2d Circuit Case Commentaries

“No Injury, No Standing” – The Second Circuit Mandates Individualized Loss for ERISA 401(k) Plaintiffs in Collins v. Northeast Grocery, LLC

Date: Aug 25, 2025

“No Injury, No Standing” – The Second Circuit Mandates Individualized Loss for ERISA 401(k) Plaintiffs in Collins v. Northeast Grocery, LLC 1. Introduction The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second...

Accrual-Point and Jurisdictional Deference under 28 U.S.C. § 2467: A Commentary on In Re Enforcement of Philippine Forfeiture Judgment

Date: Aug 25, 2025

Accrual-Point and Jurisdictional Deference under 28 U.S.C. § 2467 – Commentary on In Re Enforcement of Philippine Forfeiture Judgment, 24-185(L) (2d Cir. 2025) 1. Introduction On 18 August 2025 the...

Kellogg v. Nichols: The Second Circuit Bars § 1983 Declaratory and Injunctive Relief Against State Judges Serving as Firearms Licensing Officers

Date: Aug 25, 2025

Kellogg v. Nichols: The Second Circuit Bars § 1983 Declaratory and Injunctive Relief Against State Judges Serving as Firearms Licensing Officers 1. Introduction Kellogg v. Nichols, No. 23-8093-cv (2d...

“Proximity-and-Accessibility” as the Determinative Nexus & Plain-Error Limits on Predicate Switching: An In-Depth Commentary on United States v. Prawl (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Aug 25, 2025

“Proximity-and-Accessibility” as the Determinative Nexus & Plain-Error Limits on Predicate Switching: A Comprehensive Commentary on United States v. Prawl (2d Cir. 2025) Introduction United States v....

Second Circuit Re-characterizes § 6213(a) as a Non-Jurisdictional, Equitably-Tollable Deadline

Date: Aug 19, 2025

Second Circuit Redefines the 90-Day Deficiency Deadline: I.R.C. § 6213(a) Deemed Non-Jurisdictional and Subject to Equitable Tolling I. Introduction In Buller v. Commissioner, No. 24-1557 (2d Cir....

“Arbitration in Name Only” – Second Circuit Refines the FAA’s Limits in Flores v. N.Y. Football Giants

Date: Aug 19, 2025

“Arbitration in Name Only” – Second Circuit Refines the FAA’s Limits in Flores v. N.Y. Football Giants 1. Introduction The United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit has delivered a...

Continuances after Patel: Second Circuit Confirms Judicial Review & Re-states the “Good-Cause/Prima-Facie–Eligibility” Test – Commentary on Hernandez Flores v. Bondi (2025)

Date: Aug 19, 2025

Continuances after Patel: Second Circuit Confirms Judicial Review & Re-states the “Good-Cause/Prima-Facie–Eligibility” Test – Commentary on Hernandez Flores v. Bondi (2025) 1. Introduction Hernandez...

Employer Assurances Can Nullify Broad Release: The “Knowing-and-Voluntary” Standard Re-Defined in Schuyler v. Sun Life

Date: Aug 19, 2025

Employer Assurances Can Nullify Broad Release: The “Knowing-and-Voluntary” Standard Re-Defined in Schuyler v. Sun Life Assurance Company of Canada Introduction On 14 August 2025 the United States...

Debit-Card Numbers and PINs as “Means of Identification”: A Commentary on United States v Constantinescu (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Aug 19, 2025

Debit-Card Numbers and PINs as “Means of Identification”: A Structured Commentary on United States v. Constantinescu, 91 F.4th ___ (2d Cir. 2025) 1. Introduction The Second Circuit’s decision in...

Clarifying the Boundary Between Medical Screening and Strip Search: Sanchez v. Binghamton CSD (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Aug 16, 2025

Clarifying the Boundary Between Medical Screening and Strip Search: Sanchez v. Binghamton City School District 1. Introduction Sanchez v. Binghamton City School District, No. 24-2125-cv, decided by...

