Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Rule 14 of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 read with Sec. 11AB of the Central Excise Act, 1944.
  • provisions of Rule 14 of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 read with Sec. 11A of the Central Excise Act, 1944
  • Rule 15 of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 read with Section 11AC of Central Excise Act, 1944.23(d). M/s.
  • CENTRAL EXCISE ACT 1944
  • Rule 2(l) of the Central Excise Rules, 2004
  • Rule 3 of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004
  • Rule 2(l) of the Cenvat Credit Rules.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Rule 14 of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 read with Sec. 11AB of the Central Excise Act, 1944.
  • provisions of Rule 14 of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 read with Sec. 11A of the Central Excise Act, 1944
  • Rule 15 of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 read with Section 11AC of Central Excise Act, 1944.23(d). M/s.
  • CENTRAL EXCISE ACT 1944
  • Rule 2(l) of the Central Excise Rules, 2004
  • Rule 3 of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004
  • Rule 2(l) of the Cenvat Credit Rules.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Tribunal Order (per M.V. Ravindran, Member (J))

Factual and Procedural Background

Metro Shoes Pvt. Ltd. (the appellant) manufactured branded footwear in its factory and cleared those goods to retail showrooms owned by the appellant. The appellant availed Cenvat credit on service tax paid for various input services (including commissions to retail agents, advertising, clearing & forwarding charges, telephone, internet, courier, postage, etc.) under Rule 3 of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004. The adjudicating authority concluded that certain service tax credits claimed were ineligible because the services were post-manufacture (subsequent to clearance from the place of removal). A show cause notice dated 6-11-2006 demanded recovery of Cenvat credit of Rs. 78,50,491/- (including education cess) under Rule 14 read with Section 11A of the Central Excise Act, 1944, proposed penalty under Section 11AC, and interest under Section 11AB.

The adjudicating authority, by Order-in-Original No. 1/M-I/2007 dated 27-2-2007, confirmed the demand of Rs. 78,50,491/-, appropriated amounts deposited by the appellant, imposed a penalty of Rs. 78,50,491/- under Rule 15 read with Section 11AC, and directed recovery of interest under Section 11AB. The appellant appealed to the Tribunal challenging the reversal of Cenvat credit and the penalty.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether service tax paid on services used up to the retail showrooms owned by the manufacturer (and thus used "in or in relation to the manufacture of final products and clearance of final products from the place of removal") is eligible as Cenvat input service credit under Rule 2(l) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004.
  2. Whether service tax credit claimed on services that are "directly and wholly attributable to trading activities" (i.e., purchased for trading by the retail showroom) is eligible as input service credit.
  3. Whether penalty under Section 11AC is leviable where the principal issue is interpretation of the statutory definition of "input service."
  4. Whether interest under Section 11AB is payable on any confirmed demands.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant manufactured footwear at its factory and cleared the goods to showrooms owned by the appellant; therefore showrooms are the place of removal, and sales occur for the first time at those showrooms.
  • Service tax on commissions and other services for activities up to the showrooms is directly or indirectly used in or in relation to manufacture and clearance up to the place of removal, and thus eligible as input service credit under Rule 2(l) (relying on the inclusive part of the definition).
  • The services in question (commission, advertising, transportation, warehousing, overheads like internet, security, postage, courier, etc.) relate to goods manufactured by the appellant and hence the credit availed was correct.
  • The demand confirmed by the adjudicating authority should be set aside in its entirety.

Respondent's (Revenue) Arguments (Ld. SDR)

  • The services provided by commission agents and other retail-related services do not fall within the statutory definition of "input service" because they are utilized after the clearance of the final product from the factory; once clearances have taken place, input service credit does not arise.
  • The adjudicating authority correctly denied credit where services were post-manufacture or were not in relation to manufacture/clearance of final products.
  • The definition of input service must be read as a whole and should not be fragmented to allow ineligible credits.
  • Relied upon a Tribunal judgment in Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. to support the proposition that input service stage credit is not available once clearances have taken place.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. (Tribunal decision) Principle that once clearances have taken place the question of granting input service stage credit does not arise. The decision was relied upon by the Revenue to support denial of credit for services said to be post-manufacture. The Tribunal considered this precedent as part of submissions but conducted its own statutory interpretation of Rule 2(l) and did not adopt the precedent as overriding: it accepted the Revenue's proposition only to the extent of services directly and wholly attributable to trading activities, while allowing credit for services used up to the place of removal (showrooms owned by the manufacturer).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal focused on the statutory definition of "input service" in Rule 2(l) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004. The definition as reproduced in the order contains multiple parts; the Tribunal observed that the first part (services used by a provider of taxable service to provide an output service) was not in issue. The contest centered on the second part concerning services "used by the manufacturer, whether directly or indirectly, in or in relation to the manufacture of final products and clearance of final products from the place of removal."

