Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant-husband filed a matrimonial suit in 2010 seeking annulment of marriage under Section 13(1)(ia) and (ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, alleging cruelty and desertion by the respondent-wife. The marriage was solemnized on 21.05.2005 at Akbarpur, Nawada, and the couple lived together for about 1 year and 11 months. The appellant alleged that the respondent exhibited abnormal behavior and was diagnosed with schizophrenia and permanent disability in her leg, which was not disclosed prior to marriage. The respondent allegedly deserted the appellant in 2006, leaving the matrimonial home. The suit was initially filed in Alipore, West Bengal, but transferred to Family Court, Nawada by the Supreme Court. The Family Court dismissed the petition on 22.11.2018. Both parties were given opportunities for mediation, which failed. The appellant challenged this dismissal by filing the present appeal under Section 19 of the Family Courts Act, 1984.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent-wife is suffering from schizophrenia or other mental disorder of such a kind and to such an extent that the appellant cannot reasonably be expected to live with her.
  2. Whether the appellant-husband has proved cruelty and desertion as grounds for divorce under Section 13(1)(ia) and (ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.
  3. Whether the Family Court erred in dismissing the appellant's petition for divorce.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Family Court failed to properly consider facts and evidence, especially regarding the respondent's mental condition and disability.
  • The respondent-wife is suffering from schizophrenia and permanent disability in her leg, which was concealed prior to marriage.
  • The parties have been living separately for over 18 years, and the matrimonial bond is irreparable.
  • The respondent deserted the appellant, as admitted in her own statements.
  • The impugned judgment was passed without documentary evidence and without framing an issue on the respondent’s mental disorder.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent denied all allegations of mental illness and disability.
  • The respondent refuted any cruelty or aggressive behavior towards the appellant.
  • The respondent denied executing any documents regarding dissolution of marriage and claimed such documents are fabricated.
  • The appellant failed to prove any mental disorder or desertion.
  • The respondent intended to live with the appellant and had always resided as husband and wife.
  • The Family Court rightly dismissed the petition based on evidence.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ram Narain Gupta v. Smt. Rameshwari Gupta, (1988) 4 SCC 247 Section 13(1)(iii) requires the mental disorder to be of such degree that the petitioner cannot reasonably be expected to live with the respondent; mere existence of mental disorder is insufficient for divorce. The Court applied this principle to hold that the appellant failed to prove the respondent’s mental disorder to the requisite degree for dissolution of marriage.
Smt. Rita Roy v. Sitesh Chandra, AIR 1982 Cal 138 Each case of schizophrenia must be considered on merits; both unsoundness of mind and degree of disorder must be established to grant divorce. The Court relied on this precedent to emphasize the necessity of proving both elements before granting divorce under mental disorder ground.
Kollam Chandra Sekhar vs. Kollam Padma Latha, (2014) 1 SCC 225 Reiterated the principle that mental disorder must be serious enough to justify divorce under Section 13(1)(iii). The Court reaffirmed the requirement of cogent evidence and medical proof, which was lacking in the appellant's case.
Vinita Saxena v. Pankaj Pandit, (2006) 3 SCC 778 Medical reports must show that the mental illness is serious and symptoms are not under control to grant divorce on mental disorder ground. The Court noted that absence of medical evidence and treatment records in the present case undermined the appellant’s claim.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the evidence and pleadings, noting that the appellant failed to produce medical evidence or testimony of the doctor treating the respondent for schizophrenia. The Court highlighted that mere allegations without documentary proof are insufficient to establish mental disorder under Section 13(1)(iii) of the Hindu Marriage Act. The Court referred to binding Supreme Court precedents establishing that the mental disorder must be of such a degree that the petitioner cannot reasonably be expected to live with the spouse. It found that the appellant neither proved cruelty nor desertion to the required standard. The Court also observed that the appellant himself had abandoned the respondent, which disentitles him from seeking relief on grounds of cruelty or desertion. The Family Court’s findings that the appellant failed to prove the respondent’s mental illness or disability were accepted as just and proper. Consequently, the Court affirmed the dismissal of the divorce petition.

Holding and Implications

The present miscellaneous appeal is dismissed, affirming the judgment and decree of the Family Court dismissing the appellant-husband’s petition for divorce.

