Date of Hearing: 19/11/2019 Date of Decision: 22/11/2019
CORAM:
HON'BLE SHRI S.S GARG, JUDICIAL MEMBER Final Order No. 21023 - 21025 /2019
1
Per : S.S GARG
Appellants have filed these three appeals against the common impugned order dated 4.9.2014 passed by the Commissioner (Appeals) whereby the Commissioner (A) has partially allowed the refund and partially rejected the same on various grounds. Since the issue involved in all the three appeals is identical and there is a common impugned order, therefore, all the three appeals are being taken up together for disposal.
2. The details of the refunds in all the three appeals and other details are given herein below:
Appeal No. ST/23727/2014 ST/23728/2014 ST/23729/2014
Period of Dispute July to September October to October to 2009 December 2009 December 2008
Refund claimed Rs.8,14,222/- Rs.39,39,034/- Rs.34,23,481/- Show-cause IV/16/564/2010- IV/16/864/2010 IV/16/832/2009 Notice No. ST(R)/8611/2010 ST(R)/1202/10 Ref. Dn.II/859/10 dated 13.9.2010 dated 21.12.2010 dated 24.12.2009 OIO No. No.879/2011 No.878/2011 No.762/2010 dt.30.11.2011 dt.30.11.2011 dt. 29.12.2010 OIA No. No.575-577/2014 dated 4.9.2014
Refund rejected Rs.8,14,222/- Rs.39,39,034/- Rs.24,58,109/- and disputed
3. Briefly the facts of the present case are that the appellants are registered with the service tax department under the category of Consulting Engineering, Business Auxiliary Services, Maintenance and Repair Services, Erection, Commissioning and Installation Service and Management Consultant Services. Appellant had filed refund claims as listed in the table above seeking refund of unutilized CENVAT credit paid on input services used for providing the Consulting Engineering Services exported during the impugned period under Notification No.5/2006-CE dated 14.3.2006. Thereafter, show-cause notices were issued to the appellant seeking rejection of the claims on various discrepancy/shortcomings. After
2
considering the reply filed by the appellant, the original authority rejected the refund claims partially. Aggrieved by the said order, appellant filed appeals before the Commissioner (A), who also partially allowed the appeals of the appellant. Hence, these present appeals.
4. Heard both the parties and perused the records.
5. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the impugned order rejecting the refund is not sustainable in law as the same has been passed without appreciating the definition of „Input Service" and also binding judicial precedents. He further submitted that with regard to certain input services, the refund has been rejected on the ground that there is no nexus with the output service. In this regard, the Commissioner (A) has rejected the refund on the basis of lack of nexus, non-submission of documents and the debit notes are not proper documents for claiming CENVAT credit and for other procedural irregularities.
| Ground for rejection |
Services Involved |
| Input services do not have nexus with output service |
Rent-a-cab Service Pandal and Shamiana Service Event Management Service Outdoor Catering Services Landscape Maintenance Sewage Treatment Plant Custom House Agency Service |
| No finding on nexus with respect to input services |
Commercial or Industrial Construction service Company Secretary Public Relations Management Service |
| Refund eligible on nexus issue but rejected on account of non- submission of BAS invoices |
Architect Services Business Support Services Business Auxiliary Services Chartered Accountant Services Cargo Handling Services Clearing & Forwarding Agent Commercial Training or Coaching Services |
3
|
Courier Services Erection, Commissioning or Installation Management or Business Consultant Services Consulting Engineering Services Information Technology Software Services Management, Maintenance or Repairs Services Manpower Recruitment or Supply Agency services Technical Inspection and Certification Services Supply of Tangible Goods Service Security Agency Services Telecommunication Services |
| Refund rejected on other procedural irregularities |
Business Support Services Authorized Service Station‟s Services Information Technology Software Services Courier Services |
5.1 Learned counsel submitted that the refunds were rejected on certain services on the ground that there is no direct nexus between the input services which are used for providing taxable output service which is exported, but the said services have been held to be input services by various decisions of the Tribunal. For each service, she has given the decisions rendered by the Tribunal holding that service as an input service on the ground that they are essential for rendering output service.
| Service |
Relied upon decisions |
| Rent-a-cab Scheme Operator‟s Service |
CCE, Bangalore-III vs. Stanzen Toyotetsu India (P) Ltd.: 2011 (23) STR 444 (Kar.) CCE, Bangalore vs. Bell Ceramics: 2012 (25) STR 428 (Kar.) Deloittee Support Services India Pvt. Ltd. vs. CCE, Hyderabad-IV: 2018 (5) GSTL 393 (Tri.-Bang.) maintained by the Hon‟ble AP High Court in 2017 (5) GSTL J197 (AP) |
4
| Pandal and Shamiana Services |
Toyota Kirloskar Motor Pvt. Ltd. vs. CCE, Bangalore: 2011 (24) STR 645 (Kar.) City Union Bank Ltd. vs. CGST: 2019 (365) ELT 440 (Tri.-Chennai) Adani Port & Special Economic Zone Ltd. vs. CST, Ahemdabad: 2016 (42) STR 1010 (Tri.-Ahmd.) CST, Chennai vs. Ford Business Services Centre Pvt. Ltd.: 2015 (38) STR 700 (Tri.- Chennai) |
| Event Management Services |
Shell India Marketing Pvt. Ltd. vs. CCE: 2017-TIOL-2320-CESTAT-BANG. Toyota Kirloskar Motor Pvt. Ltd. vs. CCE: 2011-TIOL-941-HC-KAR-ST CST, Mumbai vs. DBOI Global Services P. Ltd.: 2017 (48) STR 157 (Tri.-Mum.) approved by the High Court in 2019 (20) GSTL 351 (Bom-HC) CST, Mumbai-II vs. WNS Global Services: 2016-TIOL-1275-CESTAT-MUM |
| Outdoor Catering Services |
Wipro Ltd. vs. CCE, Bangalore-III: 2018 (363) ELT 1111 (Tri.-LB) HICAL Ltd. vs. CCE, Bangalore: 2017 (4) GSTL 354 (Tri.-Bang.) CCE vs. Reliance Industries Ltd.: 2018-TIOL- 211-CESTAT-MUM. CCE, Belapur vs. Hyva (India) Pvt. Ltd.: 2018-TIOL-259-CESAT-MU |
5.2 She further submitted that with regard to input service of Commercial and Industrial Construction Service; Company Secretary and Public Relation Management service, the Commissioner (A) has not given any finding with regard to the nexus. She also submitted that these services also fall in the definition of „input service" as the same are necessary for rendering output service which are exported.
