Karnataka High Court Case Commentaries

PIL Against Construction on Alleged Playground Fails Where Land Is Duly Allotted and Not Notified Under the KPPOS Act

Date: Jan 22, 2026

PIL Against Construction on Alleged Playground Fails Where Land Is Duly Allotted and Not Notified Under the KPPOS Act 1) Introduction In DR B R AMBEDKAR YOUTH SOCIAL AND CULTURAL WELFARE TRUST v....

Deemed Extension Under Section 8A(3) MMDR Act Is Unavailable Where the Underlying Mining Lease Is Void for Breach of Rule 22-D (Minimum Area)

Date: Jan 20, 2026

Deemed Extension Under Section 8A(3) MMDR Act Is Unavailable Where the Underlying Mining Lease Is Void for Breach of Rule 22-D (Minimum Area) 1. Introduction In M/S SHRI VENKATESHWARA MINERALS v....

Appeals Against Acquittal After the 2005 Amendment: For Bailable IPC Offences, the State Must Appeal to the High Court (Not the Sessions Court)

Date: Jan 15, 2026

Appeals Against Acquittal After the 2005 Amendment: For Bailable IPC Offences, the State Must Appeal to the High Court (Not the Sessions Court) 1) Introduction Case: SRI K KESHAVA v. STATE OF...

Finality of Section 29(2) KIAD Act Negotiated Compensation and Bar on “Site-in-Lieu” Claims Contrary to the BMIC Framework Agreement

Date: Jan 10, 2026

Finality of Section 29(2) KIAD Act Negotiated Compensation and Bar on “Site-in-Lieu” Claims Contrary to the BMIC Framework Agreement Court: High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru Date: 09-01-2026 Case:...

Section 498A/DP Act FIRs Must Not Criminalise “Daily Wear and Tear” of Marriage: Quashing Vague, Omnibus Matrimonial Allegations and Caution Against Coercive Look Out Circulars

Date: Jan 9, 2026

Section 498A/DP Act FIRs Must Not Criminalise “Daily Wear and Tear” of Marriage: Quashing Vague, Omnibus Matrimonial Allegations and Caution Against Coercive Look Out Circulars 1. Introduction Case:...

Bail Parity Not Automatic in NIA Appeals: Foreign National, Alleged Forged Identity Documents & Flight-Risk Justify Refusal Despite Co-accused Bail

Date: Jan 7, 2026

Bail Parity Not Automatic in NIA Appeals: Foreign National, Alleged Forged Identity Documents & Flight-Risk Justify Refusal Despite Co-accused Bail 1. Introduction The decision in AMOL CHANDRA DAS @...

Due Process and Police Surveillance of “Rowdy Sheeters”: Commentary on Sunil Kumar @ Silent Sunil v. State of Karnataka

Date: Dec 11, 2025

Due Process and Police Surveillance of “Rowdy Sheeters”: Commentary on Sunil Kumar @ Silent Sunil v. State of Karnataka 1. Introduction The judgment of the Karnataka High Court in Sunil Kumar @...

Abandonment of Trade Marks of Companies in Liquidation and Jurisdictional Limits under Section 446: Commentary on Boman R. Irani v. Official Liquidator of Ideal Jawa (India) Ltd.

Date: Dec 4, 2025

Abandonment of Trade Marks of Companies in Liquidation and Limits of Company Court Jurisdiction: Commentary on Mr. Boman R. Irani v. The Official Liquidator of M/s Ideal Jawa (India) Ltd. (in...

CGHS Reimbursement for Emergency CRT-D Implantation: Treating Doctors’ Clinical Judgment Prevails Over Ex Post Technical Rejection; Interest and Consideration of Cashless CGHS Mechanism

Date: Dec 4, 2025

CGHS Reimbursement for Emergency CRT-D Implantation: Treating Doctors’ Clinical Judgment Prevails Over Ex Post Technical Rejection; Interest and Consideration of Cashless CGHS Mechanism Case: MRS....

