11th Circuit Case Commentaries

No Personal Jurisdiction Through Plaintiff-Selected Counsel: An Analysis of ECB USA, Inc. v. Savencia Cheese USA, LLC

Date: Jul 9, 2025

No Personal Jurisdiction Through Plaintiff-Selected Counsel: ECB USA, Inc. v. Savencia Cheese USA, LLC Introduction On 8 July 2025 the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit decided...

Acevedo Does Not Curtail Bankruptcy Courts’ Power to Retroactively Annul Automatic Stays – A Commentary on Rajesh C. Patel v. Rishi M. Patel (11th Cir. 2025)

Date: Jul 9, 2025

Acevedo Does Not Curtail Bankruptcy Courts’ Power to Retroactively Annul Automatic Stays (Commentary on Rajesh C. Patel v. Rishi M. Patel, 23-12847, 11th Cir., 8 July 2025) I. Introduction The...

“Concrete Proof, Not Conclusory Allegations” – The Eleventh Circuit Tightens the Bad-Faith Exception to Younger Abstention

Date: Jul 8, 2025

“Concrete Proof, Not Conclusory Allegations” – The Eleventh Circuit Tightens the Bad-Faith Exception to Younger Abstention Introduction Belinda Anglon Wells, Calvin Dewayne Wells, and their daughter...

Collateral Estoppel and the Finality of Court-Approved Settlement Agreements: A Commentary on Martha C. Harris v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A.

Date: Jul 8, 2025

Collateral Estoppel and the Finality of Court-Approved Settlement Agreements: A Commentary on Martha C. Harris v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. Introduction The Eleventh Circuit’s unpublished per curiam...

“Time-of-State-Conviction” Reaffirmed: Career-Offender Predicates and United States v. Alacaliph Woodard

Date: Jul 8, 2025

“Time-of-State-Conviction” Reaffirmed: Career-Offender Predicates and United States v. Alacaliph Woodard 1. Introduction The Eleventh Circuit’s unpublished decision in United States v. Alacaliph...

United States v. Angelo Williams: Terse Sentencing Explanations Suffice for Within-Guidelines Sentences under Steiger

Date: Jul 8, 2025

United States v. Angelo Williams: Terse Sentencing Explanations Suffice for Within-Guidelines Sentences under Steiger Introduction United States v. Angelo Williams, No. 24-11023 (11th Cir. July 7,...

United States v. Whidden – Eleventh Circuit Re-Affirms Kushmaul and Clarifies the Categorical Test for § 2252A Recidivist Enhancements

Date: Jul 8, 2025

United States v. Whidden – Eleventh Circuit Re-Affirms Kushmaul and Clarifies the Categorical Test for § 2252A Recidivist Enhancements Introduction In United States v. Donovan E. Whidden, the...

Re-affirming Deferential Appellate Review of Career-Offender Sentences: United States v. Parker

Date: Jul 8, 2025

Re-affirming Deferential Appellate Review of Career-Offender Sentences: United States v. Jessie Anthony Parker Introduction United States v. Jessie Anthony Parker, No. 24-11140 (11th Cir. July 7...

United States v. Andrews – Elevating the “Bona-Fide Doubt” Standard and Closing the Door on Extra-Record Evidence

Date: Jul 8, 2025

United States v. Andrews – Elevating the “Bona-Fide Doubt” Standard and Closing the Door on Extra-Record Evidence 1. Introduction In United States v. Lonnise Andrews, No. 24-10334 (11th Cir. 2025)...

Eleventh Circuit Re-Affirms Due-Process Prerequisites and Magistrate-Referral Authority in § 1983 Habeas-Related Litigation – Commentary on Carlton Smith v. Attorney General, State of Georgia (2025)

Date: Jul 5, 2025

Eleventh Circuit Re-Affirms Due-Process Prerequisites and Magistrate-Referral Authority in § 1983 Habeas-Related Litigation Commentary on Carlton Smith v. Attorney General, State of Georgia, 24-12929...