The direct effect of this decision is that the matrimonial bond between the parties remains intact, and the appellant is denied relief on the grounds of cruelty, desertion, and mental disorder. The Court’s decision reinforces the legal standard that mental disorder as a ground for divorce requires cogent medical evidence and a showing that the disorder is of such severity as to make cohabitation unreasonable. No new precedent was established; rather, the Court applied settled legal principles to the facts before it.

    Sanjay Kumar Shaw v. Smt. Anjali Kumari Shaw

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA

    Miscellaneous Appeal No.1152 of 2018

    ====================================================== Sanjay Kumar Shaw Son of Sri Ganga Prasad Shaw Resident at 8/1 C Panditiya Road, P.S.- Garia Hat Kolkatta- 700029 (West Bengal) ... ... Appellant/s

    Versus

    Smt. Anjali Kumari Shaw Wife of Sri Sanjay Kumar Shaw, Daughter of Sri Bhola Prasad Shaw Permanent Resident of Village- Akbarpur, P.O.- Raj-hat, P.S- Akbarpur, District- Nawada.

    ... ... Respondent/s

    ======================================================

    Appearance :

    For the Appellant/s : Mr. Surendra Kishore Thakur, Advocate : Mr. Sanjay Kumar Sinha, Advocate

    For the Respondent/s : Mr. Satish Chandra, Advocate ======================================================

    CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P. B. BAJANTHRI

    and

    HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SUNIL DUTTA MISHRA

    C.A.V. JUDGMENT

    (Per: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SUNIL DUTTA MISHRA) Date :07-04-2025

    Heard learned counsel for the parties

    2. The present appeal under Section 19 of the Family Courts Act, 1984 is directed against the judgment and order dated 22.11.2018 passed by learned Principal Judge, Family Court, Nawada in Matrimonial Case No. 52 of 2010 (15 of 2013), whereby and whereunder the petition filed by the appellant-husband under Section 13(1) (ia) and (ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act') for annulment of marriage has been dismissed.

    3. The appellant has filed Matrimonial suit No. 52 of 2010 with the learned Court of District and Sessions Judge,

    1

    2/15

    Alipore (West Bangal) and the same was transferred to the Family Court, Nawada by the Hon'ble Supreme Court vide order dated 02.10.2012 in Transfer Petition (Civil) No. 278 of

    2011.

    4. As per appellant case, the marriage between appellant-husband and respondent-wife was solemnized on 21.05.2005 at Akbarpur, Nawada as per Hindu rites and ceremonies. The appellant and respondent started living together in a rented house at Kolkata. They lived together for about 1 year and 11 months. Immediately after marriage, the appellant- husband found some abnormal behavior in attitude and also in movement of the respondent which gradually intensified. The respondent was treated in the department of psychiatric in Ramkrishna Mission Sewa Pratisthan where the doctor diagnosed her to be suffering from schizophrenia i.e., sort of mental disease or disorder. Also, respondent has got permanent disability in her leg and cannot move properly for which she was treated in the same hospital. The appellant-husband was physically attacked for several times by the respondent without any cogent reason. The parents of respondent never disclosed about any disease of the respondent. The couple never mixed up as husband and wife and the respondent realized the mistake on

    3/15

    part of their family members and after discussion with her parents and other family members decided to leave the petitioner without any allegation and decided to cease the matrimonial tie with the petitioner. She left without any allegation against her husband by executing two document in her own handwriting agreeing to dissolve their marriage. On 26.11.2006 the mother along with two relatives of the respondent took her with all articles and belongings of the respondents. Since then, the respondent has been living at her parental home. The respondent with malafide intention has withdrawn herself from the society of petitioner and has deserted him.

    5. Both the parties were given adequate opportunities by the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court on 15.10.2019 to reach an amicable settlement through mediation. However, the efforts remained unsuccessful as no mutual agreement could be reached between the parties.

