahan (139 Idaho 267) presents a...

Idaho Supreme Court Confirms Limited Public Policy Exception to At-Will Employment: Edmondson v. Shearer Lumber Products

Date: Jul 24, 2003

Idaho Supreme Court Confirms Limited Public Policy Exception to At-Will Employment: Edmondson v. Shearer Lumber Products Introduction In the landmark case of Michael J. Edmondson v. Shearer Lumber...

Reissuance of Search Warrants and Judicial Notice: State v. Nunez

Date: Apr 4, 2003

Reissuance of Search Warrants and Judicial Notice: State v. Nunez Introduction In the landmark case State of Idaho v. Ignacio Moro Nunez, 138 Idaho 636, the Supreme Court of Idaho addressed critical...

Restrictive Covenants Must Be Clear to Prohibit Short-Term Rentals: Insights from Idaho Supreme Court

Date: Feb 28, 2003

Restrictive Covenants Must Be Clear to Prohibit Short-Term Rentals: Insights from Idaho Supreme Court Introduction The case of Pinehaven Planning Board v. Thomas J. Brooks and Jennifer Brooks,...

Ineffective Assistance of Counsel in Post-Conviction Relief and Pretrial Conference Recording: Insights from Randall C. Goodwin v. State of Idaho

Date: Oct 30, 2002

Ineffective Assistance of Counsel in Post-Conviction Relief and Pretrial Conference Recording: Insights from Randall C. Goodwin v. State of Idaho Introduction Randall C. Goodwin v. State of Idaho is...

Idaho Supreme Court Clarifies Prescriptive Easement Rights and Contempt Proceedings in Camp v. East Fork Ditch Company

Date: Sep 12, 2002

Idaho Supreme Court Clarifies Prescriptive Easement Rights and Contempt Proceedings in Camp v. East Fork Ditch Company Introduction In the landmark case of Camp v. East Fork Ditch Company, the Idaho...

Idaho Supreme Court Dismisses Constitutional Challenge to Indian Gaming Initiative, Affirming Justiciability and Separation of Powers

Date: Aug 29, 2002

Idaho Supreme Court Dismisses Constitutional Challenge to Indian Gaming Initiative, Affirming Justiciability and Separation of Powers Introduction The case IN THE MATTER OF THE PETITION/ACTION TO...

Supreme Court of Idaho Reinforces Burden of Proof in Termination of Parental Rights

Date: Aug 14, 2002

Supreme Court of Idaho Reinforces Burden of Proof in Termination of Parental Rights Introduction In the landmark case John Doe v. State of Idaho, Department of Health and Welfare (137 Idaho 758), the...

Supreme Court of Idaho Affirms Implied-in-Fact Contract and Flow-Down Compensation in Fox v. Mountain West Electric

Date: Jun 7, 2002

Supreme Court of Idaho Affirms Implied-in-Fact Contract and Flow-Down Compensation in Fox v. Mountain West Electric Introduction Fox v. Mountain West Electric, Inc., 137 Idaho 703 (Supreme Court of...

Idaho Supreme Court Establishes Strict Interpretation of Duty to Defend in Insurance Policies

Date: Jun 7, 2002

Idaho Supreme Court Establishes Strict Interpretation of Duty to Defend in Insurance Policies Introduction The case of Richard W. Hoyle et al. v. Utica Mutual Insurance Company and Employers...

Idaho Supreme Court Invalidates City of Salmon's Attempt to Exchange Public Street

Date: Jan 18, 2002

Idaho Supreme Court Invalidates City of Salmon's Attempt to Exchange Public Street Introduction The case of Ray E. Infanger and Vera S. Infanger v. The City of Salmon et al. represents a significant...

Interpretation of Amended Contracts in Breach of Contract Cases: Opportunity v. Ossewarde

Date: Jan 5, 2002

Interpretation of Amended Contracts in Breach of Contract Cases: Opportunity v. Ossewarde Introduction The case of Opportunity, L.L.C. v. Fred and Joanne Ossewarde is a significant judicial decision...

Affirmation of Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Standards in Post-Conviction Relief for Lewd Conduct Cases

Date: Aug 7, 2001

Affirmation of Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Standards in Post-Conviction Relief for Lewd Conduct Cases Introduction The case of State of Idaho v. Creston G. Downing (136 Idaho 367) serves as a...

Clarifying Fee Simple Conveyance in Railroad Deeds: Supreme Court of Idaho Affirms Fee Simple Interpretation over 'Right of Way' Language

Date: May 3, 2001

Clarifying Fee Simple Conveyance in Railroad Deeds: Supreme Court of Idaho Affirms Fee Simple Interpretation over 'Right of Way' Language Introduction The case of C G, Inc., and Martin C. Galvin vs....

Affirmation of Aggravated Assault Conviction in State v. Daniels Establishes Clear Standards for Intent and Ability

Date: Sep 28, 2000

Affirmation of Aggravated Assault Conviction in State of Idaho v. Shawn D. Daniels Establishes Clear Standards for Intent and Ability Introduction In the pivotal case of State of Idaho v. Shawn D....

Fixed Life Sentencing in Second Degree Murder: Analysis of State of Idaho v. Jason Burdett

Date: Mar 9, 2000

Fixed Life Sentencing in Second Degree Murder: Analysis of State of Idaho v. Jason Burdett Introduction The case State of Idaho v. Jason Burdett, adjudicated in the Court of Appeals of Idaho in 2000,...

Idaho Supreme Court Upholds Heroin Possession Conviction Without Usable Quantity Requirement

Date: Sep 29, 1999

Idaho Supreme Court Upholds Heroin Possession Conviction Without Usable Quantity Requirement Introduction In the landmark case State of Idaho v. Sasha K. Rhode, 133 Idaho 459 (1999), the Supreme...

Enforcement of Share Transfer Agreements: Idaho Supreme Court Sets New Precedent

Date: Sep 23, 1999

Enforcement of Share Transfer Agreements: Idaho Supreme Court Sets New Precedent Introduction The case of August V. Klaue v. Alan Hern addresses critical issues surrounding the enforcement of...

Idaho Supreme Court Clarifies Dram Shop Act and Duty of Care Obligations for Universities and Sororities

Date: Aug 31, 1999

Idaho Supreme Court Clarifies Dram Shop Act and Duty of Care Obligations for Universities and Sororities Introduction The case of Rejena Coghlan et al. v. Beta Theta Pi Fraternity et al. brought...