Florida Case Commentaries

Arbitration Provision and Fraud Claims: Jackson v. Shakespeare Foundation

Date: Feb 1, 2013

Arbitration Provision and Fraud Claims: Jackson v. Shakespeare Foundation Introduction In George Jackson, et al. v. The Shakespeare Foundation, Inc., et al., 108 So. 3d 587 (Fla. 2013), the Supreme...

Rebuttable Presumption in Rear-End Collision Cases Under Florida's Comparative Negligence System

Date: Jan 25, 2013

Rebuttable Presumption in Rear-End Collision Cases Under Florida's Comparative Negligence System Introduction The case of Warren A. Birge v. Crystal D. Charron, decided by the Supreme Court of...

New Precedent on Attorney's Fees and Offer of Judgment under FDUTPA: Diamond Aircraft Industries, Inc. v. Horowitch

Date: Jan 11, 2013

New Precedent on Attorney's Fees and Offer of Judgment under FDUTPA: Diamond Aircraft Industries, Inc. v. Horowitch Introduction Diamond Aircraft Industries, Inc. v. Alan Horowitch is a cornerstone...

Limitations on Interlocutory Review of Sovereign Immunity Claims: Citizens Property Insurance Corp. v. San Perdido Association

Date: Nov 16, 2012

Limitations on Interlocutory Review of Sovereign Immunity Claims: Citizens Property Insurance Corp. v. San Perdido Association Introduction The case of Citizens Property Insurance Corporation v. San...

Strict Standards for Certiorari Relief in Discovery Orders: Insights from Board of Trustees v. American Educational Enterprises

Date: Sep 28, 2012

Strict Standards for Certiorari Relief in Discovery Orders: Insights from Board of Trustees v. American Educational Enterprises Introduction The case of Board of Trustees of the Internal Improvement...

Unconstitutionality of Special Lien Laws: Shands v. Mercury Insurance Co. of Florida

Date: Sep 5, 2012

Unconstitutionality of Special Lien Laws: Shands v. Mercury Insurance Co. of Florida Introduction The landmark case of Shands Teaching Hospital and Clinics, Inc. v. Mercury Insurance Company of...

Florida Supreme Court Upholds Strict Liability in Controlled Substance Offenses under Chapter 893

Date: Jul 13, 2012

Florida Supreme Court Upholds Strict Liability in Controlled Substance Offenses under Chapter 893 Introduction The case of State of Florida v. Luke Jarrod Adkins (96 So. 3d 412) addresses the...

NORDELO v. STATE (93 So. 3d 178): Redefining Standards for Newly Discovered Evidence in Postconviction Relief

Date: Jun 8, 2012

NORDELO v. STATE (93 So. 3d 178): Redefining Standards for Newly Discovered Evidence in Postconviction Relief Introduction In NORDELO v. STATE, the Supreme Court of Florida addressed pivotal issues...

Florida Supreme Court Affirms Statutory First-Party Bad Faith Claims and Upholds Hurricane Deductible Enforcement

Date: Jun 1, 2012

Florida Supreme Court Affirms Statutory First-Party Bad Faith Claims and Upholds Hurricane Deductible Enforcement Introduction The case of QBE Insurance Corporation v. Chalfonte Condominium Apartment...

Expansion of Second-Tier Certiorari Jurisdiction in Florida's Implied Consent Cases

Date: May 5, 2012

Expansion of Second-Tier Certiorari Jurisdiction in Florida's Implied Consent Cases Introduction In the landmark case of Susan Nader v. Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles, the...

Establishing Standing in Mortgage Foreclosure: McLean v. JP Morgan Chase Bank

Date: Feb 9, 2012

Establishing Standing in Mortgage Foreclosure: McLean v. JP Morgan Chase Bank Introduction The case of Robert McLean v. JP Morgan Chase Bank National Association explores the critical issue of...

Broad Interpretation of Consent in Insurance Coverage: Geico Indemnity Co. v. Shazier

Date: Jan 24, 2012

Broad Interpretation of Consent in Insurance Coverage: Geico Indemnity Co. v. Shazier Introduction Geico Indemnity Co. v. Shazier is a landmark decision by the Supreme Court of Florida that redefines...

Amendment 7 Mandates Disclosure of Medical Credentialing Records: Insights from West Florida Regional Medical Center v. See

Date: Jan 13, 2012

Amendment 7 Mandates Disclosure of Medical Credentialing Records: Insights from West Florida Regional Medical Center v. See Introduction The case of West Florida Regional Medical Center, Inc., etc.,...

Affirmation of Capital Murder Convictions in Knight v. State: Procedural Standards and Proportionality of Death Sentences

Date: Dec 16, 2011

Affirmation of Capital Murder Convictions in Knight v. State: Procedural Standards and Proportionality of Death Sentences Introduction Richard Knight v. State of Florida (76 So. 3d 879) is a...

Florida Appellate Court Upholds Constitutionality of Controlled Substance Possession Statute, Reforms Improper Fees Imposed

Date: Dec 1, 2011

Florida Appellate Court Upholds Constitutionality of Controlled Substance Possession Statute, Reforms Improper Fees Imposed Introduction In the landmark appellate case of Herman P. Maestas v. State...

Time Limitations Under Florida Rule 3.850 Affirmed in CARBAJAL v. STATE

Date: Nov 4, 2011

Time Limitations Under Florida Rule 3.850 Affirmed in CARBAJAL v. STATE Introduction The case of CARBAJAL v. STATE, adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Florida on November 3, 2011, addresses the...

Affirmation of Denial of Postconviction Relief in HOSKINS v. STATE: Implications for Ineffective Assistance Claims

Date: Nov 4, 2011

Affirmation of Denial of Postconviction Relief in HOSKINS v. STATE: Implications for Ineffective Assistance Claims Introduction The case of Johnny HOSKINS v. STATE of Florida (75 So. 3d 250, Supreme...

Strict Enforcement of Filing Deadlines for Objections to Personal Representative Qualifications: Analysis of Sol v. Hill

Date: Sep 2, 2011

Strict Enforcement of Filing Deadlines for Objections to Personal Representative Qualifications: Analysis of Sol v. Hill Introduction Solveig Edna Hill v. Douglas Davis, 70 So. 3d 572 (Fla. 2011),...

Clarifying Household Exclusions in Automobile Insurance: State Farm v. Menendez

Date: Aug 26, 2011

Clarifying Household Exclusions in Automobile Insurance: State Farm v. Menendez Introduction In the landmark case of State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company v. Gilda Menendez, decided on...

Effective Assistance of Counsel in Immigration Consequences: Hernandez v. State of Florida

Date: Jun 18, 2011

Effective Assistance of Counsel in Immigration Consequences: Hernandez v. State of Florida Introduction Hernandez v. State of Florida, 61 So. 3d 1144 (2011), adjudicated by the District Court of...