Supreme Court Case Commentaries

Pleadings-First Doctrine: Supreme Court Clarifies Mandatory Scrutiny of Pleadings before Allowing Additional Evidence under Order XLI Rule 27 CPC

Date: Aug 24, 2025

Pleadings-First Doctrine: Supreme Court Clarifies Mandatory Scrutiny of Pleadings before Allowing Additional Evidence under Order XLI Rule 27 CPC Introduction In Iqbal Ahmed (Dead) by LRs. & Anr. v....

Kavin v. P. Sreemani Devi (2025) – Lifetime Compensation & Family-Pain Doctrine in Motor Accident Claims

Date: Aug 24, 2025

Kavin v. P. Sreemani Devi (2025) – Supreme Court Establishes the Lifetime Compensation & Family-Pain Doctrine for 100 % Disability Cases 1. Introduction On 22 August 2025, the Supreme Court of India...

“From ‘Prefer’ to ‘Prosecute’: Supreme Court Clarifies Victim-Centric Appellate Rights under Section 372 CrPC”

Date: Aug 24, 2025

“From ‘Prefer’ to ‘Prosecute’: Supreme Court Clarifies Victim-Centric Appellate Rights under Section 372 CrPC” 1. Introduction In Khem Singh (Dead through LRs) v. State of Uttaranchal (now...

“Equal Pay Parity for Contractual Academics” – The New Doctrine from Shah Samir Bharatbhai v. State of Gujarat (2025)

Date: Aug 24, 2025

“Equal Pay Parity for Contractual Academics” – The New Doctrine from Shah Samir Bharatbhai v. State of Gujarat (2025) 1. Introduction The Supreme Court of India, in Shah Samir Bharatbhai & Ors. v....

Supreme Court Clarifies Rule 2(g) of the 1966 Recruitment Rules: Forest Range Officers Brought within the “State Forest Service” for Promotion to the Indian Forest Service

Date: Aug 24, 2025

Supreme Court Clarifies Rule 2(g) of the 1966 Recruitment Rules: Forest Range Officers Brought within the “State Forest Service” for Promotion to the Indian Forest Service Introduction In P. Maruthi...

Strengthening Safeguards Against Uncorroborated Extra-Judicial Confessions – A Commentary on Neelam Kumari v. State of Himachal Pradesh (2025 INSC 1013)

Date: Aug 22, 2025

Strengthening Safeguards Against Uncorroborated Extra-Judicial Confessions – A Commentary on Neelam Kumari v. State of Himachal Pradesh (2025 INSC 1013) Introduction The Supreme Court’s decision in...

Clarifying the Dual Barriers: Supreme Court on Section 195 Cr.P.C. and the Meaning of “Obstruction” under Section 186 I.P.C.

Date: Aug 21, 2025

Clarifying the Dual Barriers: The Supreme Court’s Definitive Ruling on Section 195 Cr.P.C. & the Contours of “Obstruction” under Section 186 I.P.C. (Devendra Kumar v. State (NCT of Delhi) 2025 INSC...

“SBI v. Ramadhar Sao (2025): Re-affirming the Narrow Compass of Judicial Review over Departmental Punishments and Clarifying that No Elaborate Reasons Are Required When the Disciplinary Authority Concurs with the Inquiry Report”

Date: Aug 21, 2025

State Bank of India v. Ramadhar Sao (2025) – Re-affirming the Narrow Compass of Judicial Review over Departmental Punishments and Clarifying that No Elaborate Reasons Are Required When the...

Supreme Court Re-asserts Doctrine of Severability and Individualised Scrutiny in Mass-Cancellation of Appointments

Date: Aug 20, 2025

Supreme Court Re-asserts Doctrine of Severability and Individualised Scrutiny in Mass-Cancellation of Appointments 1. Introduction The Supreme Court’s decision in Pawan Kumar Tiwary v. Jharkhand...

Kalpataru Power v. Vinod (2025): Supreme Court Calls for Statutory Appeal Mechanism under Telegraph-Related Compensation Proceedings

Date: Aug 20, 2025

Kalpataru Power Transmission Ltd. (Now Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.) v. Vinod & Ors. (2025 INSC 1004) “Towards an Appellate Framework for Compensation Disputes under the Indian Telegraph...

