Arizona Case Commentaries

Clear and Convincing Evidence Standard for Prior Bad Acts in Arizona Criminal Cases: State of Arizona v. Mario Amado Terrazas

Date: Aug 15, 1997

Clear and Convincing Evidence Standard for Prior Bad Acts in Arizona Criminal Cases Introduction State of Arizona v. Mario Amado Terrazas is a landmark decision by the Supreme Court of Arizona that...

Limits on Diminished Capacity Defense in Arizona: Analysis of STATE v. MOTT

Date: Jan 17, 1997

Limits on Diminished Capacity Defense in Arizona: Analysis of STATE v. MOTT Introduction In State of Arizona v. Shelly Kay Mott, 183 Ariz. 191 (App. 1995), the Supreme Court of Arizona addressed the...

Presumption of Validity Upholds Scottsdale's Development Fee under A.R.S. § 9-463.05

Date: Jan 8, 1997

Presumption of Validity Upholds Scottsdale's Development Fee under A.R.S. § 9-463.05 Introduction The case of Home Builders Association of Central Arizona v. City of Scottsdale addresses the legality...

Enhanced Standards for Investigatory Vehicle Stops: Insights from State v. Gonzalez-Gutierrez

Date: Dec 6, 1996

Enhanced Standards for Investigatory Vehicle Stops: Insights from State v. Gonzalez-Gutierrez Introduction State of Arizona v. Rodolfo Gonzalez-Gutierrez is a pivotal case decided by the Supreme...

Arizona Supreme Court Affirms Death Penalty Based on Pecuniary Gain and Multiple Homicides in State v. Soto-Fong

Date: Nov 20, 1996

Arizona Supreme Court Affirms Death Penalty Based on Pecuniary Gain and Multiple Homicides in State of Arizona v. Martin Raul Soto-Fong Introduction In the landmark case of State of Arizona v. Martin...

Affirmation of Felony Murder Conviction and Death Sentence in STATE v. Gregory Scott Dickens

Date: Nov 1, 1996

Affirmation of Felony Murder Conviction and Death Sentence in STATE v. Gregory Scott Dickens Introduction STATE of Arizona v. Gregory Scott Dickens (187 Ariz. 1, 1996) is a pivotal decision by the...

Adoption of 'Reasonable Efforts' Jury Instructions in Arizona

Date: Sep 6, 1996

Adoption of 'Reasonable Efforts' Jury Instructions in Arizona Introduction The case of State of Arizona v. Larry Francis LeBlanc (186 Ariz. 437) marks a significant shift in Arizona's approach to...

Blackmore v. State: Redefining the Boundaries of Investigatory Detention and Arrest under the Fourth Amendment

Date: Aug 30, 1996

Blackmore v. State: Redefining the Boundaries of Investigatory Detention and Arrest under the Fourth Amendment Introduction The case of State of Arizona v. Timothy Scott Blackmore, decided by the...

Burden of Proof and Good Faith in Arrest Warrants: Insights from STATE of Arizona v. Hyde

Date: Jul 10, 1996

Burden of Proof and Good Faith in Arrest Warrants: Insights from STATE of Arizona v. Hyde Introduction STATE of Arizona v. David O'Neal Hyde is a pivotal judgment delivered by the Supreme Court of...

Affirmation of Death Sentence in Light of Accomplice Testimony Restrictions and Prosecutorial Conduct in State of Arizona v. Towery

Date: Jun 28, 1996

Affirmation of Death Sentence in Light of Accomplice Testimony Restrictions and Prosecutorial Conduct in State of Arizona v. Towery Introduction The case of State of Arizona v. Robert Charles Towery,...

Statute of Limitations and Unsound Mind: Insights from Florez v. Sargeant et al.

Date: May 17, 1996

Statute of Limitations and Unsound Mind: Insights from Florez v. Sargeant et al. Introduction In the landmark case of Florez v. Sargeant et al., the Supreme Court of Arizona addressed pivotal issues...

Reaffirming the Constitutionality of "Especially Heinous, Cruel or Depraved" in Death Sentencing: Commentary on State of Arizona v. Luis Morine Mata

Date: May 10, 1996

Reaffirming the Constitutionality of "Especially Heinous, Cruel or Depraved" in Death Sentencing Introduction State of Arizona v. Luis Morine Mata (185 Ariz. 319) is a significant judicial decision...

Zamora v. Superior Court: Interpretation of Historical Prior Felony Convictions under A.R.S. § 13-604(U)(1)(a)

Date: May 8, 1996

Clarifying the Scope of Historical Prior Felony Convictions: The Supreme Court of Arizona’s Interpretation of A.R.S. § 13-604(U)(1)(a) Introduction In the landmark case of Daniel Rodriguez Zamora v....

Authorized Initiative: Arizona Supreme Court Reinforces Foreign Corporations’ Capacity to Sue

Date: May 8, 1996

Authorized Initiative: Arizona Supreme Court Reinforces Foreign Corporations’ Capacity to Sue Introduction In the landmark case of GEMSTAR LIMITED v. ERNST YOUNG, the Supreme Court of Arizona...

Admissibility of Prior Sexual Assaults to Establish Modus Operandi and Emotional Propensity: State of Arizona v. Roscoe

Date: Feb 2, 1996

Admissibility of Prior Sexual Assaults to Establish Modus Operandi and Emotional Propensity: State of Arizona v. Roscoe Introduction State of Arizona v. Kevin Scott Roscoe is a landmark decision by...

Limitations on Appointed Counsel Rights in Discretionary Post-Conviction Appeals – Arizona v. Smith

Date: Jan 17, 1996

Limitations on Appointed Counsel Rights in Discretionary Post-Conviction Appeals – Arizona v. Smith Introduction Arizona v. Herbert Allen Smith is a pivotal case decided by the Supreme Court of...

Affirming the Applicability of Pecuniary Gain in Death Penalty Sentencing: Analysis of State v. Spears

Date: Jan 5, 1996

Affirming the Applicability of Pecuniary Gain in Death Penalty Sentencing: Analysis of State of Arizona v. Anthony Marshall Spears Introduction In State of Arizona v. Anthony Marshall Spears (184...

MAXWELL v. FIDELITY FINANCIAL SERVICES: Clarifying Unconscionability and Novation in Contract Law

Date: Nov 22, 1995

MAXWELL v. FIDELITY FINANCIAL SERVICES: Clarifying Unconscionability and Novation in Contract Law Introduction In Elizabeth A. MAXWELL v. FIDELITY FINANCIAL SERVICES, Inc., the Supreme Court of...

Affirmation of Conviction and Death Sentence in State v. Gulbrandson: An In-Depth Legal Analysis

Date: Nov 3, 1995

Affirmation of Conviction and Death Sentence in State of Arizona v. Gulbrandson: An In-Depth Legal Analysis Introduction State of Arizona v. David Gulbrandson, 184 Ariz. 46, decided by the Supreme...

State of Arizona v. Murray: Affirmation of Capital Convictions and Procedural Standards

Date: Oct 27, 1995

State of Arizona v. Murray: Affirmation of Capital Convictions and Procedural Standards Introduction In the landmark case of State of Arizona v. Robert Wayne Murray, decided on October 26, 1995, the...