Calcutta High Court Case Commentaries

Appeal Against Order Under Section 151 CPC Not Maintainable: Nanalal Varma & Co. v. Gordhandas

Date: May 23, 1964

Appeal Against Order Under Section 151 CPC Not Maintainable: M/S. Nanalal M. Varma & Co. v. Gordhandas Introduction The case M/S. Nanalal M. Varma And Co. (Gunnies) P. Ltd. v. Gordhandas Jerambhai...

Estoppel in Arbitration: Insights from New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Dalmia Iron and Steel Ltd.

Date: May 20, 1964

Estoppel in Arbitration: Insights from New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Dalmia Iron and Steel Ltd. Introduction The case of New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Dalmia Iron and Steel Ltd. adjudicated by...

Surendranath Paul v. Union of India: Guidelines on Arbitrator Appointment and Continuity

Date: Apr 30, 1964

Surendranath Paul v. Union of India: Guidelines on Arbitrator Appointment and Continuity Introduction In the landmark case of Surendranath Paul v. Union of India, adjudicated by the Calcutta High...

Estoppel by Negligence in Share Ownership: Sm. Sumitra Debi Jalan v. Satya Narayan Prahladka And Others

Date: Mar 27, 1964

Estoppel by Negligence in Share Ownership: Sm. Sumitra Debi Jalan v. Satya Narayan Prahladka And Others 1. Introduction The case of Sm. Sumitra Debi Jalan v. Satya Narayan Prahladka And Others...

Determining Permanent Structures and Notice Requirements in Tenancy Law: Insights from Suraya Properties Pvt. Ltd. v. Bimalendu Nath Sarkar

Date: Mar 21, 1964

Determining Permanent Structures and Notice Requirements in Tenancy Law: Insights from Suraya Properties Pvt. Ltd. v. Bimalendu Nath Sarkar Introduction The case of M/S. Suraya Properties Private...

Readiness and Willingness in Specific Performance Suits: Saral Kumar Chatterjee v. Madhusudan Auddy

Date: Mar 21, 1964

Readiness and Willingness in Specific Performance Suits: Saral Kumar Chatterjee v. Madhusudan Auddy Introduction The case of Saral Kumar Chatterjee v. Madhusudan Auddy (Calcutta High Court, 1964) is...

Defining Tenancy Under Renewal Clauses: Insights from Lalit Mohan Dey v. Smt. Satadalbasini Dasi

Date: Mar 17, 1964

Defining Tenancy Under Renewal Clauses: Insights from Lalit Mohan Dey v. Smt. Satadalbasini Dasi Introduction The case of Lalit Mohan Dey v. Smt. Satadalbasini Dasi, adjudicated by the Calcutta High...

Valuation of Non-Saleable Shares under the Gift Tax Act: Insights from Gift Tax Officer v. Kastur Chand Jain

Date: Mar 17, 1964

Valuation of Non-Saleable Shares under the Gift Tax Act: Insights from Gift Tax Officer v. Kastur Chand Jain 1. Introduction The case of Gift Tax Officer v. Kastur Chand Jain adjudicated by the...

Jurisdiction to Extend Time in Injunction Orders: An Analysis of Bokaro And Ramgur Ltd. v. State Of Bihar

Date: Mar 11, 1964

Jurisdiction to Extend Time in Injunction Orders: An Analysis of Bokaro And Ramgur Ltd. v. State Of Bihar Introduction The case of Bokaro And Ramgur Ltd. v. State Of Bihar & Ors. adjudicated by the...

Adjoining Owner's Right to Injunction for Municipal Rules Violation: Krishna Kali Mallik v. Babulal Shaw & Ors.

Date: Mar 3, 1964

Adjoining Owner's Right to Injunction for Municipal Rules Violation: Krishna Kali Mallik v. Babulal Shaw & Ors. Introduction In the landmark case of Krishna Kali Mallik v. Babulal Shaw & Ors.,...