The Tribunal applied a plain reading of that second part and reached the following analytical steps:

  • It was undisputed that the appellant manufactured shoes in its factory and cleared the same to showrooms owned by the appellant, and that the first sale took place at those showrooms (i.e., sales did not occur at the factory).
  • Given that the showrooms owned by the appellant are the places where sale occurs for the first time, the Tribunal treated those showrooms as the "place of removal."
  • Accordingly, services used by the appellant up to the place of removal (examples given in the order: goods transport agency services, warehousing, clearing & forwarding agents, insurance, internet services, security, courier, telecom, pest control, bank services, etc.) were considered "used by the manufacturer ... in or in relation to the manufacture of final products and clearance of final products from the place of removal." Service tax on such services is therefore eligible as input service credit.
  • However, the Tribunal distinguished services that are "directly and wholly attributable to trading activities." Where the appellant had purchased goods for trading (i.e., not manufactured by it), the definition of input service (which is confined to services used "in respect of manufacture" and clearance of the final product) does not apply. Thus, service tax credit attributable to trading activities is ineligible.
  • On penalty under Section 11AC, the Tribunal reasoned that the central controversy was one of statutory interpretation. Because the matter involved interpretation of the law rather than clear-cut wrongful availment, penalty under Section 11AC would not arise and the penalty imposed by the adjudicating authority was therefore not sustainable.
  • Regarding interest, since the Tribunal upheld the demand portion that related to trading-attributable services, interest under Section 11AB was held payable on that confirmed demand amount.

Holding and Implications

Core Rulings:

  • The Tribunal held that input service credit is available for services used by the manufacturer up to the place of removal (here, the appellant's own retail showrooms) — and thus service tax on such services is eligible as Cenvat credit.
  • The Tribunal upheld the adjudicating authority's denial of credit only in respect of services that are directly and wholly attributable to trading activities (amounting to Rs. 13,27,497/-).
  • The penalty imposed under Section 11AC was set aside on the ground that the primary issue was one of statutory interpretation.
  • The appellant is liable to pay interest under Section 11AB on the confirmed demand of Rs. 13,27,497/-.

Implications and practical effect:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The Tribunal allowed the appeal in part — it disallowed the appeal to the extent of Rs. 13,27,497/- (demand and interest payable), but restored eligibility for credit for other service tax amounts that pertained to services used up to the place of removal. The penalty equal to the demand was vacated.
  • The order clarifies that, on the facts before it, where a manufacturer owns showrooms and the first sale occurs at such showrooms, those showrooms constitute the place of removal for the purpose of input service credit entitlements under Rule 2(l). Conversely, services directly and wholly attributable to pure trading activities remain outside the scope of input service credit.
  • The Tribunal did not purport to lay down a sweeping new precedent beyond the statutory interpretation in this case; it resolved the issues on the facts and statutory language before it.

Disposition: The appeal was allowed in part as described above and the Tribunal pronounced its order accordingly.

(Summary prepared exclusively from the provided Tribunal opinion; no outside information has been added.)

    Metro Shoes Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Mumbai-I

    [Order per : M.V. Ravindran, Member (J)]. - This appeal is directed against Order-in-Original No. 1/M-I/2007, dated 27-2-2007, vide which the adjudicating authority has confirmed demand of Rs. 78,50,491/- including education cess and appropriated the amount deposited by the appellant, imposed penalty of equal amount under the provisions of Sec. 11AC of the Central Excise Act, 1944 and also ordered for demand of interest as applicable under the provision of Section 11AB of the Central Excise Act, 1944.

