Arizona Case Commentaries

Red-Light Violation Requires Intersection Entry; A.R.S. § 28-672 Cannot Attach When the Fatal Collision Occurs Before the Intersection

Date: Dec 13, 2025

Red-Light Violation Requires Intersection Entry; A.R.S. § 28-672 Cannot Attach When the Fatal Collision Occurs Before the Intersection Case: STATE OF ARIZONA v. HON. GORDON/OWEN (Ariz. Dec. 12, 2025)...

No Statewide Electorate Required: Knight v. Fontes and the Scope of Arizona’s “Free and Equal” Elections Clause

Date: Dec 9, 2025

No Statewide Electorate Required: Knight v. Fontes and the Scope of Arizona’s “Free and Equal” Elections Clause I. Introduction In Knight v. Fontes, CV-24-0220-T/AP (Ariz. Dec. 4, 2025), the Arizona...

State v. Alvarez‑Soto: Arizona Rejects Independent Appellate Review of Video Evidence and Upholds Traffic Stops Based on Objectively Reasonable Mistakes of Law

Date: Nov 29, 2025

State v. Alvarez‑Soto: Arizona Rejects Independent Appellate Review of Video Evidence and Upholds Traffic Stops Based on Objectively Reasonable Mistakes of Law I. Introduction The Arizona Supreme...

Non‑Signatories and Forum‑Selection Clauses in Arizona: Henderson v. Moskowitz/Sullivan Rejects the Closely Related Party Doctrine

Date: Nov 29, 2025

Non‑Signatories and Forum‑Selection Clauses in Arizona: Henderson v. Moskowitz/Sullivan Rejects the Closely Related Party Doctrine I. Introduction In Henderson v. Hon. Moskowitz / Sullivan, No....

Clear-and-Convincing Is a Standard, Not an Element: Henke v. Hospital Development of West Phoenix Recalibrates Causation Proof in Arizona Emergency-Room Malpractice

Date: Oct 23, 2025

Clear-and-Convincing Is a Standard, Not an Element: Henke v. Hospital Development of West Phoenix Recalibrates Causation Proof in Arizona Emergency-Room Malpractice Introduction In Henke v. Hospital...

Locked Bedrooms as “Residential Structures”: Arizona Supreme Court Recognizes Nested Castles and Limits Co‑Occupant Invitations in Justification Law

Date: Oct 8, 2025

Locked Bedrooms as “Residential Structures”: Arizona Supreme Court Recognizes Nested Castles and Limits Co‑Occupant Invitations in Justification Law Introduction In State of Arizona v. John Logan...

Delegation as Injury: Arizona Supreme Court Recognizes Legislative Standing to Challenge Voter‑Enacted Agency Powers and Clarifies VPA Limits in Montenegro v. Fontes

Date: Sep 30, 2025

Delegation as Injury: Arizona Supreme Court Recognizes Legislative Standing to Challenge Voter‑Enacted Agency Powers and Clarifies VPA Limits in Montenegro v. Fontes Introduction In Montenegro v....

Personal Waiver Required for Plea-Stage Ineffective Assistance Claims; Stewart’s Automatic Preclusion Disavowed

Date: Sep 24, 2025

Personal Waiver Required for Plea-Stage Ineffective Assistance Claims; Stewart’s Automatic Preclusion Disavowed Introduction In State of Arizona v. Michael Eugene Traverso, the Arizona Supreme Court...

Gross Negligence Is Not a “Reasonable Alternative”: Arizona’s Anti‑Abrogation Clause Invalidates Pandemic Immunity for Ordinary Medical Negligence, but a Clear‑and‑Convincing Burden Survives

Date: Sep 13, 2025

Gross Negligence Is Not a “Reasonable Alternative”: Arizona’s Anti‑Abrogation Clause Invalidates Pandemic Immunity for Ordinary Medical Negligence, but a Clear‑and‑Convincing Burden Survives...

Arizona Supreme Court: General Anti‑Assignment Clauses Do Not Bar Assignment of Accrued Implied‑Warranty Claims to HOAs

Date: Sep 5, 2025

General Anti‑Assignment Clauses Do Not Bar Assignment of Accrued Implied‑Warranty Claims to HOAs Introduction In Pointe 16 Community Association v. GTIS-HOV Pointe 16, LLC, the Arizona Supreme Court...

