Idaho Case Commentaries

Idaho Court of Appeals Establishes Procedural Bar on Cruel and Unusual Punishment Claims in Post-Conviction Relief

Date: Aug 1, 2007

Idaho Court of Appeals Establishes Procedural Bar on Cruel and Unusual Punishment Claims in Post-Conviction Relief Introduction In Da v. d KNUTSEN, the Court of Appeals of Idaho revisited the...

Fraud Negates Good Faith in Restitution Claims under Idaho's Betterment Statutes - Bach v. Miller

Date: May 11, 2007

Fraud Negates Good Faith in Restitution Claims under Idaho's Betterment Statutes - Bach v. Miller Introduction The case of John N. Bach v. Katherine D. Miller addresses critical issues surrounding...

Stolle v. Bennett: Upholding Procedural Integrity and Burden of Proof in Idaho Worker’s Compensation Law

Date: Mar 29, 2007

Stolle v. Bennett: Upholding Procedural Integrity and Burden of Proof in Idaho Worker’s Compensation Law Introduction The case of Mary Jo Stolle versus Christine Bennett revolves around a worker's...

Application of Res Judicata in Bankruptcy Proceedings: Ticor Title Company v. Richard W. Stanion II

Date: Mar 22, 2007

Application of Res Judicata in Bankruptcy Proceedings: Ticor Title Company v. Richard W. Stanion II Introduction Ticor Title Company, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Richard W. Stanion II,...

Right to Counsel During Court-Ordered Psychosexual Evaluations: Estrada v. State of Idaho

Date: Jan 23, 2007

Right to Counsel During Court-Ordered Psychosexual Evaluations: Estrada v. State of Idaho Introduction Krispen Estrada v. State of Idaho is a landmark case adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Idaho...

Termination of Parental Rights in Best Interest of the Child: Idaho Supreme Court Establishes Critical Precedent

Date: Sep 30, 2006

Termination of Parental Rights in Best Interest of the Child: Idaho Supreme Court Establishes Critical Precedent Introduction The case of STATE of Idaho v. John Doe delves into the intricate balance...

Termination of Parental Rights in Doe v. State Establishes Rigorous Standards for Neglect

Date: Sep 26, 2006

Termination of Parental Rights in Doe v. State Establishes Rigorous Standards for Neglect Introduction In the Matter of Jane DOE and Others: Children Under Eighteen Years of Age. State of Idaho,...

Ensuring Just Cause in Abandonment Claims: Idaho Supreme Court's Reversal in Doe v. Roe

Date: Aug 17, 2006

Ensuring Just Cause in Abandonment Claims: Idaho Supreme Court's Reversal in Doe v. Roe Introduction The case of Jane Roe and John Roe v. John Doe (143 Idaho 188) adjudicated by the Supreme Court of...

Termination of Parental Rights Due to Neglect: Roe v. Doe Analysis

Date: Nov 24, 2005

Termination of Parental Rights Due to Neglect: Roe v. Doe Analysis Introduction The case of Roe v. Doe (142 Idaho 174, 2005) represents a significant judicial decision by the Supreme Court of Idaho...

Affirmation of Denial to Set Aside Default Judgments: Suitts v. Nix Establishes Strict Requirements for Rule 60(b) Relief

Date: Aug 5, 2005

Affirmation of Denial to Set Aside Default Judgments: Suitts v. Nix Establishes Strict Requirements for Rule 60(b) Relief Introduction Richard and Kathryn Suitts, Individuals, Plaintiffs-Respondents...

Reaffirmation of At-Will Employment Doctrine in Idaho: Jenkins v. Boise Cascade Corporation

Date: Feb 24, 2005

Reaffirmation of At-Will Employment Doctrine in Idaho: Jenkins v. Boise Cascade Corporation Introduction The case of Larry Jenkins and Susan Jenkins v. Boise Cascade Corporation, Pauline Irish, and...

Idaho Supreme Court Upholds Effective Assistance of Counsel and Clarifies Post-Conviction Relief Standards in DUNLAP v. STATE

Date: Feb 17, 2005

Idaho Supreme Court Upholds Effective Assistance of Counsel and Clarifies Post-Conviction Relief Standards in DUNLAP v. STATE Introduction DUNLAP v. STATE, 141 Idaho 50 (2005), is a pivotal case...

Reevaluation of Post-Conviction Relief Procedures: Charboneau v. State of Idaho

Date: Nov 24, 2004

Reevaluation of Post-Conviction Relief Procedures: Charboneau v. State of Idaho Introduction The case of Jaimi D. Charboneau v. State of Idaho presents a pivotal moment in Idaho's judicial handling...

Sufficiency of Charging Documents in Establishing Jurisdiction: State v. Jones

Date: Nov 11, 2004

Sufficiency of Charging Documents in Establishing Jurisdiction: State v. Jones Introduction State of Idaho, Plaintiff-Respondent, v. Benjamin Arlo Jones, Defendant-Appellant is a pivotal case decided...

Affirmation of Punitive Damages in Breach of Contract: Myers v. Workmen's Auto Insurance Company

Date: Jul 24, 2004

Affirmation of Punitive Damages in Breach of Contract: Myers v. Workmen's Auto Insurance Company Introduction The case of Jessica Myers v. Workmen's Auto Insurance Company serves as a pivotal...

Idaho Supreme Court Establishes Limits on Statutory Interpretation of School Disruption Laws

Date: May 26, 2004

Idaho Supreme Court Establishes Limits on Statutory Interpretation of School Disruption Laws Introduction The case of State of Idaho v. John Doe, adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Idaho in May...

Retention of Jurisdiction Despite Sentencing Delays: Insights from STATE of Idaho v. Rogers

Date: May 22, 2004

Retention of Jurisdiction Despite Sentencing Delays: Insights from STATE of Idaho v. Trever Lee Rogers Introduction STATE of Idaho v. Trever Lee Rogers (140 Idaho 223) is a significant judicial...

Idaho Supreme Court Upholds Denial of Franks Hearing in Drug Possession Case

Date: May 13, 2004

Idaho Supreme Court Upholds Denial of Franks Hearing in Drug Possession Case Introduction In State of Idaho v. Daniel Eugene Fisher (140 Idaho 365), the Idaho Supreme Court addressed critical...

Narrow Interpretation of Aggravating Factor I.C. § 19-2515(h)(9) in the Murder of a Peace Officer: State v. Yager

Date: Feb 12, 2004

Narrow Interpretation of Aggravating Factor I.C. § 19-2515(h)(9) in the Murder of a Peace Officer: State v. Yager Introduction In the case of State of Idaho v. Scott D. Yager (139 Idaho 680), the...

Idaho Appellate Court Clarifies Willful Infliction Standard in Felony Domestic Battery under I.C. § 18-918(3)

Date: Nov 27, 2003

Idaho Appellate Court Clarifies Willful Infliction Standard in Felony Domestic Battery under I.C. § 18-918(3) Introduction The case of State of Idaho v. Heraclio Reyes, Jr. (139 Idaho 502) represents...