1st Circuit Case Commentaries

Affirming Employer Liability for Hostile Work Environment and Retaliation under Title VII: White v. New Hampshire Department of Corrections

Date: Aug 3, 2000

Affirming Employer Liability for Hostile Work Environment and Retaliation under Title VII: White v. New Hampshire Department of Corrections Introduction In the landmark case Sherri White v. New...

Limits on Successive §2255 Petitions After Statutory Reinterpretation: The Sustache-Rivera Decision

Date: Jul 26, 2000

Limits on Successive §2255 Petitions After Statutory Reinterpretation: The Sustache-Rivera Decision Introduction The case of David Sustache-Rivera v. United States of America (221 F.3d 8) adjudicated...

Enhancing Child Protection in International Abduction: Insights from Walsh v. Walsh

Date: Jul 26, 2000

Enhancing Child Protection in International Abduction: Insights from Walsh v. Walsh Introduction The case of John Walsh v. Jacqueline Walsh and Martha Miller is a seminal decision by the United...

Legislative Immunity Upholds Municipal Ordinance in Employment Disputes

Date: Jul 26, 2000

Legislative Immunity Upholds Municipal Ordinance in Employment Disputes Introduction The case of Felix Figueroa-Serrano, et al. v. Hon. Angel Ramos-Alverio, et al. is a significant appellate decision...

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Williams v. Raytheon: Implications for Discrimination and Retaliation Claims

Date: Jul 22, 2000

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Williams v. Raytheon: Implications for Discrimination and Retaliation Claims Introduction In the landmark case Ralph Williams v. Raytheon Company, 220 F.3d 16 (1st...

Establishing Sufficiency of Circumstantial Evidence in Drug Conspiracy Cases: United States v. Hernández & Gorbea Del-Valle

Date: Jul 18, 2000

Establishing Sufficiency of Circumstantial Evidence in Drug Conspiracy Cases: United States v. Hernández & Gorbea Del-Valle Introduction In the landmark case of United States of America v. José Ramón...

Statute of Limitations in Tort Actions: Torres v. E.I. DuPont de Nemours Company

Date: Jul 18, 2000

Statute of Limitations in Tort Actions: Torres v. E.I. DuPont de Nemours Company Introduction The case of Torres v. E.I. DuPont de Nemours Company adjudicated by the United States Court of Appeals...

Relating Amendments to Original Complaint Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 15(c)(3): Leonard v. Parry

Date: Jul 18, 2000

Relating Amendments to Original Complaint Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 15(c)(3): Leonard v. Parry 1. Introduction The case of Mitchell Leonard v. Kay Parry (219 F.3d 25) adjudicated by the...

Expanded Interpretation of 'Products-Completed Operations Hazard' Exclusion in General Liability Policies

Date: Jul 14, 2000

Expanded Interpretation of 'Products-Completed Operations Hazard' Exclusion in General Liability Policies Introduction The case Brazas Sporting Arms, Inc. v. American Empire Surplus Lines Insurance...

Federal Tax Liens and Trust Interests: Insights from United States v. Murray

Date: Jul 7, 2000

Federal Tax Liens and Trust Interests: Insights from United States v. Murray Introduction United States v. Murray (217 F.3d 46, 2000) is a pivotal case adjudicated by the United States Court of...

Affirmation of Chapter 93A Standards in Reinsurance Contract Disputes

Date: Jul 7, 2000

Affirmation of Chapter 93A Standards in Reinsurance Contract Disputes Introduction The case of Commercial Union Insurance Company, as Successor in Interest to Employers' Surplus Lines Insurance...

Advancing Employment Discrimination Law: Circumstantial Evidence and Contractual Interpretation in Santiago-Ramos v. Centennial P.R. Wireless Corp.

Date: Jul 7, 2000

Advancing Employment Discrimination Law: Circumstantial Evidence and Contractual Interpretation in Santiago-Ramos v. Centennial P.R. Wireless Corp. Introduction Santiago-Ramos v. Centennial P.R....

Federal Courts to Abstain from Pretrial Habeas Corpus Petitions Interfering with State Criminal Proceedings

Date: Jul 4, 2000

Federal Courts to Abstain from Pretrial Habeas Corpus Petitions Interfering with State Criminal Proceedings Introduction The case In re: Justices of the Superior Court Department of the Massachusetts...

Expanding Privity in Rule 41(a)(2) Dismissals: Insights from John Doe v. Urohealth Systems, Inc.

Date: Jun 27, 2000

Expanding Privity in Rule 41(a)(2) Dismissals: Insights from John Doe v. Urohealth Systems, Inc. Introduction John Doe v. Urohealth Systems, Inc. (216 F.3d 157, 2000) is a pivotal case adjudicated by...

Jurisdictional Clarity in ICCTA Claims: Pejepscot Industrial Park v. Maine Central Railroad

Date: Jun 24, 2000

Jurisdictional Clarity in ICCTA Claims: Pejepscot Industrial Park v. Maine Central Railroad 215 F.3d 195, United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, June 23, 2000 Introduction The case of...

ERISA Preemption Revisited: First Circuit Abrogates Prior Holding in Carpenters Local Union No. 26 v. US Fidelity Guaranty Co.

Date: Jun 17, 2000

ERISA Preemption Revisited: First Circuit Abrogates Prior Holding in Carpenters Local Union No. 26 v. US Fidelity Guaranty Co. Introduction The case of Carpenters Local Union No. 26, United...

First Circuit Upholds Conspiracy Conviction and Validates Inmate Call Recording under Title III

Date: Jun 17, 2000

First Circuit Upholds Conspiracy Conviction and Validates Inmate Call Recording under Title III Introduction In the case of United States of America v. Troy Footman, the United States Court of...

Remand for Discovery Completion in Carmona v. Toledo Establishes Judicial Scrutiny on Summary Judgment Motions

Date: Jun 17, 2000

Remand for Discovery Completion in Carmona v. Toledo Establishes Judicial Scrutiny on Summary Judgment Motions Introduction Carmona Carmona, Etc., Plaintiffs, Appellants, v. Pedro A. Toledo, Etc.,...

Clarifying Direct Evidence and Mixed-Motive Jury Instructions in ADEA Cases: Analysis of Clemente Febres v. Challenger Caribbean Corp.

Date: Jun 9, 2000

Clarifying Direct Evidence and Mixed-Motive Jury Instructions in ADEA Cases: Analysis of Clemente Febres v. Challenger Caribbean Corp. 1. Introduction Clemente Febres, A/K/A Clemente Febres-Morales,...

Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies under IDEA: Affirmation in Rose v. Yeaw

Date: Jun 8, 2000

Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies under IDEA: Affirmation in Rose v. Yeaw Introduction The case of Wayne Rose and Donna Rose, individually and as parents and natural guardians of Wayne Rose, Jr.,...