“From Agricultural to Civil: Supreme Court Clarifies That a Subsequent Section 143 UPZALR Declaration Confers Civil-Court Jurisdiction”

Date: Aug 20, 2025

From Agricultural to Civil: Supreme Court Clarifies That a Subsequent Section 143 UPZALR Declaration Confers Civil-Court Jurisdiction I. Introduction The Supreme Court’s decision in Mahesh Chand...

Shifting the Onus Back: Supreme Court Re-affirms Prosecution’s Foundational Burden before Invoking Section 411 IPC

Date: Aug 20, 2025

Shifting the Onus Back: Supreme Court Re-affirms Prosecution’s Foundational Burden before Invoking Section 411 IPC 1. Introduction In SD Shabuddin v. State of Telangana (2025 INSC 999) the Supreme...

Doctrine of Movability Reaffirmed: Power-Plant Assets Are Not ‘Goods’ & Press Releases Are Not “Change in Law” – A Comment on Nabha Power Ltd. v. PSPCL (2025 INSC 1002)

Date: Aug 20, 2025

Doctrine of Movability Reaffirmed: Power-Plant Assets Are Not “Goods” & Press Releases Are Not “Change in Law” – Supreme Court Commentary on Nabha Power Ltd. v. Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd....

Dharam Singh v. State of U.P. (2025): Judicial Review of “Financial-Constraint” Refusals and a New Constitutional Duty to Regularise Perennial Daily-Wage Workers

Date: Aug 20, 2025

Dharam Singh v. State of U.P. (2025): Judicial Review of “Financial-Constraint” Refusals and a New Constitutional Duty to Regularise Perennial Daily-Wage Workers 1. Introduction The Supreme Court of...

“From ‘May’ to ‘Shall’” – The Supreme Court Makes the Charged-Officer’s Examination and Disclosure of CVC Advice Mandatory in Departmental Inquiries

Date: Aug 20, 2025

“From ‘May’ to ‘Shall’” – The Supreme Court Makes the Charged-Officer’s Examination and Disclosure of CVC Advice Mandatory in Departmental Inquiries Introduction The decision in K. Prabhakar Hegde v....

The “Proximate-Trigger” Doctrine: Supreme Court Re-calibrates Abetment to Suicide under Section 306 IPC

Date: Aug 19, 2025

The “Proximate-Trigger” Doctrine: Supreme Court Re-calibrates Abetment to Suicide under Section 306 IPC 1. Introduction Criminal Appeal Nos. 2177-2185 of 2024 in Abhinav Mohan Delkar v. State of...

“Once You Approbate, You Cannot Reprobate” – Supreme Court Crystallises Estoppel Against Post-Decree Challenges to Arbitrability

Date: Aug 15, 2025

“Once You Approbate, You Cannot Reprobate” – Supreme Court Crystallises Estoppel Against Post-Decree Challenges to Arbitrability Introduction In Sanjit Singh Salwan & Ors. v. Sardar Inderjit Singh...

“No Monopoly over the Generic”: Supreme Court Clarifies Anti-Dissection, Dominant-Feature and Post-Sale Confusion Doctrines in Pernod Ricard v. Karanveer Singh Chhabra

Date: Aug 15, 2025

“No Monopoly over the Generic” Supreme Court Clarifies Anti-Dissection, Dominant-Feature and Post-Sale Confusion Doctrines in Pernod Ricard India Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. v. Karanveer Singh Chhabra (2025) 1....

Mandatory 30-Day Rent-Deposit Rule under the WBPT Act Re-affirmed: Seventh Day Adventist School v. Ismat Ahmed (2025)

Date: Aug 15, 2025

Mandatory 30-Day Rent-Deposit Rule under the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act Re-affirmed Commentary on Seventh Day Adventist Senior Secondary School v. Ismat Ahmed & Ors. (2025 INSC 984) 1....

“Summons ≠ Proceedings” – The Supreme Court’s Definitive Clarification of Section 6(2)(b) CGST in Armour Security

Date: Aug 15, 2025

“Summons ≠ Proceedings” – The Supreme Court’s Definitive Clarification of Section 6(2)(b) CGST M/S Armour Security (India) Ltd. v. Commissioner, CGST, Delhi East Commissionerate (2025 INSC 982) 1....