    6. Respondent-wife had filed written statement before the Family Court stating that prior to marriage the parents of the appellant saw her twice, once at Akbarpur and secondly at Kolkata, thereafter, marriage was solemnized. The respondent further denied all the allegations regarding her

    4/15

    mental condition or allegation that she is suffering from schizophrenia. It has been denied that behavior of respondent- wife is aggressive towards her husband. It is stated that she is a spiritual lady, she had never used any weapon such as knife and spoon to cause harm to the appellant-husband as alleged. It has also been specifically refuted that respondent had executed any document regarding dissolution of her marriage and has also refuted that she was being counseled by any psychiatric, in furtherance any such document, if prepared, is false and fabricated and was made without her knowledge and consent. She has no disease and lived with petitioner as husband and wife. Furthermore, it has been stated that the appellant had no reason to bring this suit, therefore, it is liable to be dismissed with cost.

    7. On behalf of the appellant, two witnesses have been examined, viz., Nathun Shaw P.W.-1 (uncle of the appellant) and Sanjay Kumar Shaw P.W.-2 (appellant). On the other hand, the respondent-wife, in support of her case, examined three witnesses viz., Anjali Shaw O.P.W.-1 (respondent herself), Bhola Prasad O.P.W.-2 (father of respondent) and Shyam Sundar Shaw O.P.W.-3. No document was exhibited on behalf of both the parties.

    5/15

    8. On the basis of pleading and submissions advanced on behalf of the parties, the learned Family Court framed following issues:

    (i) Whether the case as framed is maintainable?

    (ii) Whether the petitioner has valid cause of action?

    (iii) Whether the defendant committed cruelty against the petitioner and due to the said conduct petitioner has been living a deserted life since two years before filing the petition?

    (iv) Whether the defendant has sufficient ground to refuse to give divorce against the petitioner?

    (v) Whether the petitioner is entitled to the relief or other reliefs sought?

    9. After hearing the parties, appraising the pleading and evidence, the learned Family Court came to the conclusion that appellant-husband failed to prove that the responded-wife had committed any cruelty with the appellant-husband. Even the parents of appellant have not been examined as witnesses. There is no evidence on record to show that respondent has deserted the appellant-husband. The appellant-husband himself has committed dowry torture and abandoned the respondent-wife, therefore he cannot take advantage of his own mistake. The appellant except allegation has not adduced any document to show that respondent-wife is suffering from schizophrenia or any other mental disorder or any deficiency in her leg. Recording the aforesaid findings, the Family Court has

    6/15

    dismissed the divorce suit filed by the appellant-husband under Section 13 of the Act vide judgment dated 22.11.2018 and decree dated 04.12.2018. The appellant being not satisfied and aggrieved by the said judgment filed the present appeal.

    10. Learned Counsel on behalf of the appellant has submitted that the Family Court without considering the facts and evidence on record, dismissed the Matrimonial Suit of the appellant. It is further submitted that the learned Family Court has failed to appreciate the statements of the respondent and her father made during examination and also, it has erred in considering the mental disease or disorder of the respondent- wife due to which both the parties are living separately for about 12 years, thus, it is fit case for divorce. Moreover, it is further submitted that the impugned judgment was passed without exhibiting any documentary evidence and no issue was framed with respect to whether the respondent is suffering from mental disorder i.e., schizophrenia or not?

    11. It is further submitted that marriage was solemnized in year 2005 and they are living separately since more than 18 years having no regard to the feelings and emotions of the parties and their matrimonial bond is beyond repair and by refusing to sever that tie may lead to mental

    7/15

    cruelty. In para 3 of the chief and para 18 of cross-examination of the responded-wife herself stated that she lived in her sasural (matrimonial home) for about one year which shows that admittedly there was desertion on the part of respondent-wife. Furthermore, it was submitted that there was concealment of mental condition of respondent-wife. On the ground of aforesaid facts and circumstances, learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the impugned judgment and order passed by learned Principal Judge, Family Court, Nawada is liable to be set-aside.

    12. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent- wife submitted that the learned Family Court after appreciating the evidences and considering the material available on record has rightly dismissed petition filed by the appellant-husband. It is further submitted that the appellant-husband has failed to prove that responded-wife is suffering from any mental disease or disorder. Also, the respondent-wife has no deficiency in her leg as asserted by the appellant-husband. The appellant has also not made out his specific plea with respect to cruelty by the respondent-wife. Moreover, it is submitted that the respondent- wife intents to live with the appellant-husband as earlier they had always resided as husband and wife at Kolkata. Thus, the

    8/15

    impugned judgment and decree passed by the learned Family Court is justified and no interference is required by this Court.

