Hawaii Case Commentaries

Advancing-the-Trust Test for Attorneys’ Fees: Hawaiʻi Supreme Court Requires Merits Determination and “Assistance to the Court” Showing Before Shifting Fees in Contested Trust Matters

Date: Sep 9, 2025

Advancing-the-Trust Test for Attorneys’ Fees: Hawaiʻi Supreme Court Requires Merits Determination and “Assistance to the Court” Showing Before Shifting Fees in Contested Trust Matters Case: In re:...

Hawai‘i Supreme Court Clarifies Condo Resale Disclosures: Managing Agents Must Provide Online Downloads at No Cost and Must Produce Resale-Specific Documents

Date: Sep 8, 2025

Hawai‘i Supreme Court Clarifies Condo Resale Disclosures: Managing Agents Must Provide Online Downloads at No Cost and Must Produce Resale-Specific Documents Introduction In Caven, Jr. v. Certified...

CZMA’s Statewide Reach Defines Environmental Due Process: Agencies Must Hold Contested Case Hearings Before Renewing Revocable Permits; Environmental Courts May Modify Permits on HRS § 91‑14 Review

Date: Sep 8, 2025

CZMA’s Statewide Reach Defines Environmental Due Process: Agencies Must Hold Contested Case Hearings Before Renewing Revocable Permits; Environmental Courts May Modify Permits on HRS § 91‑14 Review...

Hawaiʻi Supreme Court Reaffirms Non-Appealability of Orders Vacating Arbitration Awards with Rehearing; Clarifies Final-Judgment Protocols in Special Proceedings

Date: Sep 8, 2025

Reaffirming the Non-Appealability of Orders Vacating Arbitration Awards with Rehearing under HRS § 658A-28 and Mandating “In Aid of Jurisdiction” Remands for Final Judgments in Special Proceedings...

Cotenants’ Standing To Defend Absent Cotenants Against Adverse Possession, and Laches as a Bar to Century‑Old Land Court Claims: The Hawaiʻi Supreme Court’s Decision in In re Application of Pioneer Mill Co., Limited (2025)

Date: Sep 4, 2025

“Equity Aids the Vigilant”: Cotenants May Defend Absent Cotenants Against Adverse Possession, and Laches Bars a Century-Old Land Court Claim Introduction In a published opinion with far-reaching...

Preponderance Standard Governs LUC Boundary Interpretations; Declaratory Orders Limited to Resolving Map Uncertainty

Date: Sep 2, 2025

Preponderance Standard Governs LUC Boundary Interpretations; Declaratory Orders Limited to Resolving Map Uncertainty Introduction In Honoipu Hideaway, LLC v. State (Supreme Court of Hawaiʻi, August...

“Private Place” Need Not Be Defined in the Indictment; Courts May Consider Extrinsic Information to Assess Notice on Timely Challenges — State v. Kaakimaka (Haw. 2025)

Date: Sep 2, 2025

“Private Place” Need Not Be Defined in the Indictment; Courts May Consider Extrinsic Information to Assess Notice on Timely Challenges — State v. Kaakimaka (Haw. 2025) Introduction In State v....

When the Record Is Not Enough: Hawai‘i Supreme Court Requires an EA as a Matter of Law for HEPA Exemptions Not Supported on the Face of the Agency Record

Date: Aug 31, 2025

When the Record Is Not Enough: Hawai‘i Supreme Court Requires an EA as a Matter of Law for HEPA Exemptions Not Supported on the Face of the Agency Record Introduction In Ke Kauhulu O Mānā v. Board of...

Rodriguez v. Mauna Kea Resort LLC: The “Specific-Percentage” Disclosure Rule for Hawaiʻi Service Charges

Date: Aug 26, 2025

Rodriguez v. Mauna Kea Resort LLC: The New Requirement to State the Exact Portion of a Service Charge Paid as Tip Income Introduction Rodriguez v. Mauna Kea Resort LLC, 155 Haw. 223 (Haw. 2025),...

Hawaiʻi Supreme Court Clarifies Mandatory Director Indemnification and “Fees-on-Fees” Recovery: Loyalty Development Company, Ltd. v. Ching (2025)

Date: Aug 25, 2025

Hawaiʻi Supreme Court Clarifies Mandatory Director Indemnification and “Fees-on-Fees” Recovery Loyalty Development Company, Ltd. v. Ching, 154 Haw. 256 (2025) Introduction In Loyalty Development...

