Georgia Case Commentaries

Speculative Conflicts Do Not Trigger Prosecutor Disqualification Under GRPC 1.9(a) Absent a “Substantially Related” Prior Representation

Date: Feb 5, 2026

Speculative Conflicts Do Not Trigger Prosecutor Disqualification Under GRPC 1.9(a) Absent a “Substantially Related” Prior Representation Introduction This consolidated Supreme Court of Georgia...

Condra Does Not Mandate a “Personal Practices” Jury Charge; Pattern Instructions Are Not Law and Trial Courts May Tailor Charges

Date: Feb 5, 2026

Condra Does Not Mandate a “Personal Practices” Jury Charge; Pattern Instructions Are Not Law and Trial Courts May Tailor Charges Introduction Georgia Bone & Joint Surgeons, P.C. v. Keel reached the...

Gibson v. State: “Conflict-Free Counsel” Requires an Articulated Actual Conflict; A Desire to Hire Private Counsel Is Not Enough

Date: Feb 5, 2026

Gibson v. State: “Conflict-Free Counsel” Requires an Articulated Actual Conflict; A Desire to Hire Private Counsel Is Not Enough Court: Supreme Court of Georgia Date: February 3, 2026 Case: Gibson v....

Graham v. State: No Ineffective Assistance for Omitting Additional Justification/Character Charges and for Declining a Novel Curtilage-Based Defense-of-Habitation Theory; Cumulative Error Requires Identified Trial Error

Date: Feb 5, 2026

Graham v. State: No Ineffective Assistance for Omitting Additional Justification/Character Charges and for Declining a Novel Curtilage-Based Defense-of-Habitation Theory; Cumulative Error Requires...

Kerns v. State — No Separate Right to Virtual Trial Access After Removal for Disruption; No Mandatory Hearing on Substitute-Counsel Requests Absent Adequate Record

Date: Feb 5, 2026

Kerns v. State — No Separate Right to Virtual Trial Access After Removal for Disruption; No Mandatory Hearing on Substitute-Counsel Requests Absent Adequate Record 1. Introduction In Kerns v. THE...

Riley v. State: No Brady/Giglio Violation Absent a Pretrial Leniency Agreement; Speculation About Cross-County Favor Is Insufficient

Date: Feb 5, 2026

Riley v. State: No Brady/Giglio Violation Absent a Pretrial Leniency Agreement; Speculation About Cross-County Favor Is Insufficient Court: Supreme Court of Georgia Date: February 3, 2026 Case: Riley...

Cell-Tower “Mapping” and Autonomous Surveillance Foundations: When Location-Tracking Summaries Are Lay Testimony and Timestamped Video Is Self-Authenticating Under OCGA § 24-9-923(c)

Date: Feb 5, 2026

Cell-Tower “Mapping” and Autonomous Surveillance Foundations: When Location-Tracking Summaries Are Lay Testimony and Timestamped Video Is Self-Authenticating Under OCGA § 24-9-923(c) I. Introduction...

State v. Lee: Clarifying “Why Am I Charged?” Questions Do Not Reinitiate Interrogation After Invocation; “Why Do You Think?” Follow-Ups Are Edwards-Prohibited Interrogation

Date: Feb 5, 2026

State v. Lee: Clarifying “Why Am I Charged?” Questions Do Not Reinitiate Interrogation After Invocation; “Why Do You Think?” Follow-Ups Are Edwards-Prohibited Interrogation I. Introduction State v....

Taylor v. State: Ineffective-Assistance Claims Must Identify Specific, Record-Supported Deficiencies; Appellate Courts Will Not Cull the Record

Date: Feb 5, 2026

Taylor v. State: Ineffective-Assistance Claims Must Identify Specific, Record-Supported Deficiencies; Appellate Courts Will Not Cull the Record Introduction In Taylor v. The State (Supreme Court of...

Georgia RICO Cannot Be Used to Transform a Post-Divorce Child-Support Dispute into a Treble-Damages Racketeering Case

Date: Feb 5, 2026

Georgia RICO Cannot Be Used to Transform a Post-Divorce Child-Support Dispute into a Treble-Damages Racketeering Case Introduction In WARNER v. ESPITIA et al., the Court of Appeals of Georgia...

