2d Circuit Case Commentaries

Reaffirming the Economic-Motive Exception: Cardenas-Zepeda v. Bondi and the Nexus Requirement in Gang-Extortion Asylum Claims

Date: Aug 13, 2025

Reaffirming the Economic-Motive Exception: Cardenas-Zepeda v. Bondi and the Nexus Requirement in Gang-Extortion Asylum Claims 1. Introduction Cardenas-Zepeda v. Bondi, decided by the United States...

Tiered Partnerships and the Two-Year Disguised-Sale Presumption: Lessons from PIMLICO, LLC v. Commissioner (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Aug 13, 2025

Tiered Partnerships and the Two-Year Disguised-Sale Presumption: Lessons from PIMLICO, LLC v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue (2d Cir. 2025) 1. Introduction The Second Circuit’s summary order in...

“Seeing” Is Still Believing: Clear-Error Review of District-Court Findings Based on Video Evidence after United States v. Espinal (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Aug 13, 2025

“Seeing” Is Still Believing: Clear-Error Review of District-Court Findings Based on Video Evidence after United States v. Espinal (2d Cir. 2025) 1. Introduction The Second Circuit’s summary order in...

United States v. Figueroa: Sharpening the Limits of the Cronic Presumption and Client-Autonomy Claims in the Second Circuit

Date: Aug 13, 2025

United States v. Figueroa: Sharpening the Limits of the Cronic Presumption and Client-Autonomy Claims in the Second Circuit Introduction On 11 August 2025 the United States Court of Appeals for the...

The Gardner-Alfred Doctrine: Second Circuit Defines When Courts May Resolve Religious-Accommodation Claims at Summary Judgment and Upholds Robust Discovery-Sanctions Powers

Date: Aug 13, 2025

The Gardner-Alfred Doctrine: Second Circuit Defines When Courts May Resolve Religious-Accommodation Claims at Summary Judgment and Upholds Robust Discovery-Sanctions Powers Introduction In...

When Assets and Liabilities Transfer, So Does Jurisdiction: The Second Circuit’s Landmark Successor-Jurisdiction Doctrine in Lelchook v. Société Générale de Banque au Liban S.A.L. (2025)

Date: Aug 13, 2025

When Assets and Liabilities Transfer, So Does Jurisdiction: The Second Circuit’s Landmark Successor-Jurisdiction Doctrine in Lelchook v. Société Générale de Banque au Liban S.A.L. (2025) Introduction...

United States v. Rodriguez: Mandatory Dismissal of Frivolous In-Forma-Pauperis Appeals From Compassionate-Release Denials

Date: Aug 13, 2025

United States v. Rodriguez: The Second Circuit’s New Directive on Dismissing Frivolous IFP Appeals in the Compassionate-Release Context Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit | August Term 2024 |...

“Dangerousness as a Historical Constant” – The Second Circuit Upholds 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(9) in United States v. Simmons

Date: Aug 13, 2025

“Dangerousness as a Historical Constant” – The Second Circuit Upholds 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(9) in United States v. Simmons 1. Introduction On 11 August 2025 the United States Court of Appeals for the...

“The ‘Before-Trial’ Rule” — Second Circuit Declares Post-Verdict Westfall Act Substitution Barred in Carroll v. Trump

Date: Aug 13, 2025

“The ‘Before-Trial’ Rule” — Second Circuit Declares Post-Verdict Westfall Act Substitution Barred in Carroll v. Trump Introduction In Carroll v. Trump, No. 24-644 (2d Cir. Aug. 8, 2025), the United...

Offensive Claim Preclusion Rebuffed: Second Circuit Clarifies the Limits of Bankruptcy Allowance Orders

Date: Aug 13, 2025

Offensive Claim Preclusion Rebuffed: Second Circuit Clarifies the Limits of Bankruptcy Allowance Orders 1. Introduction In Thermal Surgical, LLC v. Brown, the United States Court of Appeals for the...