    2. The relevant facts that arise for consideration are the appellant i.e. Metro Shoes Pvt. Ltd. (MSPL) manufactured shoes in their factory premises and cleared the same on payment of duty to their own retail outlets. For manufacture of such goods, the said MSPL availed Cenvat credit of the duty paid on the inputs and also on the input services. The scrutiny of the records filed by the appellant revealed that they had availed Cenvat credit under Rule 3 of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 on input services like retail agents commission, selling agents commission, advertising expenses, clearing and forwarding charges, telephone and internet, courier and postage charges etc. It was found by the lower authorities that the Service tax paid on the services availed by the appellant were in the nature of post manufacture i.e. subsequent to the clearance of the goods from the place of removal and hence were found to be ineligible for availment of such input stage service tax credit. Show cause notice dated 6-11-2006 was issued to the appellant, requiring them to show cause as to why the Cenvat credit amounting to Rs. 78,50,491/- including education cess availed and utilized by them during the period October, 2005 to March, 2006 be not demanded and recovered under provisions of Rule 14 of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 read with Sec. 11A of the Central Excise Act, 1944 and why penalty be not imposed on them under provisions of Section 11AC of the Central Excise Act, 1944 besides why interest should not be recovered under provisions of Rule 14 of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 read with Sec. 11AB of the Central Excise Act, 1944. The appellant strongly contested the allegations in the show cause notice mainly on the ground that the excisable goods which are manufactured by them i.e. branded footwear, were cleared from their factory premises to the retail shops which are owned by them. It was their submission that the showrooms are their own and there is no sale at the premises where the shoes are manufactured. It was their contention before the adjudicating authority that the sales were effected for the first time from their showrooms and the clearance which took place from their manufacturing premises was only inter depot or inter showroom transfer. It was also contended that the commission charges which are paid to those people in the retail showroom were in fact commissions and Service tax was paid by such people on said commission and they have correctly availed credit of such input services. After hearing the appellant, the adjudicating authority came to the conclusion that the appellant were not eligible to avail credit of the input stage services and coming to such conclusion the adjudicating authority passed the following order :

    ”23(a). In view of the detailed discussion above, I, hereby, disallow the inadmissible Cenvat credit, as discussed above, amounting to Rs. 78,50,491/- (Rupees seventy-eight lakhs fifty thousand four hundred and ninety-one only), comprising of Central Excise duty of Rs. 76,96,485/- and Education Cess of Rs. 1,54,006/-, availed and utilized by M/s. Metro Shoes P. Ltd. during the period October, 2005 to March, 2006 and confirm the demand of Rs. 78,50,491/- against them under SCN No. V-Adj(64)CSCN/M-I/15-8/2006, dated 6-11-2006. They should make the payment forthwith.
    23(b). I hereby appropriate the amount of Rs. 13,27,497/- paid by M/s. MSPL towards Central Excise duty amounting to Rs. 13,01,468/- and Education Cess amounting to Rs. 26,029/-.
    23(c). I impose a penalty of Rs. 78,50,491/- (Rupees seventy-eight lakhs fifty thousand four hundred ninety-one only) against M/s. Metro Shoes P. Ltd. under Rule 15 of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 read with Section 11AC of Central Excise Act, 1944.
    23(d). M/s. Metro Shoes P. Ltd. shall pay all the dues along with interest as applicable under Section 11AB of Central Excise Act, 1944.”

    3. Ld. Counsel for the appellant, assailing the above order of confirmation of demand of duty submits that the reversal of the Cenvat credit as ordered by the adjudicating authority is incorrect. It is his submission that the appellant had availed input stage credit of the service tax paid by the commission agents at the retail showroom of the appellant themselves. It is his submission that the demand of the duty has been confirmed by the adjudicating authority under the following heads :

    (i)      Services directly and wholly attributable to goods manufactured by the appellant Rs. 62,71,473/-
    (ii)    Services directly and wholly attributable to trading activities Rs. 13,27,497/-
    (iii)   Other overhead expenses incurred for running retail outlets Rs. 2,51,581/-.

    4. It is his submission that the credit of the service tax availed of the above three amounts was correct. He submits that the service tax element on all the above three heads pertains to the business auxiliary services (commission paid to commission agents), advertisement services travel agency services (including transportation), storage and warehousing and other overhead like maintenance and repair services, insurance, internet, security, postage and courier etc. It is his submission that the service tax paid for the above-said services are directly relatelable to the goods which are manufactured by the appellant. It was submitted that the appellant manufactured the goods at their factory premises and do not sell these goods to any agent or dealer. It is the submission that the goods are transported from their premises to retail showrooms which are their own showrooms, on a stock transfer memo. It is submitted that the sale of the said goods takes place for the first time from the showrooms. Hence the showrooms has to be considered as place of removal. He draws our attention to the definition of input services in the Cenvat Credit Rules to submit that all the services which are used by the manufacturer whether directly or indirectly till the place of removal are eligible as input service credit. He strongly relies upon the inclusive part of the definition under Rule 2(l) of the Cenvat Credit Rules. It is his submission that there is no dispute as regards the retail showroom being considered as a place of removal. It is his submission that denial of the service tax paid on the commissions for the services rendered by the commission agents, only on the ground that the services are provided primarily in relation to the sale of goods and thus not in or in relation to the manufacture of goods and clearance of final products. It is his submission that having admitted that the sale of goods through commission agent is a routinely adopted marketing practice, the denial of credit does not arise. He submits that the entire demand as confirmed by the adjudicating authority is liable to be set aside and prays so.