Phillips v. State: Curative Instructions Cure Brief “Vouching,” and Recorded Interviews Are Not Admissible in Full Absent Proper Impeachment and Proffer

Date: Jan 23, 2026

Phillips v. State: Curative Instructions Cure Brief “Vouching,” and Recorded Interviews Are Not Admissible in Full Absent Proper Impeachment and Proffer I. Introduction In Phillips v. The State...

Speculation Is Not “New Evidence”: Due Diligence, Materiality, and Plain-Error Limits on Involuntary Intoxication Theories in Georgia

Date: Jan 22, 2026

Speculation Is Not “New Evidence”: Due Diligence, Materiality, and Plain-Error Limits on Involuntary Intoxication Theories in Georgia Case: Williams v. State (Supreme Court of Georgia) Date: January...

Burns v. State: Implicit Waiver After Counsel Request When Suspect Reinitiates; No Duty to Clarify Ambiguous Lawyer References

Date: Jan 22, 2026

Burns v. State: Implicit Waiver After Counsel Request When Suspect Reinitiates; No Duty to Clarify Ambiguous Lawyer References Introduction In Burns v. The State (S25A1487, decided January 21, 2026),...

Dickerson v. State (Ga. 2026): Requested Jury Instructions as Affirmative Waiver; Witness-Threat Evidence to Explain Reluctant Testimony

Date: Jan 22, 2026

Requested Jury Instructions Constitute Affirmative Waiver that Bars Plain-Error Review; Threat Evidence Unconnected to Defendant May Explain Witness Reluctance Case: Dickerson v. The State, S25A1365...

Franklin v. State — Ineffective Assistance and Cell-Phone Suppression Motions: Abandonment and No Duty to Anticipate Wilson

Date: Jan 22, 2026

Franklin v. State: No Ineffective Assistance for Failing to Seek Suppression of (1) an Abandoned Cell Phone and (2) a Pre‑Wilson “Evidence of Murder” iPhone Warrant 1. Introduction In Franklin v....

Privacy Is Not a Categorical Bar to Discovering Medical Records in Georgia HSV-Transmission Claims; Discovery Must Be Narrowly Tailored with Protective Orders

Date: Jan 22, 2026

Privacy Is Not a Categorical Bar to Discovering Medical Records in Georgia HSV-Transmission Claims; Discovery Must Be Narrowly Tailored with Protective Orders 1. Introduction Moulton v. Goodell...

Contingency Fees Cannot Attach to Routine Probate Distributions; Disputed Fees Must Remain in Trust—Conversion Warrants Disbarment

Date: Jan 22, 2026

Contingency Fees Cannot Attach to Routine Probate Distributions; Disputed Fees Must Remain in Trust—Conversion Warrants Disbarment 1. Introduction In the Matter of Nubiyn Matamalaki Mosi Mzekewe...

Georgia Supreme Court Rejects Public Reprimand for Rule 8.4(a)(8) Criminal-Act Misconduct Despite Pardon and Interim Suspension

Date: Jan 22, 2026

Georgia Supreme Court Rejects Public Reprimand for Rule 8.4(a)(8) Criminal-Act Misconduct Despite Pardon and Interim Suspension Case: In the Matter of W. McCall Calhoun, Jr. (S25Y1501) | Court:...

Opening Default in Georgia Attorney Discipline: OCGA § 9-11-55(b) Applies Liberally and Requires Case-Wide (Not Partial) Relief to Preserve Merits Review

Date: Jan 22, 2026

Opening Default in Georgia Attorney Discipline: OCGA § 9-11-55(b) Applies Liberally and Requires Case-Wide (Not Partial) Relief to Preserve Merits Review 1. Introduction In the Matter of Mylee...

Accurate-at-Trial Disclosure of a Witness Plea Deal Satisfies Brady/Giglio Despite Post‑Trial Plea Modification to Avoid a Potentially Illegal Sentence

Date: Jan 22, 2026

Accurate-at-Trial Disclosure of a Witness Plea Deal Satisfies Brady/Giglio Despite Post‑Trial Plea Modification to Avoid a Potentially Illegal Sentence Case: Wells v. State Court: Supreme Court of...