Colorado Case Commentaries

Nonresidential Community Corrections Is Not “Confinement” for Presentence Credit: Colorado Supreme Court Reaffirms Hoecher and Emphasizes Legislative Acquiescence

Date: May 28, 2025

Nonresidential Community Corrections Is Not “Confinement” for Presentence Credit: Colorado Supreme Court Reaffirms Hoecher and Emphasizes Legislative Acquiescence Introduction In Bonde v. People,...

Pretext Conversations and Voluntary Out-of-Custody Statements

Date: May 13, 2025

Pretext Conversations and Voluntary Out-of-Custody Statements Introduction The People of the State of Colorado v. Patrick Nkongolo (2025 CO 20) arises from an interlocutory appeal in a...

State Tort Claims for Climate Change Damages Are Not Preempted by Federal Law

Date: May 13, 2025

State Tort Claims for Climate Change Damages Are Not Preempted by Federal Law Introduction In In Re County Commissioners of Boulder County and City of Boulder v. Suncor Energy USA, Inc., et al., 2025...

Limiting Counterman’s Recklessness Requirement to True-Threats Stalking Charges

Date: May 13, 2025

Limiting Counterman’s Recklessness Requirement to True-Threats Stalking Charges Introduction In In Re The People of the State of Colorado v. David Samuel Crawford (2025 CO 22), the Colorado Supreme...

Colorado Supreme Court Holds the Clean Air Act Does Not Preempt State Tort Damages Claims for Climate-Related Harms Against Fossil Fuel Producers

Date: May 13, 2025

Colorado Supreme Court Holds the Clean Air Act Does Not Preempt State Tort Damages Claims for Climate-Related Harms Against Fossil Fuel Producers Introduction In a closely watched climate litigation...

Non-Content-Based Stalking: Mens Rea Clarification in In Re People v. Crawford (2025 CO 22)

Date: May 13, 2025

Non-Content-Based Stalking: Mens Rea Clarification in In Re People v. Crawford (2025 CO 22) Introduction In In Re The People of the State of Colorado v. David Samuel Crawford (2025 CO 22), the...

Pretext Texts Are Not Inherently Coercive: Colorado Sets Voluntariness Benchmark for Agent‑Mediated, Noncustodial Conversations

Date: May 13, 2025

Pretext Texts Are Not Inherently Coercive: Colorado Sets Voluntariness Benchmark for Agent‑Mediated, Noncustodial Conversations Introduction In People v. Nkongolo, 2025 CO 20, the Colorado Supreme...

Affirmation of Comprehensive Physician-Patient Privilege for Emergency Treatment Records

Date: May 13, 2025

Affirmation of Comprehensive Physician-Patient Privilege for Emergency Treatment Records Introduction In Re Lucas Trenshaw and Theresa Gardner, Personal Representative for the Estate of Timothy...

Communications in Treatment Records Are Categorically Privileged: Colorado Supreme Court Bars Sentence-by-Sentence Parsing of Medical Records

Date: May 13, 2025

Communications in Treatment Records Are Categorically Privileged: Colorado Supreme Court Bars Sentence-by-Sentence Parsing of Medical Records Introduction In Trenshaw v. Jennings, 2025 CO 23, 568...

Counterman’s Recklessness Requirement Does Not Apply to Content‑Neutral Stalking: Colorado Supreme Court Clarifies § 18‑3‑602(1)(c) in People v. Crawford (2025)

Date: May 13, 2025

Counterman’s Recklessness Requirement Does Not Apply to Content‑Neutral Stalking: Colorado Supreme Court Clarifies § 18‑3‑602(1)(c) in People v. Crawford (2025) Introduction In People v. Crawford,...

No‑Contact Means No‑Contact: Attempted Communication Through a Protected Party’s Lawyer Violates a Protection Order; Punitive Contempt and Protection‑Order Breaches Support Colo. RPC 8.4(b) Without a Criminal Conviction

Date: May 8, 2025

No‑Contact Means No‑Contact: Attempted Communication Through a Protected Party’s Lawyer Violates a Protection Order; Punitive Contempt and Protection‑Order Breaches Support Colo. RPC 8.4(b) Without a...

Intervening Cause Defense in Colorado’s Fentanyl-Death Enhancement Statute

Date: May 6, 2025

Intervening Cause Defense in Colorado’s Fentanyl-Death Enhancement Statute Introduction In Re The People of the State of Colorado v. Patrick L. Beverly, II (2025 CO 18) presents the first opportunity...

Restoration Evaluations Are “Services Necessary to Competency Restoration”: Colorado Supreme Court Authorizes CDHS to Reevaluate Juvenile Competency Without a Court Order

Date: May 6, 2025

Restoration Evaluations Are “Services Necessary to Competency Restoration”: Colorado Supreme Court Authorizes CDHS to Reevaluate Juvenile Competency Without a Court Order Case: In re The People of...

Colorado Supreme Court Declares No Willful-and-Wanton Exception to the Economic Loss Rule

Date: Apr 22, 2025

Colorado Supreme Court Declares No Willful-and-Wanton Exception to the Economic Loss Rule Introduction In Mid-Century Insurance Company v. HIVE Construction, Inc., 567 P.3d 153, 2025 CO 17 (Colo....

Anti‑Speculation Doctrine Does Not Apply to Water Court Review of Amendments to Augmentation Plans for Not‑Nontributary Denver Basin Groundwater

Date: Apr 22, 2025

Anti‑Speculation Doctrine Does Not Apply to Water Court Review of Amendments to Augmentation Plans for Not‑Nontributary Denver Basin Groundwater Case: Franktown Citizens Coalition II, Inc. and West...

No Exception for Willful and Wanton Conduct Under Colorado’s Economic Loss Rule

Date: Apr 22, 2025

No Exception for Willful and Wanton Conduct Under Colorado’s Economic Loss Rule Introduction In Mid-Century Insurance Company, as subrogee of Masterpiece Kitchen, v. HIVE Construction, Inc. (2025 CO...

Channeling Prosecutorial Appeals in Colorado: As‑Applied Constitutional Dismissals Go to the Court of Appeals; Misfiled Appeals Must Be Transferred, Not Dismissed

Date: Apr 15, 2025

Channeling Prosecutorial Appeals in Colorado: As‑Applied Constitutional Dismissals Go to the Court of Appeals; Misfiled Appeals Must Be Transferred, Not Dismissed Case: People of the State of...

Authority of the Department to Conduct Restoration Evaluations as Services Necessary to Competency Restoration

Date: Apr 15, 2025

Authority of the Department to Conduct Restoration Evaluations as Services Necessary to Competency Restoration Introduction In In Re The People of the State of Colorado, In the Interest of Juvenile:...

Discovery in Statutory Hospital-Lien Class Actions Is Limited to Billing-and-Lien Elements: Garcia v. Centura Health (Colo. 2025)

Date: Apr 15, 2025

Discovery in Statutory Hospital-Lien Class Actions Is Limited to Billing-and-Lien Elements: Garcia v. Centura Health (Colo. 2025) Introduction In a significant clarification of the discovery rules...

The Exterior Access Doctrine: Probable Cause to Search Vehicle Trunks under the Automobile Exception

Date: Apr 15, 2025

The Exterior Access Doctrine: Probable Cause to Search Vehicle Trunks under the Automobile Exception Introduction This case, The People of the State of Colorado v. Sheron Mario Furness (2025 CO 16),...