7th Circuit Case Commentaries

Affirmation of Judgment in Murray v. Chicago Transit Authority: Clarifying the Boundaries of Tangible Employment Actions and Hostile Work Environments

Date: May 11, 2001

Affirmation of Judgment in Murray v. Chicago Transit Authority: Clarifying the Boundaries of Tangible Employment Actions and Hostile Work Environments Introduction In the appellate case Lorene F....

Waiver of Timeliness Defense in Title VII Claims: McArthur Ester v. Anthony J. Principi

Date: May 9, 2001

Waiver of Timeliness Defense in Title VII Claims: McArthur Ester v. Anthony J. Principi Introduction In the case of McArthur Ester v. Anthony J. Principi, the Plaintiff-Appellant, McArthur Ester,...

Waiver of Jury Trial and Diversity Jurisdiction in Middle Tennessee News Co. v. Charnel of Cincinnati

Date: May 9, 2001

Waiver of Jury Trial and Diversity Jurisdiction in Middle Tennessee News Co. v. Charnel of Cincinnati Introduction The case of Middle Tennessee News Co., Inc. d/b/a Austin Book and Merchandise v....

Property and Liberty Interests of Public School Principals under the 14th Amendment: Insights from Ulichny v. Merton Community School District

Date: May 8, 2001

Property and Liberty Interests of Public School Principals under the 14th Amendment: Insights from Ulichny v. Merton Community School District Introduction Ulichny v. Merton Community School...

Proper Standards for Class Certification under Federal Rule 23: Insights from Szabo v. Bridgeport Machines

Date: May 5, 2001

Proper Standards for Class Certification under Federal Rule 23: Insights from Szabo v. Bridgeport Machines Introduction The case of John D. Szabo, doing business as Zatron, Plaintiff-Appellee, v....

AAR International v. Nimelias Enterprises: Reversing Abstention under Colorado River Doctrine

Date: Apr 28, 2001

AAR International v. Nimelias Enterprises: Reversing Abstention under Colorado River Doctrine Introduction The case of AAR International, Incorporated v. Nimelias Enterprises S.A., Vacances Heliades...

Judicial Standards for Ex Parte Communications: Ellsworth v. Levenhagen Analysis

Date: Apr 21, 2001

Judicial Standards for Ex Parte Communications: Ellsworth v. Levenhagen Analysis Introduction Edward L. Ellsworth appealed his conviction in Ellsworth v. Levenhagen (248 F.3d 634), challenging the...

Failure to Utilize Peremptory Challenges for Juror Bias Grounds Right to New Trial: Thompson v. Altheimer Gray

Date: Apr 20, 2001

Failure to Utilize Peremptory Challenges for Juror Bias Grounds Right to New Trial: Thompson v. Altheimer Gray Introduction In the landmark case of Rhodda Thompson v. Altheimer Gray, decided by the...

Montenegro v. United States: Clarifying Due Diligence and Statutory Limitations under 28 U.S.C. §2255

Date: Apr 17, 2001

Montenegro v. United States: Clarifying Due Diligence and Statutory Limitations under 28 U.S.C. §2255 Introduction Montenegro v. United States, 248 F.3d 585 (7th Cir. 2001), is a pivotal case that...

Szumny v. American General Finance: Reinforcing TILA's General Disclosure Standards

Date: Apr 14, 2001

Szumny v. American General Finance: Reinforcing TILA's General Disclosure Standards Introduction In Frank J. Szumny, Plaintiff-Appellant v. American General Finance, Incorporated and American...

Strict Adherence to Medicare's Dental Service Exclusions: Wood v. Thompson

Date: Apr 13, 2001

Strict Adherence to Medicare's Dental Service Exclusions: Wood v. Thompson Introduction Wood v. Thompson is a pivotal case adjudicated by the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit on...

Affirmation of Lack of Federal Jurisdiction in Transit Express v. Ettinger

Date: Apr 13, 2001

Affirmation of Lack of Federal Jurisdiction in Transit Express, Inc. v. Ettinger Introduction Transit Express, Incorporated, a for-profit transportation service company based in Wisconsin, challenged...

Limits on Prosecutorial Use of Pre-Arrest Silence: Patricia Ouska v. State

Date: Apr 13, 2001

Limits on Prosecutorial Use of Pre-Arrest Silence: Patricia Ouska v. State Introduction In Patricia Ouska v. Lynn Cahill-Masching, the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit addressed...

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Age and Sex Discrimination Claims: O'Regan v. Arbitration Forums, Inc.

Date: Apr 10, 2001

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Age and Sex Discrimination Claims: O'Regan v. Arbitration Forums, Inc. Introduction In the case of Mary A. O'Regan v. Arbitration Forums, Inc., the plaintiff, Mary...

Enhancing Standards for ALJ Credibility and Residual Functional Capacity Assessments: Insights from Zurawski v. Halter

Date: Apr 7, 2001

Enhancing Standards for ALJ Credibility and Residual Functional Capacity Assessments: Insights from Zurawski v. Halter Introduction The case of Joseph A. Zurawski v. William A. Halter, Acting...

Equal Protection in Municipal Code Enforcement: Analysis of ALBIERO v. CITY OF KANKAKEE

Date: Apr 6, 2001

Equal Protection in Municipal Code Enforcement: Analysis of ALBIERO v. CITY OF KANKAKEE Introduction In the case of Ernest F. ALBIERO v. CITY OF KANKAKEE, the United States Court of Appeals for the...

Protection of Pharmaceutical Communications Under Illinois CFA: Bober v. Glaxo Wellcome

Date: Apr 6, 2001

Protection of Pharmaceutical Communications Under Illinois CFA: Bober v. Glaxo Wellcome Introduction The case of Estelle Bober, Executor of the Estate of Mortimer Bober, on behalf of Mortimer Bober...

Terry Logan v. Caterpillar, Inc.: Establishing the Boundaries of Malicious Prosecution Claims in Employment Disputes

Date: Apr 5, 2001

Terry Logan v. Caterpillar, Inc.: Establishing the Boundaries of Malicious Prosecution Claims in Employment Disputes Introduction The case of Terry Logan v. Caterpillar, Inc. addresses critical...

Assent Through Conduct: Enforceability of Release Waivers in Motorsport Events – BEAVER v. GRAND PRIX KARTING ASSOCIATION

Date: Mar 31, 2001

Assent Through Conduct: Enforceability of Release Waivers in Motorsport Events – BEAVER v. GRAND PRIX KARTING ASSOCIATION Introduction BEAVER v. GRAND PRIX KARTING ASSOCIATION, INC., 246 F.3d 905...

Eighth Amendment Protections in Prisoners' §1983 Actions: Analysis of Syl v. Wynn

Date: Mar 30, 2001

Eighth Amendment Protections in Prisoners' §1983 Actions: Analysis of Syl v. Wynn Introduction Sylvester E. Wynn v. Donna Southward et al., 251 F.3d 588 (7th Cir. 2001), addresses critical issues...