Boehringer v. HHS – The Second Circuit Re-Affirms the “Voluntary Participation” Doctrine and Upholds IRA Drug-Price Negotiations

Date: Aug 13, 2025

Boehringer Ingelheim Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Department of Health & Human Services (2d Cir. 2025) Clarifying Voluntary Participation, Unconstitutional Conditions, and APA Exemption under the...

The “Substantial-Interdependence” Rule: Second Circuit Allows Joinder of Fraud and Tax Counts and Declines Per-Se Ineffective-Counsel Claim in United States v. Wynder

Date: Aug 13, 2025

The “Substantial-Interdependence” Rule: Second Circuit Allows Joinder of Fraud and Tax Counts and Declines Per-Se Ineffective-Counsel Claim in United States v. Wynder 1. Introduction In United States...

“Current Asylum Status” as a Condition Precedent to Adjustment of Status: An In-Depth Commentary on Wassily & Velasquez Arreaga v. Bondi (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Aug 13, 2025

“Current Asylum Status” as a Condition Precedent to Adjustment of Status A Comprehensive Commentary on Wassily v. Bondi; Velasquez Arreaga v. Bondi, 2d Cir., 7 Aug 2025 Introduction On 7 August 2025...

Second Circuit Clarifies the Reach of FDCA § 379r(a): Marketing and Pricing Claims for OTC Drugs Are Pre-empted When Success Would Impose Additional Label Requirements

Date: Aug 13, 2025

Second Circuit Clarifies the Reach of FDCA § 379r(a): Marketing and Pricing Claims for OTC Drugs Are Pre-empted When Success Would Impose Additional Label Requirements 1. Introduction In Collaza v....

Second Circuit Flexes Rule 62.1: Appellate Remand Permitted After Sua Sponte Indicative Ruling

Date: Aug 13, 2025

Second Circuit Flexes Rule 62.1: Appellate Remand Permitted After Sua Sponte Indicative Ruling Introduction In Gustavia Home LLC v. Hoyer; Hoyer v. Bank of America, the United States Court of Appeals...

Mosaic Health v. Sanofi-Aventis: A New Blueprint for Pleading Antitrust Conspiracies and Confirming 340B Safety-Net Provider Standing

Date: Aug 13, 2025

Mosaic Health v. Sanofi-Aventis: A New Blueprint for Pleading Antitrust Conspiracies and Confirming 340B Safety-Net Provider Standing 1. Introduction In Mosaic Health, Inc. v. Sanofi-Aventis U.S.,...

The Implicit-Abandonment Rule in Credibility Appeals: A Commentary on Chen v. Bondi (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Aug 7, 2025

The Implicit-Abandonment Rule in Credibility Appeals: How Chen v. Bondi Strengthens Border-Interview Evidence and Clarifies Pattern-or-Practice Proof 1. Introduction Chen v. Bondi, No. 23-6508 (2d...

“Substantively-the-Same” State Tort Claims Survive: Second Circuit Narrows HMTA Pre-emption in DCC Propane LLC v. KMT Enterprises, Inc.

Date: Aug 7, 2025

“Substantively-the-Same” State Tort Claims Survive: Second Circuit Narrows HMTA Pre-emption in DCC Propane LLC v. KMT Enterprises, Inc. 1. Introduction The United States Court of Appeals for the...

“Fairfield Sentry” and the Extraterritorial Safe-Harbor: The Second Circuit Extends § 546(e) to Foreign-Law and Common-Law Claims in Chapter 15 Proceedings

Date: Aug 7, 2025

“Fairfield Sentry” and the Extraterritorial Safe-Harbor: The Second Circuit Extends § 546(e) to Foreign-Law and Common-Law Claims in Chapter 15 Proceedings Introduction The decision in In re...

United States v. Fasasi: Second Circuit Clarifies the Boundaries of Plain-Error Review, Rule 32 PSR Verification, and the “Substantial Overseas Conduct” Fraud Enhancement

Date: Aug 6, 2025

United States v. Fasasi: Second Circuit Clarifies the Boundaries of Plain-Error Review, Rule 32 PSR Verification, and the “Substantial Overseas Conduct” Fraud Enhancement 1. Introduction United...