Florida Case Commentaries

Presumption of Authenticity for Court Official Signatures and the Florida Courts E-Filing Portal

Date: May 23, 2025

Presumption of Authenticity for Court Official Signatures and the Florida Courts E-Filing Portal Introduction In In Re: Amendments to Florida Rules of General Practice and Judicial Administration...

Unanimous First-Degree Verdicts and the CCP Aggravator: Florida Supreme Court Affirms

Date: May 23, 2025

Unanimous First-Degree Verdicts and the CCP Aggravator: Florida Supreme Court Affirms Introduction In Mark H. Wilson v. State of Florida, No. SC2023-0320 (Fla. May 22, 2025), the Florida Supreme...

Presumptive Suspension for Attorney Criminal Misconduct Involving Domestic Violence

Date: May 16, 2025

Presumptive Suspension for Attorney Criminal Misconduct Involving Domestic Violence Introduction This commentary examines the Florida Supreme Court’s decision in The Florida Bar v. Ryan F. C....

Upholding Procedural Bars and Rejecting As-Applied Execution Claims: Rogers v. State

Date: May 9, 2025

Upholding Procedural Bars and Rejecting As-Applied Execution Claims: Rogers v. State Introduction Glen Edward Rogers v. State of Florida (No. SC2025-0585) is a May 8, 2025 decision of the Supreme...

Rational Understanding Supersedes Delusional Beliefs: Clarifying Competency to be Executed

Date: May 1, 2025

Rational Understanding Supersedes Delusional Beliefs: Clarifying Competency to be Executed Introduction The Supreme Court of Florida’s decision in Jeffrey G. Hutchinson v. State of Florida (No....

The Hutchinson Standard for Florida Death-Warrant Litigation: No Due Process Violation in Shortened Review Periods and No Expansion of Eighth Amendment Protections

Date: Apr 26, 2025

The Hutchinson Standard for Florida Death-Warrant Litigation: No Due Process Violation in Shortened Review Periods and No Expansion of Eighth Amendment Protections Introduction Jeffrey G. Hutchinson...

Reaffirming Broad Executive Discretion and Strict Limits on Warrant-Period Litigation in Florida Capital Cases: Hutchinson v. State

Date: Apr 26, 2025

Reaffirming Broad Executive Discretion and Strict Limits on Warrant-Period Litigation in Florida Capital Cases: Hutchinson v. State Introduction In Jeffrey G. Hutchinson v. State of Florida and...

Mandatory Pretrial Detention for Dangerous Crimes: Amendment to Florida Rule of Criminal Procedure 3.132

Date: Apr 25, 2025

Mandatory Pretrial Detention for Dangerous Crimes: Amendment to Florida Rule of Criminal Procedure 3.132 Introduction This commentary examines the Supreme Court of Florida’s April 3, 2025, opinion in...

Enhanced Procedural Safeguards: Amendments to Florida Criminal Procedure Rules 3.220, 3.851 & 3.853

Date: Apr 11, 2025

Enhanced Procedural Safeguards: Amendments to Florida Criminal Procedure Rules 3.220, 3.851 & 3.853 Introduction On April 10, 2025, the Supreme Court of Florida, acting per curiam, adopted...

Recalibrating Pretrial Detention in Florida: Supreme Court Aligns Rule 3.132 with “Substantial Probability,” Bars Pre–First Appearance Release for Dangerous Crimes, and Authorizes Hearsay-Only Detention Orders

Date: Apr 4, 2025

Recalibrating Pretrial Detention in Florida: Supreme Court Aligns Rule 3.132 with “Substantial Probability,” Bars Pre–First Appearance Release for Dangerous Crimes, and Authorizes Hearsay-Only...

Tanzi v. Florida: Executive Discretion in Death-Warrant Scheduling and Procedural Limits on Postconviction Relief

Date: Apr 2, 2025

Tanzi v. Florida: Executive Discretion in Death-Warrant Scheduling and Procedural Limits on Postconviction Relief Introduction In Michael A. Tanzi v. State of Florida (consolidated with petitions...

