AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Acts
  • rule 14 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004
  • rule 2(e) of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004
  • rule 2(e) of the Credit Rules,
  • rule 6 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004
  • 1-4-2011; provisions of Rule 6
  • Rule 2(e)
  • rule 3 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004;
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Acts
  • rule 14 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004
  • rule 2(e) of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004
  • rule 2(e) of the Credit Rules,
  • rule 6 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004
  • 1-4-2011; provisions of Rule 6
  • Rule 2(e)
  • rule 3 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004;
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    PIDILITE INDUSTRIES LTD v. COMMISSIONER CGST AND CENTRAL EXCISE-BELAPUR

    CUSTOMS, EXCISE AND SERVICE TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL

    MUMBAI

    WEST ZONAL BENCH

    EXCISE APPEAL NO: 87173 OF 2015

    [Arising out of Order-in-Original No: Belapur/03-04/Taloja/R-I/COMMR/SFA/ 2015-16 dated 26thJune 2015 passed by the Commissioner of Central Excise & Customs, Belapur.]

    Pidilite Industries Limited

    Plot No. 19, MIDC, Taloja, Dist: Raigad - 412208 … Appellant versus

    Commissioner of CGST and Central Excise Belapur

    CGO Complex, CBD Belapur, Navi Mumbai - 400614

    …Respondent

    WITH

    EXCISE APPEAL NO: 87180 OF 2015

    [Arising out of Order-in-Original No: Belapur/03-04/Taloja/R-I/COMMR/SFA/ 2015-16 dated 26thJune 2015 passed by the Commissioner of Central Excise & Customs, Belapur.]

    Pidilite Industries Limited

    Plot No. B-35/36, MIDC, Taloja, Dist: Raigad - 412208 … Appellant versus

    Commissioner of CGST and Central Excise Belapur

    CGO Complex, CBD Belapur, Navi Mumbai - 400614

    …Respondent

    APPEARANCE:

    Shri Mihir Mehta, Advocate for the appellant Shri Hemant Kumar Tantia, Joint Commissioner (AR) for the respondent

    CORAM:

    HON'BLE MR C J MATHEW, MEMBER (TECHNICAL) HON'BLE MR AJAY SHARMA, MEMBER (JUDICIAL)

    1

    FINAL ORDER NO: 86797-86798/2025

    DATE OF HEARING: 24/09/2025

    DATE OF DECISION: 24/09/2025

    PER: CJ MATHEW

    M/s Pidilite Industries Limited was proceeded against for recovery of ₹ 4,14,00,774 under rule 14 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 in connection with credit distributed by their head-office, as 'input service distributor (ISD)', between April 2007 to November 2011, after excluding tax of ₹ 13,37,34,363 on 'input service' that was not availed during the period on their own estimation of inadmissibility, to two units to the extent of 'input service' exclusively consumed by each and of common services not attributable exclusively to manufacture of exempted goods or for trading activities by either. The order1of Commissioner of Central Excise & Customs, Belapur limiting the liability to ₹ 2,75,68,443, comprising of ₹ 2,43,51,720 being services utilized in common and ₹ 32,16,723 for lack of nexus between 'input service' and manufacturing activities, is impugned before us.

    2. Learned Counsel for appellant made several submissions on the erroneous conclusions leading to recovery of credit but, compellingly, intimated that an identical dispute arising from four notices for the same

    1 [order-in-original no. Belapur/03-04/Taloja/R-I/COMMR/SFA/ 201 5-1 6 dated 26 th June 201 5]

    2

    period in connection with two factories at Mahul and one each in Kamothe and Panvel decided by the Tribunal was applicable to the present dispute pertaining to two units at Taloja.

    3. We have heard Learned Authorized Representative.

    4. On perusal of the order2of Tribunal disposing off appeal3against order4of Commissioner of Central Excise & Customs, Raigad, the legality of the order was decided in the context of framework of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 and precedent judicial decisions thus. '9. Having submitted the rival submissions to careful consideration, we find that the dispute pertains to credit of tax paid on 'input services', and deployed in common, having been availed by the head office and distributed to the four factories without excluding that attributable to 'traded goods' which were neither taxable nor exempt service during the relevant period. There is no further dispute on eligibility to credit under rule 3 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004; it is only the applicability of rule 6 therein to such credit, as was distributed under rule 7 therein, that is. The claim of the central excise authorities is that 'trading' - deemed to be 'exempted service' by insertion of Explanation in rule 2(e) of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 by notification dated 1st March 2011 - was never 'taxable' and that, notwithstanding its specific inclusion in the Rules from 1st April 2011 solely for clarification, the obligation to neutralise retention of credit by recourse to rule 6 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 did always exist.

    2 [final order no. 85959-85964/2 02 4 dated 2 nd September 2 02 4]

    3 [excise appeal no. 85818 to 85821and 86254 to 86255 of 2015]

    4 [order-in-original no. 100/MAK(100)COMMR/RGD/2014 -15 dated 07 th January 2015]

    3

    10. The adjudicating authority relied upon the decision of the Tribunal in Metro Shoes Pvt Ltd v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Mumbai -I [2008-TIOL-417-CESTST-MUM] which, being upon utilisation of credit of tax paid on services used entirely for trading, does not fit the factual matrix of the present dispute. The decision of the Tribunal in Orion Appliances Limited v. Commissioner of Service Tax, Ahmedabad [2010-TIOL-752-CESTAT-AHM], relied upon in the impugned order, which approached the issue as one of 'trading' not being taxable service or dutiable goods and on the further admitted position of non-provisioning of mechanism for neutralization, has, since the decision in re Mercedes Benz India Pvt Ltd, ceased to be applicable law.

