Florida Case Commentaries

“Speak Now or Forever Hold Your Peace” – The Florida Supreme Court Declares Case (Procedural) Jurisdiction Waivable in JJJTB, Inc. v. Schmidt

Date: Jul 22, 2025

“Speak Now or Forever Hold Your Peace” – The Florida Supreme Court Declares Case (Procedural) Jurisdiction Waivable in JJJTB, Inc. v. Schmidt 1. Introduction On 17 July 2025, the Supreme Court of...

Fletcher v. State: Florida Supreme Court Rejects “Reverse Jury Nullification” & Clarifies the Mitigation-Burden Framework in Capital Sentencing

Date: Jul 22, 2025

Fletcher v. State: Florida Supreme Court Rejects “Reverse Jury Nullification” & Clarifies the Mitigation-Burden Framework in Capital Sentencing Introduction Case: Timothy W. Fletcher v. State of...

“Known-but-Unexamined” Evidence and the Due-Diligence Bar in Successive Post-Conviction Litigation – A Commentary on Toney Deron Davis v. State of Florida (2025)

Date: Jul 22, 2025

“Known-but-Unexamined” Evidence and the Due-Diligence Bar in Successive Post-Conviction Litigation A Commentary on Toney Deron Davis v. State of Florida, Supreme Court of Florida, No. SC2024-1128 (17...

“Beyond the Four Corners”: Florida Supreme Court Affirms Actionability of Implied Covenants in Public-University Contracts

Date: Jul 19, 2025

“Beyond the Four Corners”: Florida Supreme Court Affirms Actionability of Implied Covenants in Public-University Contracts 1. Introduction Anthony Rojas, a graduate student at the University of...

Bell v. State (2025): Florida Supreme Court Affirms the Right of Post-Conviction Witnesses to Invoke the Fifth Amendment and Limits Confrontation Rights in Successive Capital Collateral Proceedings

Date: Jul 11, 2025

Bell v. State (2025): Florida Supreme Court Affirms the Right of Post-Conviction Witnesses to Invoke the Fifth Amendment and Limits Confrontation Rights in Successive Capital Collateral Proceedings...

Dual-Filed Discrimination Charges Need Not Name the FCRA to Satisfy Its Administrative Filing Requirement

Date: Jul 11, 2025

Dual-Filed Discrimination Charges Need Not Name the FCRA to Satisfy Its Administrative Filing Requirement Case: Steak N Shake, Inc. v. Wilfred Ramos, Jr., 415 So.3d 107 Court: Supreme Court of...

Adequate Standard Instructions Suffice for the Avoid-Arrest Aggravator in Capital Sentencing

Date: Jul 11, 2025

Adequate Standard Instructions Suffice for the Avoid-Arrest Aggravator in Capital Sentencing Case: Michael W. Jones v. State of Florida, 415 So. 3d 113 Court: Supreme Court of Florida Opinion date:...

Allen v. State (2025): The “Self-Representation Bar” – Clarifying the Procedural Limits on Postconviction Claims by Pro Se Capital Defendants

Date: Jul 5, 2025

Allen v. State (2025): The “Self-Representation Bar” – Clarifying the Procedural Limits on Postconviction Claims by Pro Se Capital Defendants Introduction Scottie D. Allen, already serving a 25-year...

No Do‑Overs for Pro Se Capital Defendants: Florida Supreme Court Applies Invited-Error and Colorable-Claim Gatekeeping to Foreclose Postconviction Mitigation Challenges

Date: Jul 4, 2025

No Do‑Overs for Pro Se Capital Defendants: Invited Error and Colorable-Claim Gatekeeping Foreclose Postconviction Mitigation Challenges Introduction This commentary examines the Florida Supreme...

“One Unified Limited-Appearance Form” – A New Benchmark in Florida Family-Law Self-Help Documentation

Date: Jul 1, 2025

“One Unified Limited-Appearance Form” – A New Benchmark in Florida Family-Law Self-Help Documentation Introduction In In Re: Amendments to the Florida Family Law Rules of Procedure – Forms,...