Preventive Externment under Section 163 BNSS: Emergency, Proportionality and Natural Justice in Sri Adrushya Kadeshwara Swamiji v. Deputy Commissioner, Dharwad

Date: Nov 27, 2025

Preventive Externment under Section 163 BNSS: Emergency, Proportionality and Natural Justice in Sri Adrushya Kadeshwara Swamiji v. Deputy Commissioner, Dharwad I. Introduction The decision of the...

Doctrine of Pleasure, Article 14 and Law Officer Appointments: Commentary on Sunil S/o Annappa Sank v. State of Karnataka

Date: Nov 27, 2025

Constraining the Doctrine of Pleasure in Law Officer Appointments: Commentary on Sunil S/o Annappa Sank v. State of Karnataka (Karnataka High Court, 25 November 2025) I. Introduction The decision in...

Eviction as an Extraordinary but Permissible Remedy under Section 23 of the Senior Citizens Act: Commentary on Soumya v. Ratnakumari

Date: Nov 26, 2025

Eviction as an Extraordinary but Permissible Remedy under Section 23 of the Senior Citizens Act: Commentary on Smt. Soumya v. Smt. Ratnakumari 1. Introduction The decision of the Karnataka High Court...

No Limitation on Constitutional Duty to Compensate for Unlawful State Use of Private Land – Commentary on H.P. Ramesh v. State of Karnataka

Date: Nov 26, 2025

No Limitation on Constitutional Duty to Compensate for Unlawful State Use of Private Land – Commentary on Sri H.P. Ramesh v. State of Karnataka 1. Introduction This commentary analyses the decision...

Judicial Facilitation of Altruistic Non‑Directed Living Kidney Donation under the Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues Act, 1994: Commentary on Dr Thankam Subramonian v. The Chairperson, Hospital Based Authorization Committee

Date: Nov 26, 2025

Judicial Recognition and Procedural Facilitation of Altruistic Non‑Directed Living Kidney Donation under THOTA, 1994: Commentary on Dr Thankam Subramonian v. The Chairperson, HBAC, Karnataka High...

Withholding Salary for Work Performed as Unconstitutional “Begar” under Article 23: Commentary on Shri Anil s/o Mallappa Kanawade v. State of Karnataka

Date: Nov 25, 2025

Withholding Salary for Work Actually Performed Amounts to Unconstitutional “Begar” under Article 23: A Commentary on Shri Anil s/o Mallappa Kanawade v. State of Karnataka Court: High Court of...

Autonomous Government-Created Bodies and Pension under KCSRs: Karnataka High Court Clarifies Non-Automatic Pension Entitlement

Date: Nov 20, 2025

Autonomous Government-Created Bodies and Pension under KCSRs: Karnataka High Court Clarifies Non-Automatic Pension Entitlement 1. Introduction The Karnataka High Court’s Division Bench, comprising...

Reaffirming the Bar on Suo Motu Caste Investigations by the Civil Rights Enforcement Cell: Commentary on Sri T.H. Hosamani v. State of Karnataka

Date: Nov 19, 2025

Reaffirming the Bar on Suo Motu Caste Investigations by the Civil Rights Enforcement Cell: Commentary on Sri T.H. Hosamani v. State of Karnataka I. Introduction The decision of the Karnataka High...

No Vested Right to Succession or Transfer of Fair Price Shop Authorizations under Rule 13 of the Karnataka PDS Control Order

Date: Nov 19, 2025

No Vested Right to Succession or Transfer of Fair Price Shop Authorizations under Rule 13 of the Karnataka PDS Control Order 1. Introduction The decision in Lakshmamma v. State of Karnataka, WP No....

Judicial Independence and Transparent Selection for Special Courts: Commentary on Devanand Puttappa Nayak v. State of Karnataka

Date: Nov 18, 2025

Judicial Independence and Transparent Selection for Special Courts: Commentary on Devanand Puttappa Nayak v. State of Karnataka I. Introduction 1. The Case in Context The decision in Devanand...

Locus Standi of RTI Activists to Seek Third‑Party Examination Answer Scripts: Commentary on Intak Raju N v. Karnataka Information Commission

Date: Nov 13, 2025

Locus Standi of RTI Activists to Seek Third‑Party Examination Answer Scripts: Commentary on Intak Raju N v. Karnataka Information Commission Court: High Court of Karnataka, Bengaluru Case: Writ...