Florida Case Commentaries

First Amendment and Tort Liability: Religious Institutions Held Accountable for Clergy Misconduct

Date: Mar 15, 2002

First Amendment and Tort Liability: Religious Institutions Held Accountable for Clergy Misconduct Introduction The case of Jan Malicki, St. David Catholic Church, and the Archdiocese of Miami v. Jane...

First Amendment Does Not Shield Religious Institutions from Tort Liability in Clergy Sexual Misconduct — Supreme Court of Florida Decision

Date: Mar 15, 2002

First Amendment Does Not Shield Religious Institutions from Tort Liability in Clergy Sexual Misconduct Introduction In the landmark case of Jane Doe v. William Dunbar Evans, III; Church of the Holy...

Inherent Authority of Trial Courts to Impose Attorney's Fees for Bad Faith Conduct: MOAKLEY v. SMALLWOOD

Date: Mar 1, 2002

Inherent Authority of Trial Courts to Impose Attorney's Fees for Bad Faith Conduct: MOAKLEY v. SMALLWOOD Introduction The case of Barbara Moakley v. Sheri Smallwood, reported as 826 So. 2d 221,...

Supreme Court Upholds Swafford in Interpretation of Section 90.801(2)(c) in PURYEAR v. STATE

Date: Feb 8, 2002

Supreme Court Upholds Swafford in Interpretation of Section 90.801(2)(c) in PURYEAR v. STATE Introduction In the landmark case Kevin PURYEAR v. STATE of Florida (810 So. 2d 901, 2002), the Supreme...

Affirmation of Capital Murder Conviction Based on Circumstantial Evidence and DNA Analysis

Date: Jan 4, 2002

Affirmation of Capital Murder Conviction Based on Circumstantial Evidence and DNA Analysis Introduction Dolan Darling v. State of Florida, (808 So. 2d 145), adjudicated by the Supreme Court of...

Affirmation of Capital Murder Convictions: An In-depth Commentary on Peremptory Challenges, Aggravating Factors, and Mitigation

Date: Dec 21, 2001

Affirmation of Capital Murder Convictions: An In-depth Commentary on Peremptory Challenges, Aggravating Factors, and Mitigation Introduction The case of Carlton A. Francis v. State of Florida is a...

Connor v. Florida: Affirmation of Death Penalty in Double Murder Case

Date: Dec 18, 2001

Connor v. Florida: Affirmation of Death Penalty in Double Murder Case Introduction Connor v. State of Florida is a significant case decided by the Supreme Court of Florida on December 17, 2001. The...

Clarifying the Strickland Standard in Postconviction Relief: BRUNO v. STATE of Florida

Date: Dec 7, 2001

Clarifying the Strickland Standard in Postconviction Relief: BRUNO v. STATE of Florida Introduction BRUNO v. STATE of Florida, 807 So. 2d 55 (Fla. 2001), is a pivotal case in Florida jurisprudence...

Clarifying Res Judicata and Law of the Case in Workers' Compensation Immunity: Florida Dept. of Transportation v. Juliano

Date: Nov 22, 2001

Clarifying Res Judicata and Law of the Case in Workers' Compensation Immunity: Florida Department of Transportation v. Juliano Introduction In the landmark case of Florida Department of...

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Burden-Shifting Presumption in Slip-and-Fall Cases Involving Transitory Foreign Substances

Date: Nov 16, 2001

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Burden-Shifting Presumption in Slip-and-Fall Cases Involving Transitory Foreign Substances Introduction The Supreme Court of Florida, in the landmark decision of...

Reaffirming the Collateral Source Rule: SHEFFIELD v. SUPERIOR INSURANCE CO. Sets New Precedent

Date: Oct 26, 2001

Reaffirming the Collateral Source Rule: SHEFFIELD v. SUPERIOR INSURANCE CO. Sets New Precedent Introduction In the landmark case of Mary Ann SHEFFIELD v. SUPERIOR INSURANCE COmpany, the Supreme Court...

Affirmation of Death Penalty in CARD v. STATE: A Comprehensive Legal Analysis

Date: Oct 12, 2001

Affirmation of Death Penalty in CARD v. STATE: A Comprehensive Legal Analysis Introduction James Armando Card was convicted of first-degree murder, robbery, and kidnapping, culminating in a death...

Correction of Illegal Habitual Offender Sentences Under Rule 3.800(a): Insights from Bover v. State

Date: Oct 5, 2001

Correction of Illegal Habitual Offender Sentences Under Rule 3.800(a): Insights from Bover v. State Introduction The case of Jesus Bover v. State, adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Florida on...

Affirmation of Trial Court's Denial of Postconviction Relief in WATERHOUSE v. STATE

Date: Aug 24, 2001

Affirmation of Trial Court's Denial of Postconviction Relief in WATERHOUSE v. STATE Introduction WATERHOUSE v. STATE (792 So. 2d 1176) is a seminal decision by the Supreme Court of Florida addressing...

Equitable Estoppel Remains Viable Despite Strict Statutory Tolling in Florida

Date: Jul 13, 2001

Equitable Estoppel Remains Viable Despite Strict Statutory Tolling in Florida Introduction The case of MORSANI v. MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL, decided by the Supreme Court of Florida on July 12, 2001,...

Accrual of Negligence Claims and Judicial Estoppel in Insurance Cases: Blumberg v. USAA Casualty Insurance Co.

Date: Jul 13, 2001

Accrual of Negligence Claims and Judicial Estoppel in Insurance Cases: Blumberg v. USAA Casualty Insurance Co. Introduction The case of Richard Blumberg v. USAA Casualty Insurance Company, reported...

Harris v. State of Florida: Limitation of Habeas Corpus in Addressing Procedural Rights During Resentencing

Date: Jun 22, 2001

Harris v. State of Florida: Limitation of Habeas Corpus in Addressing Procedural Rights During Resentencing Introduction In Leonard A. Harris v. State of Florida (789 So. 2d 1114), the District Court...

Florida Supreme Court Affirms Limitations on Homestead Exemption Amidst Fraudulent Conveyances

Date: Jun 22, 2001

Florida Supreme Court Affirms Limitations on Homestead Exemption Amidst Fraudulent Conveyances Introduction In the landmark case of Havoco of America, Ltd. v. Elmer C. Hill, the Supreme Court of...

Standard of Certiorari Review in Land Use Decisions: Broward County v. G.B.V. International

Date: Jun 8, 2001

Standard of Certiorari Review in Land Use Decisions: Broward County v. G.B.V. International Introduction In Broward County, Petitioner, v. G.B.V. International, Ltd., 787 So. 2d 838 (Fla. 2001), the...

Affirmation of Effective Counsel's Strategic Concessions in Penalty Phase: ATWATER v. STATE of Florida

Date: Jun 8, 2001

Affirmation of Effective Counsel's Strategic Concessions in Penalty Phase: ATWATER v. STATE of Florida Introduction Jeffrey Lee Atwater was convicted of first-degree murder and robbery in the State...