    11. The decision of the Tribunal in Mercedes Benz India Pvt Ltd v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Pune-I [2014-TIOL- 476-CESTAT-MUM], relied upon in the adjudication order, was disposed off on challenge before the Hon'ble High Court of Bombay by remand back to the Tribunal owing to which it no longer is good law; furthermore, the Tribunal, in disposing off the remand, set aside the order of the original authority for further remand back. Per contra, the decision of the Tribunal in Ingersoll Rand Technologies and Services Private Ltd v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Ghaziabad [2022 (8) TMI 877- CESTAT ALLAHABAD], has held that

    '18. It is clear from the definition of 'exempted services' w.e.f. 1-4-2011 that 'exempted services' included trading. The issue that arises for consideration is whether the Explanation to rule 2(e) is prospective in nature as submitted by the appellant or it merely clarifies that trading activities were always an 'exempted service', as is contended by the department.

    19. To understand the scope of 'Explanation', it would be useful to refer to the decision of the Supreme Court in Sedco Forex. The Supreme Court clarified that if Explanation' widens the scope of the main provision, then it would be presumed to have only prospective effect, unless a contrary intention is expressed by the legislature. The same

    4

    view was expressed by the Supreme Court in Martin Lottery. The Supreme Court, in effect, held that the use of the phrases, 'it is hereby declared' or 'removal of doubts', in itself will not enable a presumption to be drawn that the Explanation is retrospective.

    20. The Tribunal in Trent Hypermarket, while dealing with the definition of 'exempted service' under rule 2(e) of the Credit Rules, held that trading cannot be treated as an 'exempted service' for the period prior to 1-4-2011 and the Explanation added on 1-4-2011 was prospective and not retrospective. The relevant portion of the decision is reproduced below:

    "5.5 It is evident from the amending provisions of Cenvat statute w.e.f. 1-3-2011 that a substantive law was enacted to consider the activities of trading as an exempted service. Now the issue remains for resolution, as to whether, such amendment in the statutory provisions is to be construed as retrospective in effect or prospective, in order to be given effect to. In this context, the law is amply clear that if a substantive law is introduced, the date of effect of the instrument through which the decision of legislation was conveyed should be considered as the relevant date, when the same was issued or published in the official gazette for the knowledge of the general public. In this contest, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Martin Lottery Agencies Ltd. (supra) have ruled that by reason of an explanation, a substantive law may also be introduced and if a substantive law is introduced, it will have no retrospective effect. We find that the Hon'ble Madras High Court in the case of Ruchika Global Interlinks (supra) have held that inclusion in Explanation to Rule 2(e) "trading" was only clarificatory. It is further observed that the arguing counsels before the Hon'ble Madras High Court did not refer to or relied upon the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Martin Lottery Agencies Ltd. (supra). Since, the law is well settled by the Hon'ble Apex Court in context with retrospective or prospective operation of the statute, the principles enunciated in the case of Martin Lottery Agencies Ltd. (supra) will be considered as the guiding factor for deciding the issue involved in the present case.

    5.6 In view of the above discussions, we do not find any infirmity in the findings recorded in the impugned order, holding that amendment to Rule 2(e) by Notification No. 3/2011-C.E.(N.T.) dated 1-3-2011 will have the prospective effect and cannot be applied retrospectively. Thus, we do not find any merits in the appeal filed by the appellant." (emphasis supplied)

    21. The same view was expressed by the Tribunal in Lenovo (India) and the relevant paragraph is reproduced below:

    "7. We find that for the period 1-4-2011, the issue stands decided in the case of Mercedes Benz India Pvt. Ltd. (supra) wherein it was held that trading is not an exempted service prior to 1-4-2011; provisions of Rule 6 requiring reversal of 6% of trading turnover is not applicable."

    5

    22. It is, therefore, clear that trading was not an 'exempted service' prior to 1-4-2011. The demand confirmed in the impugned order cannot, therefore, be sustained and is liable to be set aside.'

    The issue agitated by the appellant-Commissioner is, thus, no longer res integra. Prior to 1st April 2011, 'trading' was not an 'exempted service' and the appellant was not obliged to comply with the mandate of rule 6 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 for the relevant period.

    12. In the light of our findings supra, the demands in their present form do not survive. As the notices impugned in the dispute pertain to recovery of distributed credit which is a consequence of availment, that is now held as proper, the issue of whether any recovery remains as enforceable needs ascertaining and the original authority is entrusted with such ascertainment in remand proceedings limited to this direction.'

    5. In view of resolution of that dispute arising from identical circumstances, we deem it appropriate to set aside the impugned order and remand the dispute herein also to the original authority for fresh determination in accordance with the provisions of law and judicial decisions.

    6. Appeals are allowed by way of remand. (Operative part of the order pronounced in open court on 24th September 2025)

    (AJAY SHARMA)

    Member (Judicial)

    (C J MATHEW)

    Member (Technical)

    */as

    6

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    PIDILITE INDUSTRIES LTD v. COMMISSIONER CGST AND CENTRAL EXCISE-BELAPUR
    (Sep 24, 2025)