Tanzi v. State: Affirmation of Due Process Limits and Postconviction Relief Procedures in Florida Capital Cases

Date: Apr 2, 2025

Tanzi v. State: Affirmation of Due Process Limits and Postconviction Relief Procedures in Florida Capital Cases Introduction Michael A. Tanzi was convicted of first-degree murder, carjacking,...

Erlinger Offers No Postconviction Lifeline in Florida Capital Cases: Florida Supreme Court Reaffirms Strict Limits on Warrant-Period Discovery, Method-of-Execution Claims, and All-Writs Relief in Tanzi

Date: Apr 2, 2025

Erlinger Offers No Postconviction Lifeline in Florida Capital Cases: Florida Supreme Court Reaffirms Strict Limits on Warrant-Period Discovery, Method-of-Execution Claims, and All-Writs Relief in...

Clarifying Rule 3.852(h)’s Scope and Erlinger’s Inapplicability on Postconviction: Tanzi v. State (Fla. 2025)

Date: Apr 2, 2025

Clarifying Rule 3.852(h)’s Scope and Erlinger’s Inapplicability on Postconviction: Tanzi v. State (Fla. 2025) Introduction In a per curiam decision issued April 1, 2025, the Florida Supreme Court...

Florida Supreme Court: No Certiorari Review of Anti‑SLAPP Denials; Interlocutory Appeals Authorized via Amended Rule 9.130

Date: Mar 28, 2025

Florida Supreme Court: No Certiorari Review of Anti‑SLAPP Denials; Interlocutory Appeals Authorized via Amended Rule 9.130 Case: Kevin Vericker v. Norman Christopher Powell Court: Supreme Court of...

“Pro Bono Is Not a Shield”: Florida Supreme Court Disbars Lawyer and Clarifies Disciplinary Aggravation/Mitigation, Social‑Media Prejudice, and No‑Contact Rules — The Florida Bar v. Malik Leigh

Date: Mar 21, 2025

“Pro Bono Is Not a Shield”: Florida Supreme Court Disbars Lawyer and Clarifies Disciplinary Aggravation/Mitigation, Social‑Media Prejudice, and No‑Contact Rules — The Florida Bar v. Malik Leigh...

Presumptive Authenticity of Judicial E‑Signatures and Mandatory Portal E‑Service: Florida’s 2025 Overhaul of Electronic Filing and Service Rules

Date: Mar 21, 2025

Presumptive Authenticity of Judicial E‑Signatures and Mandatory Portal E‑Service: Florida’s 2025 Overhaul of Electronic Filing and Service Rules Introduction In this rulemaking opinion, the Supreme...

Florida Probate Practice Updated: Mandatory E‑Service of Formal Notice on Appearing Counsel; “Promptly Thereafter” Standard for Serving Objections to Personal Representative’s Proof of Claim; Guardianship Physician Report Timing Aligned with Statute

Date: Mar 21, 2025

Florida Probate Practice Updated: Mandatory E‑Service of Formal Notice on Appearing Counsel; “Promptly Thereafter” Standard for Serving Objections to Personal Representative’s Proof of Claim;...

Suspension over Admonishment: A New Benchmark in Lawyer Misconduct Discipline

Date: Mar 20, 2025

Suspension over Admonishment: A New Benchmark in Lawyer Misconduct Discipline Introduction The judgment in The Florida Bar v. Danielle Renee Watson marks a significant moment in the discipline of...

Clarifying the Boundaries of Postconviction Relief in Capital Cases: Procedural Bars, Newly Discovered Evidence, and Jury Unanimity

Date: Mar 19, 2025

Clarifying the Boundaries of Postconviction Relief in Capital Cases: Procedural Bars, Newly Discovered Evidence, and Jury Unanimity Introduction The case of Edward T. James v. State of Florida...