    5. Ld. SDR, on the other hand, emphasized that the services utilized by the appellant from the commission agent do not in any way fit into the definition of the input services as provided under statute. It is his submission that the final products i.e. shoes are manufactured by the appellant in their factory premises. Once the shoes are fully manufactured and cleared from the factory premises, the question of utilization of services of commission agent does not arise. Any commission paid by the appellant to the commission agent, admitting even if it is for sale of goods, it would not render such services as in relation to the manufacture of the final product. He submits that the credit availed by the appellant in use of other services relating to the showrooms are also not eligible as credit as they are not at all covered by the provisions as enumerated. It is his submission that the ld. adjudicating authority has clearly brought out the reasons for denial of such credit. It is his submission that the entire definition of input services should be read as a whole and should not be fragmented in order to avail ineligible credit. He relies upon the judgment of the Tribunal in the case of Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. - (Tri. - Del.) = (Tri. - Del.) to emphasize that once the clearances have taken place, the question of granting input service stage credit does not arise.

    6. Considered the submissions made at length by both sides and perused the records. The issue involved in this case is regarding the denial of credit of the input services utilized by the appellant for the finished goods manufactured and cleared by them. For the proper appreciation of the said provisions we read the definition of the input services as given in Rule 2(l) of the Central Excise Rules, 2004 :

    “(l) “input service” means any service, -
    (i)      used by a provider of taxable service for providing an output service; or
    (ii)     used by the manufacturer, whether directly or indirectly, in or in relation to the manufacture of final products and clearance of final products from the place of removal, and includes services used in relation to setting up, modernization, renovation or repairs of a factory, premises of provider of output service or on office relating to such factory or premises, advertisement or sales promotion, market research, storage up to the place of removal, procurement of inputs, activities relating to business, such as accounting, auditing, financing, recruitment and quality control, coaching and training, computer networking, credit rating, share registry, and security, inward transportation of inputs or capital goods and outward transportation up to the place of removal;”
    It can be seen from the above reproduced portion that the input services definition is having three different parts. Presumably, the first part i.e. “used by provider of taxable service for providing an output service” is not an issue in this case. The second part of the definition “used by the manufacturer ...from place of removal” is being strongly contested by both sides. On a plain reading of the second part of the definition, we find that any input service used by the manufacturer, whether directly or indirectly in or in relation to the manufacture of final product and clearance of final product from the place of removal, stands eligible for availing as credit. It is undisputed, in this case, that the appellant had manufactured shoes in their factory premises and cleared the same to their own showrooms situated at various places. It is also undisputed that the sale of said shoes take place from the said showrooms only and did not take place from the factory premises. If that be so, it has to be accepted that the show rooms which are belonging to the appellant herein, have to be considered as place of removal. The services utilized by the appellant till the place of removal and the service tax paid thereon are to be considered as services utilized by him for the manufacture of final product and clearance of the same from the place of removal. This would indicate that the services which are rendered by various service providers during the course of transportation of the final product from the appellant’s factory premises to their own showrooms located in various place, for e.g. GTA, warehousing facilities, C & F agents, insurance, internet services, security, courier services, telecom services, pest control services, bank services etc. and service tax paid on such services would be eligible as credit being the services used by the appellant directly or indirectly in or in relation to the final product and the clearance of the same from the place of removal. As such, we find that the credit of the service tax paid by the service providers and charged to appellant till the sale of the goods from the retail showroom, the appellant is eligible to avail said credit as input service credit.

    7. The duty confirmed on the service directly and wholly attributable to the goods manufactured by the appellant and the demand pertaining to the credit of the service tax on the overhead expenses for running the retail outlets are eligible for credit. But as regards the service tax credit on amount of service tax taken by the appellant for the services which are directly and wholly attributable to the trading activities would not be eligible as credit, as the definition of the input services indicates that the credit is eligible only in “respect of manufacture” of the final product and clearance of the final product form the place of removal. The question of manufacturing the final product, in the case of trading activity does not arise as it is an admitted fact that the appellant purchased these goods for the trading activities, in their retail showroom. As such, we are of the view that the credit availed on the services which are directly attributable to the trading activity is ineligible to be availed as input service credit. Accordingly, we uphold the impugned order to the extent it denies the credit of the service tax paid on the services amounting to Rs. 13,27,497/-.

    8. We find that the issue involved in this case being one of interpretation of the provisions of the statute, hence the penalty under Sec. 11AC of Central Excise Act, 1944, would not arise. As such, penalty imposed on appellant is set aside.

    9. As regards interest, we hold that the appellant is liable to pay interest on the amount of Rs. 13,27,497/- confirmed demand, which has been upheld by us. Accordingly, the appeal is allowed as indicated in the above paragraphs.

    (Pronounced in court)

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Metro Shoes Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Mumbai-I
    (Jan 8, 2008)