    13. It appears from the petition that application for divorce has been filed by the appellant under Section 13 (1) (ia) & (ib) of the Act i.e. on the ground of cruelty and desertion. However, the main ground taken for divorce is that respondent- wife is suffering from mental disease or disorder (schizophrenia) and permanent disability in her leg and due to her abnormal behavior the appellant-husband do not like to continue the matrimonial life with respondent. The learned Trial Court in para 12 of the impugned Judgment considered this aspect and held that appellant has failed to prove that respondent is suffering from the schizophrenia disease and her leg disability. From perusal of the record the question which this court has to decide is whether the respondent is suffering from schizophrenia or other mental disorder of such a kind and to such an extent that the appellant cannot reasonably be expected to live with respondent-wife or not?

    14. Taking note of the evidence adduced by the appellant, it is clear that he has not proved the mental disease or disorder of the respondent-wife, as the doctor who is treating the respondent-wife has not been examined. The grounds claimed

    9/15

    by the appellant-husband are that the respondent-wife is of unsound mind, aggressive and has deserted the appellant have not been proved from the material available on the record.

    15. In the light of discussions made above, relevant statutory provision as mentioned in Section 13(1) (ia), (ib) &(iii) of the Act which reads as under:-

    "13. Divorce-

    (1) Any marriage solemnized, whether before or after the commencement of this Act, may, on a petition presented by either the husband or the wife, be dissolved by a decree of divorce on the ground that the other party

    xxxxxxx

    (ia) has, after the solemnisation of the marriage, treated the petitioner with cruelty; or (ib) has deserted the petitioner for a continuous period of not less than two years immediately preceding the presentation of the petition; or

    xxxxxxx

    (iii) has been incurably of unsound mind, or has been suffering continuously or intermittently from mental disorder of such a kind and to such an extent that the petitioner cannot reasonably be expected to live with the respondent."

    16. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Ram Narain Gupta v. Smt. Rameshwari Gupta reported in (1988)

    4 SCC 247 held as under:-

    "Section 13(1)(iii) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 does not make the mere existence of a mental disorder of any degree sufficient in law to justify the dissolution of a marriage. The context in which

    10/15

    the ideas of unsoundness of 'mind' and 'mental disorder' occur in the section as grounds for dissolution of a marriage, require the assessment of the degree of the 'mental disorder'. Its degree must be such that the spouse seeking relief cannot reasonably be expected to live with the other. All mental abnormalities are not recognised as grounds for grant of decree."

    17. In the judgment cited above, the Hon'ble Supreme Court cited the decision of Calcutta High Court in

    Smt. Rita Roy v. Sitesh Chandra reported in AIR 1982 Cal 138 in which the Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court observed as under:-

    "9. ......each case of schizophrenia has to be considered on its own merits. ....

    15. ......According to the aforesaid clause (iii), two elements are necessary to get a decree. The party concerned must be of unsound mind or intermittently suffering from schizophrenia or mental disorder. At the same time that disease must be of such a kind and of such an extent that the other party cannot reasonably be expected to live with her. So only one element of that clause is insufficient to grant a decree."

    18. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of

    Kollam Chandra Sekhar vs. Kollam Padma Latha reported in (2014) 1 SCC 225 has reiterated the same principle as discussed in Ram Narain Gupta v. Smt Rameshwari Gupta .

    (supra).

    19. Section 13(1) (iii) of Act provides that either of

    11/15

    spouse can apply for dissolution of marriage in case the other spouse is of unsound mind or suffering from mental disorder. The Hon'ble Apex Court considered earlier precedents including judgment of Ram Narain Gupta v. Smt Rameshwari Gupta . reported in (1988) 4 SCC 247 and Judgment of Vinita Saxena v. Pankaj Pandit reported in

    (2006) 3 SCC 778, wherein the Apex Court observed as under:-

    "37. ….in our considered view, the contents of the report as stated by the team of doctors do not support the case of the appellant that the respondent is suffering from a serious case of schizophrenia, in order to grant the decree of divorce under Section 13 (1) (iii) of the Act. The report states that the respondent, although suffering from "illness of schizophrenic type", does not show symptoms of psychotic illness at present and has responded well to the treatment from the acute phases and her symptoms are fairly under control with medication which had been administered to her. It was further stated that if there is good compliance with treatment coupled with good social and family support, a schizophrenic patient can continue their marital relationship. In view of the aforesaid findings and reasons recorded, we have to hold that the patient is not suffering from the symptoms of schizophrenia as detailed above."

