7th Circuit Case Commentaries

Extreme and Outrageous Conduct in Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress: Honaker v. Smith

Date: Jun 27, 2001

Extreme and Outrageous Conduct in Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress: Honaker v. Smith Introduction Fred Honaker, the plaintiff-appellant, initiated legal action against Gary Smith, serving...

Stroe v. Immigration and Naturalization Service: Upholding Procedural Defaults and Limited Counsel Obligations in Deportation Proceedings

Date: Jun 27, 2001

Stroe v. Immigration and Naturalization Service: Upholding Procedural Defaults and Limited Counsel Obligations in Deportation Proceedings Introduction The case of Angela Stroe and Marin Stroe v....

RLA Precludes ADA Claims Requiring CBA Interpretation: An In-Depth Commentary on Brown v. Illinois Central Railroad Co.

Date: Jun 21, 2001

RLA Precludes ADA Claims Requiring CBA Interpretation: An In-Depth Commentary on Brown v. Illinois Central Railroad Co. Introduction In the landmark case of Robert Brown v. Illinois Central Railroad...

Reinforcing Standards for Disparate Treatment and Retaliation Claims under Title VII: Analysis of Dana Hoffman-Dombrowski v. Arlington International Racecourse

Date: Jun 20, 2001

Reinforcing Standards for Disparate Treatment and Retaliation Claims under Title VII Dana Hoffman-Dombrowski v. Arlington International Racecourse, Inc., 254 F.3d 644 (7th Cir. 2001) Introduction In...

Seventh Circuit Limits FLSA Claims Against State Officials in Personal Capacity

Date: Jun 16, 2001

Seventh Circuit Limits FLSA Claims Against State Officials in Personal Capacity Introduction In Roger Luder, et al. v. Jeffrey P. Endicott, et al., 253 F.3d 1020 (7th Cir. 2001), the United States...

Clay v. Holy Cross Hospital: Affirmation Reinforces Pretext Requirements in Title VII Pregnancy Discrimination Claims

Date: Jun 15, 2001

Clay v. Holy Cross Hospital: Affirmation Reinforces Pretext Requirements in Title VII Pregnancy Discrimination Claims Introduction In the case of Pamela R. Clay v. Holy Cross Hospital, decided by the...

Garza v. Lappin: Defining the Boundaries of Habeas Corpus Petitions Under §2241

Date: Jun 15, 2001

Garza v. Lappin: Defining the Boundaries of Habeas Corpus Petitions Under §2241 Introduction Juan Raul Garza, the petitioner-appellant, faced execution after being convicted of multiple federal...

Continuing Violation Doctrine in §1983 Claims: Heard v. Sheahan Analysis

Date: Jun 14, 2001

Continuing Violation Doctrine in §1983 Claims: Heard v. Sheahan Analysis Introduction Heard v. Sheahan, 253 F.3d 316 (7th Cir. 2001), is a pivotal case in the realm of prisoners' civil rights,...

Interpreting 'Located' in 28 U.S.C. § 1348: National Bank Citizenship for Diversity Jurisdiction – Firstar Bank v. Faul

Date: Jun 14, 2001

Interpreting 'Located' in 28 U.S.C. § 1348: National Bank Citizenship for Diversity Jurisdiction – Firstar Bank v. Faul Introduction Firstar Bank, N.A. v. Lawrence J. Faul and Faul Chevrolet is a...

Yellow Freight v. EEOC: Limits on ADA Protections for Erratic Attendance

Date: Jun 13, 2001

Yellow Freight v. EEOC: Limits on ADA Protections for Erratic Attendance Introduction In the landmark case Equal Employment Opportunity Commission v. Yellow Freight Systems, Inc., adjudicated by the...

Enforceability of Mutual Releases in §1983 Claims: Insights from the Seventh Circuit in Anthony H. Dye v. William B. Wargo, Jr. et al.

Date: Jun 12, 2001

Enforceability of Mutual Releases in §1983 Claims: Insights from the Seventh Circuit in Anthony H. Dye v. William B. Wargo, Jr. et al. Introduction The case of Anthony H. Dye v. William B. Wargo,...

Seventh Circuit Affirms Mechanic's Lien Priority for Unionized Workers Despite §301 LMRA Preemption

Date: Jun 8, 2001

Seventh Circuit Affirms Mechanic's Lien Priority for Unionized Workers Despite §301 LMRA Preemption Introduction The case of In re Bentz Metal Products Company, Inc. addressed a pivotal issue...

Reinforcement of Equal Protection Requirements in Racial Profiling Claims: Chavez and Lee v. Illinois State Police

Date: May 24, 2001

Racial Profiling and the Equal Protection Clause: A Comprehensive Analysis of Chavez and Lee v. Illinois State Police Introduction The appellate case of Peso Chavez and Gregory Lee v. Illinois State...

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Employment Discrimination: Wolf v. Northwest Indiana Symphony Society

Date: May 22, 2001

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Employment Discrimination: Wolf v. Northwest Indiana Symphony Society Introduction In the case of John Wolf v. Northwest Indiana Symphony Society, the plaintiff,...

Applying State Procedural Rules to Pre-Removal Actions: Romos v. Gulf Stream Coach

Date: May 22, 2001

Applying State Procedural Rules to Pre-Removal Actions: Romos v. Gulf Stream Coach Introduction In the case of Romos v. Gulf Stream Coach, Inc., the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals addressed...

Jurisdictional Scrutiny in MDL: Insights from Meyers v. Bayer

Date: May 19, 2001

Jurisdictional Scrutiny in MDL: Insights from Meyers v. Bayer Introduction The case of Barbara A. Meyers v. Bayer AG et al., decided by the United States District Court for the Eastern District of...

Understanding 'Materially Adverse Employment Action' Under the ADA: Insights from Kersting v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.

Date: May 19, 2001

Understanding 'Materially Adverse Employment Action' Under the ADA: Insights from Kersting v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. Introduction The case of James Kersting v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. addresses critical...

Statute of Limitations in Section 1983 Claims: Insights from Henderson v. Bolanda

Date: May 17, 2001

Statute of Limitations in Section 1983 Claims: Insights from Henderson v. Bolanda Introduction The case of Carlos Henderson and Charlie Richardson v. Officer Dennis Bolanda serves as a pivotal...

Distinguishing Common Law Fraud from Consumer Fraud Under Illinois Law: Insights from Cozzi Iron Metal, Inc. v. U.S. Office Equipment, Inc.

Date: May 16, 2001

Distinguishing Common Law Fraud from Consumer Fraud Under Illinois Law: Insights from Cozzi Iron Metal, Inc. v. U.S. Office Equipment, Inc. Introduction The case of Cozzi Iron Metal, Inc. v. U.S....

7th Circuit Affirms Summary Judgment: Insufficient Evidence of Pretext in ADEA Discrimination Claim

Date: May 12, 2001

7th Circuit Affirms Summary Judgment: Insufficient Evidence of Pretext in ADEA Discrimination Claim Introduction The case of Michael Rummery versus Illinois Bell Telephone Company revolved around...