5.3 She further submitted that with regard to rejection of refund on account of non-submission of invoices, she fairly concedes that before the authorities below, appellants could not produce the invoices and the said invoices have been annexed with the appeal paper also and they are ready
5
to produce the same before the original authority for verification of the invoices.
5.4 She further submitted that rejection of refund claim on other procedural irregularities, the Commissioner (A) has rejected the refund on the basis that debit notes are not the proper document for claiming CENVAT credit. In this regard, she submitted that it is a settled position that credit availed on the basis of debit notes must be allowed. For this submission, she relied upon the following decisions:
CCE, Jaipur-I vs. Bharti Hexacom Ltd.: 2018 (12) GSTL 123 (Raj.)
Unicure India Ltd. vs. CCE, Noida: 2017 (3) GSTL 418 (Tri.-All.
Ad-manum Packaging Pvt. Ltd. vs. CCE, Indore: 2017 (346) ELT 142 (Tri.-Del.)
5.5 She also submitted that refund cannot be denied on the ground that there is no address of the assessee on certain invoices. For this, she relied upon the following decisions:
GE India Exports (P) Ltd. vs. CCE & ST, Hyderabad-II: 2016 (44) STR 693 (Tri.-Hyd.)
Madhya Pradesh Consultancy Organization Ltd. vs. CCE, Bhopal: 2017
(4) GSTL 100 (Tri.-Del.)
5.6 She further submitted that in the impugned order, the Commissioner (A) while rejecting refund claim on lack of nexus has observed that "the said service does not qualify as an essential input service, the absence of which might adversely affect the quality and efficiency of the provision of output service, is not evident". To counter this finding, the learned counsel submitted that the test of whether an input service adversely affects the quality and efficiency of the provisions of output service is not prescribed anywhere in the Rules. The language employed in Rules is determinative factor of legislative intent and it is improper to add any words thereto and evolve some legislative intent, not found in the statute itself. It is submitted that the impugned order has erred in adding words to a statute and read words into statute which are not there. For this submission, she relied upon the following decisions:
6
State vs. Parmeshwaran Subramani: 2009 (242) ELT 162 (SC)
Mayfair Leather Exports (Pvt.) Ltd. vs. Union of India: 2011 (272) ELT 193 (All.)
5.7 She made reference to the TRU Circular issued from DOF No.334/1/1010-TRU dated 26.2.2010 which clarified the reason behind the amendments to the refund Notification. She also submits that it is not open to the Department to examine the admissibility of CENVAT credit while adjudicating the refund claim application, since in such matters of admissibility, the Department is mandated to take recourse under Rule 14 of CENVAT Credit Rules. For this, she placed reliance in the case of K. Line Ship Management (India) Pvt. Ltd. vs. CST, Mumbai: 2017-TIOL- 2406-CESTAT-MUM.
6. On the other hand, the learned AR defended the impugned order.
7. After considering the submissions of both the parties and perusal of the material on record, I find that the Commissioner (A) has rejected the refund claims on certain services on the ground that there is no direct nexus between the input service and the output services which is not legally sustainable. The appellant have produced various decisions cited supra wherein all these services have been held to be input services and has nexus with the output service, therefore, I hold that denial of refund on lack of nexus is not sustainable in law and therefore, I hold that appellants are entitled to the refund on these input services. I also hold that the appellant is also entitled to refund of CENVAT credit in respect of Commercial and Industrial Construction Service, Company Secretary and Public Relation Management Service being essential for rendering output service.
7.1 Further, I find that refund has been rejected on the ground of non-production of documents as cited supra. For this, I remand back the case to the original authority who will examine the documents which may be produced by the appellants in support of their refund claims. As far as denial of refund on the basis of debit notes in which the amount paid and services
7
received are not clear. In view of the decisions cited supra, I hold that debit note is a valid document for claiming CENVAT credit under Rule 9 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004.
7.2 Further, denial of refund on other procedural irregularities viz., that invoices does not contain address of the appellant is also not sustainable in law because the appellant is engaged in export of service and these services are essential for rendering output service.
8. In view of my discussions above, the matter is remanded to the original authority for verification of the documents, invoices as well as the details in the debit notes; and thereafter, pass a fresh order and determine the eligible refund claim of the appellant.
(Order was pronounced in Open Court on 22/11/2019.)
S.S GARG
JUDICIAL MEMBER
rv
8