1st Circuit Case Commentaries

Randazzo v. United States: Clarifying Joinder of Unrelated Offenses and Materiality in Criminal Convictions

Date: Apr 9, 1996

Randazzo v. United States: Clarifying Joinder of Unrelated Offenses and Materiality in Criminal Convictions Introduction In United States of America v. G. Robert Randazzo, 80 F.3d 623 (1st Cir....

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Perkins v. Brigham Women's Hospital: Upholding Non-Discriminatory Termination

Date: Apr 6, 1996

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Perkins v. Brigham Women's Hospital: Upholding Non-Discriminatory Termination Introduction In the landmark case of Patrick Perkins v. Brigham Women's Hospital and...

First Circuit Clarifies Clean Air Act Conformity Standards in Base Redevelopment

Date: Apr 3, 1996

First Circuit Clarifies Clean Air Act Conformity Standards in Base Redevelopment Introduction In Conservation Law Foundation, Inc. v. James Busey, the United States Court of Appeals for the First...

Defining 'Hearing' Under the Speedy Trial Act: Insights from United States v. Staula

Date: Mar 30, 1996

Defining 'Hearing' Under the Speedy Trial Act: Insights from United States v. Staula Introduction The case of United States of America v. Stephen J. Staula addresses critical aspects of the Speedy...

Enhanced Standards for Jury Instructions and Responses: United States v. Manning

Date: Mar 22, 1996

Enhanced Standards for Jury Instructions and Responses: United States v. Manning Introduction United States v. Trent Manning is a significant appellate decision from the United States Court of...

Argencourt v. United States: Reinforcing the Strickland Standard for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel under 28 U.S.C. § 2255

Date: Mar 19, 1996

Argencourt v. United States: Reinforcing the Strickland Standard for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel under 28 U.S.C. § 2255 Introduction In the landmark case of Argencourt v. United States, 78 F.3d...

First Circuit Affirms Secondary-Line Price Discrimination under Puerto Rico Law in COASTAL FUELS v. CARIBBEAN PETROLEUM

Date: Mar 13, 1996

First Circuit Affirms Secondary-Line Price Discrimination under Puerto Rico Law in COASTAL FUELS v. CARIBBEAN PETROLEUM Introduction The case of Coastal Fuels of Puerto Rico, Inc. v. Caribbean...

Reasonable Suspicion and Detention Scope: Insights from United States v. McCarthy

Date: Feb 27, 1996

Reasonable Suspicion and Detention Scope: Insights from United States v. McCarthy Introduction The case of United States v. Aedan C. McCarthy and Jeffrey Scott Hunter, adjudicated by the United...

Affirmation of ERISA's Six-Year Statute of Limitations and Fraudulent Concealment Doctrine in Geils Band Employee Benefit Plan v. Smith Barney Shearson

Date: Feb 21, 1996

Affirmation of ERISA's Six-Year Statute of Limitations and Fraudulent Concealment Doctrine in Geils Band Employee Benefit Plan v. Smith Barney Shearson Introduction In the landmark case of J. Geils...

Kathy Smith v. F.W. Morse Co.: Affirming Position Elimination Under Title VII

Date: Feb 13, 1996

Kathy Smith v. F.W. Morse Co.: Affirming Position Elimination Under Title VII Introduction Kathy Smith v. F.W. Morse Co., Inc. is a pivotal case decided by the United States Court of Appeals for the...

Requirement for Expert RFC Assessment in Complex Disability Claims: Manso-Pizarro v. HHS

Date: Feb 9, 1996

Requirement for Expert RFC Assessment in Complex Disability Claims: Manso-Pizarro v. HHS Introduction Victoria Manso-Pizarro v. Secretary of Health and Human Services (76 F.3d 15) is a seminal case...

Federal Tax Liens on Trust Property: Implications of Markham v. Fay

Date: Feb 8, 1996

Federal Tax Liens on Trust Property: Implications of Markham v. Fay Introduction The case Paul F. Markham, Trustee v. Claire M. Fay addresses the complex interplay between federal tax liens and trust...

Reaffirming Exigent Circumstances and Safeguards Against Prosecutorial Overreach in Drug Conspiracy Cases: Insights from United States v. Wihbey and Whitman

Date: Feb 7, 1996

Reaffirming Exigent Circumstances and Safeguards Against Prosecutorial Overreach in Drug Conspiracy Cases: Insights from United States v. Wihbey and Whitman Introduction In the landmark decision of...

Legislative Immunity in Civil Rights Litigation: Romero-Barcelo v. Hernandez-Agosto

Date: Feb 1, 1996

Legislative Immunity in Civil Rights Litigation: Romero-Barcelo v. Hernandez-Agosto Introduction Carlos Romero-Barcelo, the plaintiff and appellant, challenged a district court's dismissal of his...

Enforcing FLSA Compliance in State Employment Contracts: A Commentary on Blackie v. Maine

Date: Jan 31, 1996

Enforcing FLSA Compliance in State Employment Contracts: A Commentary on Blackie v. Maine Introduction Blackie v. Maine, 75 F.3d 716 (1st Cir. 1996), is a pivotal appellate decision that addresses...

Age Discrimination and Pension Implications in Employment Decisions: Lehman v. Prudential Insurance

Date: Jan 23, 1996

Age Discrimination and Pension Implications in Employment Decisions: Lehman v. Prudential Insurance Introduction In the landmark case of Lehman v. Prudential Insurance Company of America, decided by...

Dominique v. Weld: Defining Liberty Interests in Prison Work Release Programs Post-Sandin

Date: Jan 19, 1996

Dominique v. Weld: Defining Liberty Interests in Prison Work Release Programs Post-Sandin Introduction Dominique v. Weld is a significant appellate decision from the United States Court of Appeals...

Affirmation of Warrantless Search under Exigent Circumstances in United States v. Tibolt

Date: Dec 30, 1995

Affirmation of Warrantless Search under Exigent Circumstances in United States v. Tibolt Introduction United States of America v. William R. Tibolt, 72 F.3d 965 (1995), is a pivotal case adjudicated...

Affirming Government Unit Status of Federal Credit Unions under 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(8)

Date: Dec 19, 1995

Affirming Government Unit Status of Federal Credit Unions under 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(8) Introduction The case T I Federal Credit Union v. John Carl DelBonis, 72 F.3d 921 (1st Cir. 1995), addresses the...

Validating Amendment 506: Clarifying 'Offense Statutory Maximum' in Sentencing Guidelines

Date: Dec 7, 1995

Validating Amendment 506: Clarifying 'Offense Statutory Maximum' in Sentencing Guidelines Introduction In the landmark case UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. GEORGE LABONTE, along with associated appeals...