“Public Reprimand as a Stand-Alone Sanction for Lapsed or Non-Member Counsel” — Commentary on In Re Cruikshank, 22-90079 (2d Cir. Aug. 13, 2025)

Date: Aug 15, 2025

“Public Reprimand as a Stand-Alone Sanction for Lapsed or Non-Member Counsel” Commentary on In Re Cruikshank, 22-90079 (2d Cir. Aug. 13, 2025) 1. Introduction In In Re Cruikshank, the United States...

Clarifying “Cause” for Dismissal of Involuntary Bankruptcy Petitions and the Limits of Appellate Jurisdiction over § 303(i) Fee Awards

Date: Aug 15, 2025

Clarifying “Cause” for Dismissal of Involuntary Bankruptcy Petitions and the Limits of Appellate Jurisdiction over § 303(i) Fee Awards 1. Introduction In Re: Valuex Research, LLC concerns creditors...

Clarifying Prevailing-Party Status and Recognising Joint Trademark Ownership: A Commentary on Zioness Movement, Inc. v. The Lawfare Project, Inc.

Date: Aug 15, 2025

Clarifying Prevailing-Party Status and Recognising Joint Trademark Ownership: Commentary on Zioness Movement, Inc. v. The Lawfare Project, Inc. (2d Cir. 2025) Introduction The Second Circuit's...

“No Legislative Short-Cut to Article III”: The Second Circuit Rejects “Congressionally-Authorized Representational Standing” and Clarifies Mootness Procedure — Commentary on A.H. v. N.Y. State Dep’t of Health

Date: Aug 15, 2025

“No Legislative Short-Cut to Article III”: The Second Circuit Rejects “Congressionally-Authorized Representational Standing” and Clarifies Mootness Procedure — Commentary on A.H. v. N.Y. State Dep’t...

“The Carew Principle” – No Per-Se Duty on Defence Counsel to Pursue a Batson Remedy

Date: Aug 15, 2025

“The Carew Principle” No Per-Se Duty on Defence Counsel to Pursue a Batson Remedy – Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, 2025 1. Introduction In Carew v. Morton, the United States Court of...

“A Single Straw Breaks the Camel’s Back” – Isaacs v. Zimmerman and the Second Circuit’s Zero-Tolerance Approach to Discovery-Order Breaches

Date: Aug 15, 2025

“A Single Straw Breaks the Camel’s Back” – Isaacs v. Zimmerman and the Second Circuit’s Zero-Tolerance Approach to Discovery-Order Breaches Introduction Isaacs v. Zimmerman, No. 23-7492 (2d Cir. Aug....

“The Comma That Wasn’t”: Second Circuit Restores Full Scope of Personal-Injury Liability Insurance and Safe-Harbor Protection in N.Y. Ins. Law § 1113(a)(13) & § 1213(e)

Date: Aug 15, 2025

“The Comma That Wasn’t”: Second Circuit Restores Full Scope of Personal-Injury Liability Insurance and Safe-Harbor Protection in N.Y. Ins. Law § 1113(a)(13) & § 1213(e) 1. Introduction Liberty...

The Post-Chevron Quid-Pro-Quo Doctrine: Second Circuit Affirms IRS Power to Net State Tax Credits against § 170 Charitable Deductions

Date: Aug 15, 2025

The Post-Chevron Quid-Pro-Quo Doctrine: Second Circuit Affirms IRS Power to Net State Tax Credits against § 170 Charitable Deductions Introduction The consolidated appeal New Jersey v. Bessent;...

Extending the Dormant Commerce Clause to Federally-Prohibited Markets: A Commentary on Variscite NY Four, LLC v. New York State Cannabis Control Board

Date: Aug 15, 2025

Extending the Dormant Commerce Clause to Federally-Prohibited Markets: A Commentary on Variscite NY Four, LLC v. New York State Cannabis Control Board (2d Cir. 2025) 1. Introduction Variscite NY...

“Party-Affiliation ≠ State Action” – The Second Circuit’s Re-confirmation of the State-Actor Requirement in Sherpa v. Bondi

Date: Aug 15, 2025

“Party-Affiliation ≠ State Action” – The Second Circuit’s Re-confirmation of the State-Actor Requirement in Sherpa v. Bondi 1. Introduction Sherpa v. Bondi, No. 23-6172 (2d Cir. Aug. 14 2025) is a...