6th Circuit Case Commentaries

Defining 'False Claim' under 18 U.S.C. § 287: Sixth Circuit Sets New Precedent

Date: Mar 31, 2004

Defining 'False Claim' under 18 U.S.C. § 287: Sixth Circuit Sets New Precedent Introduction In the landmark case United States v. McBride, adjudicated by the United States Court of Appeals for the...

Reaffirming Standards for Demonstrating Prejudice in New Trial Motions: Tompkin v. Philip Morris USA, Inc.

Date: Mar 31, 2004

Reaffirming Standards for Demonstrating Prejudice in New Trial Motions: Tompkin v. Philip Morris USA, Inc. Introduction In the case of Jocelyn Tompkin, Administratrix with will annexed of the Estate...

Affirmation of Pollution Exclusion in Property Insurance: Pure Tech Systems, Inc. v. Mt. Hawley Insurance Co. & General Star Indemnity Co.

Date: Mar 27, 2004

Affirmation of Pollution Exclusion in Property Insurance: Pure Tech Systems, Inc. v. Mt. Hawley Insurance Co. & General Star Indemnity Co. Introduction In the landmark case of Pure Tech Systems, Inc....

Affirmation of Reasonable Suspicion and Use of Force Standards in Traffic Stops: GADDIS v. REDFORD TOWNSHIP

Date: Mar 27, 2004

Affirmation of Reasonable Suspicion and Use of Force Standards in Traffic Stops: GADDIS v. REDFORD TOWNSHIP Introduction In the landmark case of Joseph GADDIS v. REDFORD TOWNSHIP, decided on March...

Reaffirming Totality of Circumstances in Probable Cause Determinations: Insights from United States v. Woosley

Date: Mar 25, 2004

Reaffirming Totality of Circumstances in Probable Cause Determinations: Insights from United States v. Woosley Introduction The case of United States of America v. Rodney Todd Woosley, 361 F.3d 924...

Attorney’s Fees in Prison Litigation: Navigating the Prison Litigation Reform Act

Date: Mar 18, 2004

Attorney’s Fees in Prison Litigation: Navigating the Prison Litigation Reform Act Introduction The case of Jimmie Lee Riley v. David T. Kurtz (361 F.3d 906) adjudicated by the United States Court of...

Deliberate Indifference in Prison Safety: Greene v. Brigano Establishes New Precedent

Date: Mar 17, 2004

Deliberate Indifference in Prison Safety: Greene v. Brigano Establishes New Precedent Introduction Traci Greene v. Gayle Bowles, et al., Anthony J. Brigano is a significant appellate decision...

Non-Dischargeability of Willful Tax Evasion Confirmed in Gardner Case

Date: Mar 13, 2004

Non-Dischargeability of Willful Tax Evasion Confirmed in Gardner Case Introduction The case of In re Gary Louis Gardner, Debtor. Jeffrey D. Stamper, Executor of the Estate of Gary Louis Gardner,...

Reaffirming the Burden-Shifting Framework in Age Discrimination Cases: Rowan v. Lockheed Martin Energy Systems

Date: Mar 12, 2004

Reaffirming the Burden-Shifting Framework in Age Discrimination Cases: Rowan v. Lockheed Martin Energy Systems 1. Introduction Rowan C. Rowan, III and Charles A. Washington v. Lockheed Martin Energy...

Victim's Appellate Rights Under the Mandatory Victims Restitution Act: Analysis of United States v. Perry

Date: Mar 11, 2004

Victim's Appellate Rights Under the Mandatory Victims Restitution Act: Analysis of United States v. Perry Introduction The case of United States of America v. Anthony P. Perry, decided by the United...

Good-Faith Exception Reinforced in Carpenter Case: Implications for Fourth Amendment Jurisprudence

Date: Mar 10, 2004

Good-Faith Exception Reinforced in Carpenter Case: Implications for Fourth Amendment Jurisprudence Introduction The case of United States of America v. Lonnie D. Carpenter and Sheila J. Carpenter...

Establishing Conspiracy Participation: Insights from United States v. Henley

Date: Mar 6, 2004

Establishing Conspiracy Participation: Insights from United States v. Henley Introduction The case of United States of America v. David E. Henley, Jr., decided by the United States Court of Appeals...

Issue Preclusion and Federal-State Sovereignty: An Analysis of United States v. Dominguez

Date: Mar 5, 2004

Issue Preclusion and Federal-State Sovereignty: An Analysis of United States v. Dominguez Introduction United States of America v. Edward Dominguez, 359 F.3d 839 (6th Cir. 2004), presents a pivotal...

Jefferson v. Jefferson County Public School System: Upholding the Necessity of Proving Inadequate State Remedies in §1983 Procedural Due Process Claims

Date: Mar 5, 2004

Jefferson v. Jefferson County Public School System: Upholding the Necessity of Proving Inadequate State Remedies in §1983 Procedural Due Process Claims Introduction In the landmark case Norma...

Affirmation of District Court's Dismissal in PR Diamonds, Inc. v. John P. Chandler et al.

Date: Mar 4, 2004

Affirmation of District Court's Dismissal in PR Diamonds, Inc. v. John P. Chandler et al. Introduction In the case of PR Diamonds, Inc., et al. v. John P. Chandler, et al. (364 F.3d 671, 6th Cir....

Perjury Conviction Reinforced: United States v. Ryan E. Lee and the Materiality of False Statements

Date: Feb 28, 2004

Perjury Conviction Reinforced: United States v. Ryan E. Lee and the Materiality of False Statements Introduction The case of United States of America v. Ryan E. Lee, decided by the United States...

Affirmation of the Discretionary Function Exception in Federal Tort Claims Act Claims: Montez v. United States

Date: Feb 27, 2004

Affirmation of the Discretionary Function Exception in Federal Tort Claims Act Claims: Montez v. United States Introduction In Montez v. United States, the United States Court of Appeals for the...

Establishing Prima Facie Cases in Employment Discrimination: Insights from DiCARLO v. Potter

Date: Feb 21, 2004

Establishing Prima Facie Cases in Employment Discrimination: Insights from DiCARLO v. Potter Introduction Henry DiCARLO v. John E. Potter, decided on February 20, 2004, by the United States Court of...

Inclusion of Voluntary 401(k) Contributions as Disposable Income in Chapter 7 Dismissals: In re William M. and Dina E. Behlke v. Saul Eisen

Date: Feb 21, 2004

Treatment of Voluntary 401(k) Contributions in Determining Disposable Income for Chapter 7 Dismissals Introduction The case of In re William M. and Dina E. Behlke, Debtors versus Saul Eisen, United...

Admissibility of Reverse Rule 404(b) Evidence in Defense Strategies: United States v. Lucas

Date: Feb 13, 2004

Admissibility of Reverse Rule 404(b) Evidence in Defense Strategies: United States v. Lucas Introduction In United States v. Lucas, 357 F.3d 599 (6th Cir. 2004), the United States Court of Appeals...