“Once Recused, Still Disqualified”: Arizona Supreme Court Requires Disclosure and Opportunity to Object Before a Judge Re‑Enters a Case After Recusal

Date: Aug 22, 2025

“Once Recused, Still Disqualified”: Arizona Supreme Court Requires Disclosure and Opportunity to Object Before a Judge Re‑Enters a Case After Recusal Introduction In Contreras v. Bourke, the Arizona...

No Judicial Preapproval for Refilling Charges After NCNR; Dangerousness Trials Require Pending Charges and Apply Retroactively

Date: Aug 21, 2025

No Judicial Preapproval for Refilling Charges After NCNR; Dangerousness Trials Require Pending Charges and Apply Retroactively Introduction In a consolidated decision arising from a protracted...

Smith v. Fontes: Cementing the “Exactly-15 %” Initiative Signature Standard and Barring Double-Counting of Invalid Signatures

Date: Aug 13, 2025

Smith v. Fontes: Cementing the “Exactly-15 %” Initiative Signature Standard and Barring Double-Counting of Invalid Signatures Introduction Smith v. Fontes, decided by the Arizona Supreme Court on 6...

State v. Rushing (2025): Clarifying Fundamental-Error Review for Visible Restraints in Capital Sentencing

Date: Aug 7, 2025

State v. Rushing (2025): Clarifying Fundamental-Error Review for Visible Restraints in Capital Sentencing Introduction State of Arizona v. Jasper Phillip Rushing is the Arizona Supreme Court’s most...

Roundtree v. Page: A New Standard for Determining When a Municipal Initiative Is “Legislative”

Date: Jul 31, 2025

Roundtree v. Page: A New Standard for Determining When a Municipal Initiative Is “Legislative” Introduction Roundtree v. Page, decided by the Arizona Supreme Court on 30 July 2025, addresses the...

“Sheriff-Not-County” Rule: Arizona Supreme Court Re‐draws the Map of Vicarious Liability and Notice-of-Claim Practice (Sanchez v. Maricopa County, 2025)

Date: Jul 23, 2025

“Sheriff-Not-County” Rule: Arizona Supreme Court Re-draws the Map of Vicarious Liability and Notice-of-Claim Practice (Sanchez v. Maricopa County, 2025) Introduction Sanchez v. Maricopa County is a...

“Just Cause” Re-Defined: The Arizona Supreme Court Recasts the Abandonment Presumption in Parental-Rights Terminations

Date: Jul 23, 2025

“Just Cause” Re-Defined: The Arizona Supreme Court Recasts the Abandonment Presumption in Parental-Rights Terminations 1. Introduction In In Re Termination of Parental Rights as to B.W., the Arizona...

“Reasonable Certainty” Re-defined: McAlister v. Loeb & the Recoverability of Lost Profits in Prospective Licensing Transactions

Date: Jul 23, 2025

“Reasonable Certainty” Re-defined: McAlister v. Loeb & Loeb, LLP Arizona Supreme Court (2025) Introduction McAlister v. Loeb & Loeb, LLP is a pivotal 2025 decision from the Arizona Supreme Court...

“Outside the School-Student Relationship” – Arizona Supreme Court Defines the Geographic Limits of a School’s Duty of Care (PUSD 210 v. Hon. Sinclair/Lucero, 2025)

Date: Jul 16, 2025

“Outside the School-Student Relationship” – Arizona Supreme Court Defines the Geographic Limits of a School’s Duty of Care Commentary on PUSD 210 v. Hon. Sinclair / Lucero, CV-24-0307-PR (Ariz. Jul....

“Directory, Not Disqualifying” – Arizona Supreme Court Holds that Failure to File A.R.S. § 14-5109 Notice Does Not Automatically Bar Professional Fees

Date: Jul 13, 2025

“Directory, Not Disqualifying” – Arizona Supreme Court Holds that Failure to File A.R.S. § 14-5109 Notice Does Not Automatically Bar Professional Fees 1. Introduction In In the Matter of the...