“The Girley Standard”: Florida Supreme Court Clarifies the Limits of Lawyers’ Public Criticism of Judges

Date: Jul 1, 2025

“The Girley Standard”: Florida Supreme Court Clarifies the Limits of Lawyers’ Public Criticism of Judges Introduction On 26 June 2025 the Supreme Court of Florida decided The Florida Bar v. Brooke...

Reposting Judicial Accusations on Social Media Can Breach Rule 4-8.2(a): Florida Supreme Court Affirms 30-Day Suspensions and Reiterates Limits on Lawyer Speech and Judicial Inquiry

Date: Jun 27, 2025

Reposting Judicial Accusations on Social Media Can Breach Rule 4-8.2(a): Florida Supreme Court Affirms 30-Day Suspensions and Reiterates Limits on Lawyer Speech and Judicial Inquiry Introduction In...

“Duty Over Autonomy” – The Florida Supreme Court Confirms Trial Judges Must Consider All Record Mitigation Even When the Self-Represented Defendant Objects (Commentary on Steven J. Lorenzo v. State of Florida, No. SC2023-0539)

Date: Jun 20, 2025

“Duty Over Autonomy” – The Florida Supreme Court Confirms Trial Judges Must Consider All Record Mitigation Even When the Self-Represented Defendant Objects Commentary on Steven J. Lorenzo v. State of...

Clarifying Ethical Boundaries for Departing Associates: Unauthorized Filings, Client Contact & Discovery Obligations under Florida Bar Rules – A Commentary on The Florida Bar v. Alexa Martinez (2025)

Date: Jun 20, 2025

Clarifying Ethical Boundaries for Departing Associates: Unauthorized Filings, Client Contact & Discovery Obligations under Florida Bar Rules A Comprehensive Commentary on The Florida Bar v. Alexa...

Gudinas v. State: Florida Supreme Court Reasserts the Conformity Clause and Reinforces Procedural Bars in Post-Warrant Capital Appeals

Date: Jun 20, 2025

Gudinas v. State: Florida Supreme Court Reasserts the Conformity Clause and Reinforces Procedural Bars in Post-Warrant Capital Appeals Introduction Thomas Lee Gudinas, sentenced to death for a 1994...

“Sua Sponte” Assessment of Mandatory State-Attorney Costs: Parks v. State of Florida and the End of the “Request” Requirement

Date: Jun 18, 2025

“Sua Sponte” Assessment of Mandatory State-Attorney Costs: Parks v. State of Florida and the End of the “Request” Requirement 1. Introduction Jourdan Daniel Parks v. State of Florida, decided by the...

Irrevocability Requirement for Government-Granted Property Interests under Florida’s Takings Clause

Date: Jun 10, 2025

Irrevocability Requirement for Government-Granted Property Interests under Florida’s Takings Clause Introduction In Gustavo Bojorquez, et al. v. State of Florida, the Supreme Court of Florida...

Mandating Multilingual Residential Eviction Summons: Enhancing Procedural Fairness under Florida Rule 1.923(a)

Date: Jun 10, 2025

Mandating Multilingual Residential Eviction Summons: Enhancing Procedural Fairness under Florida Rule 1.923(a) Introduction This commentary examines the Supreme Court of Florida’s per curiam decision...

Erlinger Non-Retroactivity and Procedural Bars in Successive Death-Penalty Postconviction Relief

Date: Jun 10, 2025

Erlinger Non-Retroactivity and Procedural Bars in Successive Death-Penalty Postconviction Relief Introduction In Anthony Floyd Wainwright v. State of Florida (No. SC2025-0708), the Florida Supreme...

Presumption of Flight Risk for Unauthorized Aliens Charged with Forcible Felonies under Florida Rule 3.132(f)(2)

Date: May 23, 2025

Presumption of Flight Risk for Unauthorized Aliens Charged with Forcible Felonies under Florida Rule 3.132(f)(2) Introduction In In Re: Amendments to the Florida Rules of Criminal Procedure – 2025...