    20. In view of the above pronouncement, it appears that the ground of a spouse suffering from schizophrenia, by itself is not sufficient for grant of divorce under Section 13 (1)

    (iii) of the Act as it may involve various degree of mental

    12/15

    illness. The law provides that a spouse in order to prove a ground of divorce on the ground of mental illness, ought to prove that the spouse is suffering from a serious case of schizophrenia which must also be supported by medical reports and proved by cogent evidence before the Court that disease is of such a kind and degree that husband cannot reasonably be expected to live with wife.

    21. Section 13(1)(iii) of the Act does not make mere existence of a mental disorder of any degree sufficient in law to justify dissolution of marriage. The contents in which the ideas of unsoundness of mind and mental disorder occur in section as ground for dissolution of a marriage, require assessment of degree of mental disorder and its degree must be such that spouse seeking relief cannot reasonable be expected to live with the other. All mental abnormalities are not recognized as grounds for grant of decree. The burden of proof of existence of requisite degree of mental disorder is on the spouse who bases his or her claim on such a medical condition.

    22. In the present case, the appellant has made bald allegation in the Matrimonial Suit that respondent-wife is suffering from mental illness and her behavior is abnormal but he has failed to adduce any documentary evidence thereto. The

    13/15

    appellant did not produce the medical documentary and oral evidence of the doctor who is treating schizophrenia of the respondent-wife. Also, the appellant-husband has also failed to prove the defect in leg of the respondent as she freely moved before learned Family Court. In this way, all the allegation made by the appellant in the divorce petition lacks ingredients of Section 13(1) (ia) and (ib) of the Act. From perusal of evidence available on record, it is evident that marriage took place in the year 2005 and appellant himself made allegation that her behavior is unusual and she is suffering from mental sickness as since the beginning, she made unusual behavior like attacking the appellant-husband by spoon or knife, etc. The appellant has failed to produce any documentary evidence to substantiate his claim that the respondent-wife suffers from schizophrenia or any leg deficiency. Her free movement before the Family Court contradicts any claim of incapacitation. Additionally, no specific plea regarding cruelty has been made, and vague allegations cannot constitute a ground for divorce. Furthermore, the appellant himself abandoned the respondent-wife cannot take advantage of his own wrong to seek relief. The appellant- husband having deserted the responded-wife, cannot claim divorce on grounds of cruelty or other allegations when he

    14/15

    himself is at fault.

    23. Coming to facts of the present case and considering above pronouncement and legal position, findings of learned family court recorded have been examined wherein Family Court has opined that husband has failed to prove the factum of schizophrenia. After considering the entire evidence available on record, this court has no hesitation in accepting findings and approach of learned Family Court, which appears to be valid. No sufficient material was brought on record by husband to prove that respondent-wife is suffering from schizophrenia of such a kind and degree, which may be accepted for dissolution of marriage in terms of Section 13(1)

    (iii) of the Act. Therefore, in considered opinion of this Court, finding of the family Court in this regard in just, proper, legal and do not suffer any perversity and do not call for interference by this Court in this Appeal.

    24. On all counts keeping in view the discussions made in foregoing paragraphs, we find that there is no merit in the present appeal warranting any interference in the impugned judgment. The learned Family Court has rightly dismissed the matrimonial case of the appellant-husband seeking divorce. The present miscellaneous appeal is dismissed accordingly,

    15/15

    affirming the impugned judgment passed by the learned Family Court.

    25. Interlocutory Application(s), if any, stand disposed of.

    (Sunil Dutta Mishra, J)

    I am on the same page

    P. B. Bajanthri, J (P. B. Bajanthri, J)

    Ritik/-

    AFR/NAFR NAFR
    CAV DATE 18.02.2025
    Uploading Date 07.04.2025
    Transmission Date NA

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sanjay Kumar Shaw v. Smt. Anjali Kumari Shaw
    (Apr 7, 2025)