Georgia Case Commentaries

Coston v. State: Surveillance Video as Direct Evidence and the Limited Reach of Georgia’s Circumstantial-Evidence Rule

Date: Jun 11, 2025

Coston v. State: Surveillance Video as Direct Evidence and the Limited Reach of Georgia’s Circumstantial-Evidence Rule Introduction On 10 June 2025 the Supreme Court of Georgia decided Coston v....

“No Toll for Minors”: The Supreme Court of Georgia Declares OCGA § 9-3-90(b) Inapplicable to Municipal Ante Litem Notices in Dates v. City of Atlanta

Date: Jun 11, 2025

“No Toll for Minors”: The Supreme Court of Georgia Declares OCGA § 9-3-90(b) Inapplicable to Municipal Ante Litem Notices in Dates v. City of Atlanta 1. Introduction In Dates v. City of Atlanta,...

“Direct Evidence Prevails & Assault-Merger Mandate” — Comment on Douglas v. State (Supreme Court of Georgia, 2025)

Date: Jun 11, 2025

“Direct Evidence Prevails & Assault-Merger Mandate” A Comprehensive Commentary on Douglas v. State, 315 Ga. ___ (2025) 1. Introduction On 10 June 2025 the Supreme Court of Georgia decided Douglas v....

Floyd v. State: Reinforcing Circumstantial-Evidence Sufficiency for Predicate Armed Robbery and Delineating Confrontation Clause Limits when a Co-Indictee Refuses to Testify

Date: Jun 11, 2025

Floyd v. State: Reinforcing Circumstantial-Evidence Sufficiency for Predicate Armed Robbery and Delineating Confrontation Clause Limits when a Co-Indictee Refuses to Testify Introduction Floyd v....

James v. State: Confrontation Clause Does Not Extend to a Defendant’s Own Witness Invoking the Fifth Amendment

Date: Jun 11, 2025

James v. State: Confrontation Clause Does Not Extend to a Defendant’s Own Witness Invoking the Fifth Amendment Introduction In James v. State, the Supreme Court of Georgia confronted two familiar...

Lewis v. State: The Supreme Court of Georgia Re-Affirms Jury Primacy in Self-Defense Determinations and Clarifies Abandonment of Unbriefed Ineffective-Assistance Claims

Date: Jun 11, 2025

Lewis v. State: The Supreme Court of Georgia Re-Affirms Jury Primacy in Self-Defense Determinations and Clarifies Abandonment of Unbriefed Ineffective-Assistance Claims Introduction In Lewis v. State...

“Back to First Principles” – The Georgia Supreme Court Re-Inscribes a Strict Non-Delegation Rule and Rejects Federal-Style Third-Party Standing

Date: Jun 11, 2025

“Back to First Principles” – The Georgia Supreme Court Re-Inscribes a Strict Non-Delegation Rule and Rejects Federal-Style Third-Party Standing 1. Introduction The consolidated appeals Republican...

Scott v. State: Clarifying the Admissibility of Unredacted Death Certificates under Georgia’s Post-2013 Evidence Code

Date: Jun 11, 2025

Scott v. State: Clarifying the Admissibility of Unredacted Death Certificates under Georgia’s Post-2013 Evidence Code 1. Introduction Scott v. State, __ Ga. __ (June 10, 2025), is a Supreme Court of...

From “Void” to “Voidable”: The Georgia Supreme Court Re-defines the Effect of an Ineligible Juror on Speedy-Trial Calculations — Commentary on State v. Embert (2025)

Date: Jun 11, 2025

From “Void” to “Voidable”: The Georgia Supreme Court Re-defines the Effect of an Ineligible Juror on Speedy-Trial Calculations — Commentary on State v. Embert (2025) 1. Introduction State v. Embert...

State v. Mickel: The Georgia Supreme Court Reinforces the Duty of Trial Courts to Enter Comprehensive Findings of Fact in Probable-Cause Suppression Rulings

Date: Jun 11, 2025

State v. Mickel: The Georgia Supreme Court Reinforces the Duty of Trial Courts to Enter Comprehensive Findings of Fact in Probable-Cause Suppression Rulings 1. Introduction State v. Mickel, S25A0255,...

Refining Confession Admissibility: Interpreting “Slightest Hope of Benefit” and “Remotest Fear of Injury” under OCGA § 24-8-824

Date: May 29, 2025

Refining Confession Admissibility: Interpreting “Slightest Hope of Benefit” and “Remotest Fear of Injury” under OCGA § 24-8-824 Introduction In Short v. State, decided May 28, 2025, the Supreme Court...

Exclusivity Requirement of Paragraph V: Suits for Declaratory Relief Must Be Brought Against the County Alone

Date: May 29, 2025

Exclusivity Requirement of Georgia Constitution Article I, Section II, Paragraph V: Declaratory Relief Actions Must Be Brought Exclusively Against the County Introduction In Tussahaw Reserves, LLC et...

Autonomy in Firearm Regulation Under Georgia’s Constitution: Upholding Paragraph VIII’s “Manner Clause”

Date: May 29, 2025

Autonomy in Firearm Regulation Under Georgia’s Constitution: Upholding Paragraph VIII’s “Manner Clause” 1. Introduction Stephens v. State of Georgia, decided May 28, 2025 by the Supreme Court of...

Establishment of One-Year Suspension Standard for Client Abandonment Under Georgia Professional Conduct Rules

Date: May 29, 2025

Establishment of One-Year Suspension Standard for Client Abandonment Under Georgia Professional Conduct Rules Introduction In In the Matter of Nathaniel Watson Cochran (Supreme Court of Georgia,...

Statutory Insanity Defenses Unaffected by Voluntary Induction of Mental State

Date: May 29, 2025

Statutory Insanity Defenses Unaffected by Voluntary Induction of Mental State Introduction State v. Wierson, decided May 28, 2025 by the Supreme Court of Georgia, clarifies the scope of Georgia’s two...

Malice Murder by Participation: Sufficiency of Evidence for Party Liability in Group Gunfights

Date: May 29, 2025

Malice Murder by Participation: Sufficiency of Evidence for Party Liability in Group Gunfights Introduction Sims v. State (S25A0058) and Glover v. State (S25A0150) were decided by the Supreme Court...

Pollard v. State: Prejudice Requirement for Ineffective Assistance in Admission of Non-Warranted Cell-Site Location Evidence

Date: May 29, 2025

Pollard v. State: Prejudice Requirement for Ineffective Assistance in Admission of Non-Warranted Cell-Site Location Evidence Introduction In Pollard v. State, 310 Ga. ___ (2025), the Supreme Court of...

Prejudice Requirement in Arbitration Vacatur: Influence on Outcome Standard

Date: May 29, 2025

Prejudice Requirement in Arbitration Vacatur: Influence on Outcome Standard Introduction This commentary examines the Supreme Court of Georgia’s decision in Docs of CT, LLC v. Biotek Services, LLC,...

Burden of Proof on Identity and Sufficiency of Circumstantial Evidence in Malice Murder Convictions

Date: May 29, 2025

Burden of Proof on Identity and Sufficiency of Circumstantial Evidence in Malice Murder Convictions Introduction Porter v. State, decided by the Supreme Court of Georgia on May 28, 2025, considered...

Clarification of Nexus Jury Instruction under Georgia’s Street Gang Act: Distinguishing Mandatory and Permissive Presumptions

Date: May 29, 2025

Clarification of Nexus Jury Instruction under Georgia’s Street Gang Act: Distinguishing Mandatory and Permissive Presumptions Introduction This commentary examines the Supreme Court of Georgia’s...