Eleventh Circuit Clarifies “New-for-Old” Clause: Insurer’s Liability in Marine Hull Policies Is Capped at the Lesser of Repair Cost or Reasonable Value

Date: Jul 5, 2025

Eleventh Circuit Clarifies “New-for-Old” Clause: Insurer’s Liability in Marine Hull Policies Is Capped at the Lesser of Repair Cost or Reasonable Value 1. Introduction In Certain Underwriters at...

“Only De Minimis Force”: The Eleventh Circuit Re-affirms a Narrow Excessive-Force Threshold for School Resource Officers in Glenn v. Britt (2025)

Date: Jul 5, 2025

“Only De Minimis Force”: The Eleventh Circuit Re-affirms a Narrow Excessive-Force Threshold for School Resource Officers in Glenn v. Britt (2025) 1. Introduction Glenn v. Britt, No. 23-11890 (11th...

“Temporal Disconnect” Doctrine: Eleventh Circuit Clarifies that an Employer’s Pre-Existing Decision to Terminate Bars FMLA Interference and Retaliation Liability

Date: Jul 5, 2025

“Temporal Disconnect” Doctrine: Eleventh Circuit Clarifies that an Employer’s Pre-Existing Decision to Terminate Bars FMLA Interference and Retaliation Liability 1. Introduction In Linda Banks v....

“No Prejudice, No Relief” – Eleventh Circuit Clarifies Strickland-Prejudice When Appellate Counsel Omits an Ineffective-Assistance Claim in a Plea/Interlocutory-Appeal Setting

Date: Jul 5, 2025

“No Prejudice, No Relief” – Eleventh Circuit Clarifies Strickland-Prejudice When Appellate Counsel Omits an Ineffective-Assistance Claim in a Plea/Interlocutory-Appeal Setting 1. Introduction In...

FINRA Awards Need Not Detail Subsidiary Issues Absent Joint Request for a Reasoned Decision: Commentary on UBS Financial Services, Inc. of Puerto Rico v. David Efron (11th Cir. 2025)

Date: Jul 5, 2025

FINRA Awards Need Not Detail Subsidiary Issues Absent Joint Request for a Reasoned Decision Commentary on UBS Financial Services, Inc. of Puerto Rico v. David Efron, 23-13879 (11th Cir. July 3 2025)...

“Tapia Does Not Control Compassionate Release”: A Detailed Commentary on United States v. Francisco Saldana (11th Cir. 2025)

Date: Jul 5, 2025

“Tapia Does Not Control Compassionate Release”: A Detailed Commentary on United States v. Francisco Saldana (11th Cir. 2025) 1. Introduction The Eleventh Circuit’s unpublished but significant...

United States v. Simpkins – Eleventh Circuit Clarifies that Courts Need Not Forecast Guideline Consequences When Accepting Waivers and Guilty Pleas

Date: Jul 5, 2025

United States v. Simpkins – Eleventh Circuit Clarifies that Courts Need Not Forecast Guideline Consequences When Accepting Waivers and Guilty Pleas Introduction United States v. Richard Simpkins (No....

Labriola v. Miami-Dade County: Disruption-Based Pickering Balancing and No Compelled-Speech Claim Without Evidence of Actual Compulsion

Date: Jul 4, 2025

Labriola v. Miami-Dade County: Disruption-Based Pickering Balancing and No Compelled-Speech Claim Without Evidence of Actual Compulsion I. Introduction In John Labriola v. Miami-Dade County (11th...

“All Issues Are for the Arbitrator”: Lamonaco v. Experian and the Eleventh Circuit’s Express Recognition that Waiver Can Be Validly Delegated

Date: Jul 4, 2025

“All Issues Are for the Arbitrator”: Lamonaco v. Experian and the Eleventh Circuit’s Express Recognition that Waiver Can Be Validly Delegated 1. Introduction Lamonaco v. Experian Information...

Pinetree Principle: Timely and Methodologically-Sound Expert Evidence Is Essential for Insureds Under All-Risk Policies

Date: Jul 3, 2025

Pinetree Principle: Timely and Methodologically-Sound Expert Evidence Is Essential for Insureds Under All-Risk Policies 1. Introduction The Eleventh Circuit’s unpublished decision in 4539 Pinetree...