Extinction of Claims Under Carriage of Goods by Sea Act: A Comprehensive Analysis of Textiles And Yarn (P) Ltd. v. Indian National Steamship Co. Ltd.

Date: Jan 30, 1964

Extinction of Claims Under Carriage of Goods by Sea Act: A Comprehensive Analysis of Textiles And Yarn (P) Ltd. v. Indian National Steamship Co. Ltd. Introduction Case: Textiles And Yarn (P) Ltd. v....

Affirming Reassessment Under Section 34(1)(a) for Material Nondisclosure: Gurdayal Berlia v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax

Date: Jan 11, 1964

Affirming Reassessment Under Section 34(1)(a) for Material Nondisclosure: Gurdayal Berlia v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax Introduction The case of Gurdayal Berlia v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax,...

Substitution of Heirs in Appeals Against Deceased Respondents: State Of West Bengal v. Manisha Maity & Ors.

Date: Dec 18, 1963

Substitution of Heirs in Appeals Against Deceased Respondents: State Of West Bengal v. Manisha Maity & Ors. Introduction The case of State Of West Bengal v. Manisha Maity & Ors. adjudicated by the...

Proper Representation of Minors in Rent Suits: Insights from Nirmal Chandra Ray & Ors. v. Khandu Ghose & Ors.

Date: Dec 17, 1963

Proper Representation of Minors in Rent Suits: Insights from Nirmal Chandra Ray & Ors. v. Khandu Ghose & Ors. Introduction The case of Nirmal Chandra Ray & Ors. v. Khandu Ghose & Ors. adjudicated by...

Two Separate Appeals Required Against Composite Orders under Section 23(4) – Analysis of Messrs Fuel Supply Co. v. Commissioner Of Income Tax

Date: Dec 7, 1963

Two Separate Appeals Required Against Composite Orders under Section 23(4) – Analysis of Messrs Fuel Supply Co. v. Commissioner Of Income Tax Introduction The case of Messrs Fuel Supply Co. v....

Balancing Fair Inquiry and Protection of Public Servants: A Comprehensive Analysis of Golam Mohiuddin v. State Of West Bengal & Ors.

Date: Dec 4, 1963

Balancing Fair Inquiry and Protection of Public Servants: A Comprehensive Analysis of Golam Mohiuddin v. State Of West Bengal & Ors. Introduction The case of Golam Mohiuddin v. State Of West Bengal &...

Assessment of Rent Income under Section 9 vs Section 10 of the Income-tax Act, 1922: Indian City Properties Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-Tax (Calcutta High Court, 1963)

Date: Sep 20, 1963

Assessment of Rent Income under Section 9 vs Section 10 of the Income-tax Act, 1922: Indian City Properties Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-Tax (Calcutta High Court, 1963) Introduction The case of...

Abuse of Process in Winding Up Petitions: Sulekha Works Ltd., In Re

Date: Sep 20, 1963

Abuse of Process in Winding Up Petitions: Sulekha Works Ltd., In Re Introduction Sulekha Works Ltd., In Re is a landmark judgment delivered by the Calcutta High Court on September 19, 1963. The case...

The Limits of Consignee Rights: Clarifying Actionability in Railway Receipt Disputes

Date: Sep 20, 1963

The Limits of Consignee Rights: Clarifying Actionability in Railway Receipt Disputes Introduction The case of Commissioners For The Port Of Calcutta v. General Trading Corporation Ltd. & Anr....

Partial Imposition of Estate Duty under Section 10 of the Estate Duty Act, 1953: Insights from Rash Mohan Chatterjee & Ors. v. Controller Of Estate Duty

Date: Sep 19, 1963

Partial Imposition of Estate Duty under Section 10 of the Estate Duty Act, 1953: Insights from Rash Mohan Chatterjee & Ors. v. Controller Of Estate Duty Introduction The case of Rash Mohan Chatterjee...