Cowan v. Exclusive Resorts: Contractual Attorney-Fee Clauses Override HRS § 607-14 in Assumpsit Actions

Date: Aug 19, 2025

Cowan v. Exclusive Resorts PBL1, LLC Supreme Court of Hawaiʻi, Opinion filed 14 August 2025 “Contract-Specific Fee Clauses Defeat Statutory Fees in Assumpsit” 1. Introduction Cowan v. Exclusive...

State v. Lavoie: Supreme Court of Hawaiʻi Restricts Expert-Fee Entitlements at Regular Sentencing and Adopts the “Aggregate” Test for HRS § 706-609 Resentencing Challenges

Date: Aug 15, 2025

State v. Lavoie: Supreme Court of Hawaiʻi Restricts Expert-Fee Entitlements at Regular Sentencing and Adopts the “Aggregate” Test for HRS § 706-609 Resentencing Challenges 1. Introduction In State v....

Hawaiʻi Supreme Court Clarifies a 20-Year Statute of Limitations for Mortgage Foreclosure Actions

Date: Aug 13, 2025

Hawaiʻi Supreme Court Clarifies a 20-Year Statute of Limitations for Mortgage Foreclosures Introduction In The Bank of New York Mellon v. White, SCWC-21-0000400 (Aug. 7 2025), the Hawaiʻi Supreme...

Beyond “Seal or Remove”: The Hawaiʻi Supreme Court Defines the Constitutional Limits of Record-Sealing under HRS § 831-3.2(f)

Date: Aug 6, 2025

Beyond “Seal or Remove”: The Hawaiʻi Supreme Court Defines the Constitutional Limits of Record-Sealing under HRS § 831-3.2(f) Introduction On 4 August 2025 the Supreme Court of Hawaiʻi issued a...

“Implied Dissolution of Litigation Stays upon Reinstatement Orders” — A Commentary on Greenspon v. CIT Bank, N.A., Supreme Court of Hawaiʻi (2025)

Date: Aug 1, 2025

“Implied Dissolution of Litigation Stays upon Reinstatement Orders” Greenspon v. CIT Bank, N.A. — Supreme Court of Hawaiʻi, 29 July 2025 Introduction Greenspon v. CIT Bank, N.A. concerns prolonged...

Expanding Due-Process Standing: Skilled Nursing Facilities Gain Direct Appeal Rights in Hawaiʻi Medicaid Eligibility Disputes

Date: Aug 1, 2025

Expanding Due-Process Standing: Skilled Nursing Facilities Gain Direct Appeal Rights in Hawaiʻi Medicaid Eligibility Disputes Introduction Case: In re FT, by and through Aloha Nursing Rehab Centre v....

Refining the Boundaries of Prosecutorial Misconduct: The “Reasonable-Inference” Rule & Contextual Review after State v. Willis (2025)

Date: Jul 23, 2025

Refining the Boundaries of Prosecutorial Misconduct: The “Reasonable-Inference” Rule & Contextual Review after State v. Willis (Haw. 2025) 1. Introduction Case: State of Hawaiʻi v. Erik Willis,...

“Beyond Aspirations: Restricting Attorney Discipline to Conduct Expressly Covered By the Hawaiʻi Rules of Professional Conduct”

Date: Jul 23, 2025

Beyond Aspirations: Restricting Attorney Discipline to Conduct Expressly Covered By the Hawaiʻi Rules of Professional Conduct Introduction In Office of Disciplinary Counsel v. Zenger, the Supreme...

Hawaiʻi Supreme Court Recasts Punitive-Damages Doctrine and Rejects “Kinship” Fiduciary Duty – A Commentary on Guieb v. Guieb (2025)

Date: Jul 7, 2025

Hawaiʻi Supreme Court Recasts Punitive-Damages Doctrine and Rejects “Kinship” Fiduciary Duty – A Commentary on Guieb v. Guieb (2025) 1. Introduction Guieb v. Guieb, SCWC-20-0000727 (July 1 2025), is...

Excess Credit as a Condition Precedent: Hawai‘i Supreme Court Limits RETITC Refundability Elections to Credits Exceeding Tax Liability

Date: Jul 1, 2025

Excess Credit as a Condition Precedent: Hawai‘i Supreme Court Limits RETITC Refundability Elections to Credits Exceeding Tax Liability Introduction In Suganuma v. Goodman, SCWC-24-0000229 (Haw. June...