S. N. Hussain &
Ahsanuddin
Amanullah, JJ. Heard learned counsel for the appellant and learned counsel for the
respondents.
2. This letters patent appeal has been filed by writ petitioner-
appellant challenging order dated 09.10.2007, by which the learned Single Judge
of this Court rejected claim of the writ petitioner in C.W.J.C. No. 12880 of 2000,
which was filed by her challenging memo dated 29.03.2000, by which the
concerned respondents rejected her application and held that her date of birth was
04.01.1942 and not 04.01.1945 and ordered her superannuation with retrospective
Patna High Court LPA No.372 of 2008 dt.02-07-2013 2
effect from 31.01.2000 and also directed to recover the salary etc. paid to her
after 31.01.2000 as well as to initiate a proceeding under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar
Pension Rules.
3. The claim of the writ petitioner is that she was born on
04.01.1945 and did her Matriculation in 1958, her Pre-Science in 1959 and Part-I
Science in 1963, whereafter she joined M.B.B.S. Course in Darbhanga in the year
1963 itself and every where her date of birth was recorded as 04.01.1945.
4. Learned counsel for the writ petitioner further states that the
authorities wrongly assumed that the date of her birth was 04.01.1942 and
prepared a gradation list on 17.10.1994 showing her date of birth as 04.01.1942.
Against the said entry, the writ petitioner filed her objection on 23.03.1995, but
no heed was paid to it. She again filed a representation on 25.01.2000 along with
her duplicate matriculation certificate showing her date of birth to be 04.01.1945,
but that representation was rejected by order dated 29.03.2000, which was passed
without even considering the subsequent gradation list dated 13.03.2000, wherein
the date of birth of the writ petitioner was clearly shown as 04.01.1945.
5. Learned counsel for the writ petitioner also avers that neither any
ossification test was done nor any opportunity was given to her before passing the
aforesaid impugned order, which was unilateral and ex parte and even no enquiry
was held in the matter. Furthermore as per impugned order dated 29.03.2000, no
departmental proceeding under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules has been
started as yet although more than a decade has passed.
6. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents
vehemently opposes the contentions of learned counsel for the writ petitioner and
states that in the application filed by the writ petitioner at the time of joining
M.B.B.S. Course, her date of birth was given as 04.01.1942 and, accordingly,
Patna High Court LPA No.372 of 2008 dt.02-07-2013 3
when gradation list dated 17.10.1994 was prepared, her date of birth was recorded
therein as 04.01.1942, but it was never challenged by the writ petitioner and
hence the subsequent representation of the writ petitioner dated 25.01.2000 was
rightly rejected by the authorities on 29.03.2000, in which specific reasons were
given by the authorities for not giving importance to the gradation list of
13.03.2000, which was wrong.
7. The matter was considered in detail by the learned Single Judge of
this Court and the writ petition was dismissed on the findings that the authorities
had examined the original records of Darbhanga Medical College, which
indicated that the Admission Register contained 04.01.1942 as the writ
petitioner's date of birth and impugned order dated 29.03.2000 was well
considered order after examining the claim of the writ petitioner in her
representation dated 25.01.2000.
8. Against the aforesaid order of the learned Single Judge, the instant
letters patent appeal has been filed by writ petitioner-appellant challenging the
same on the grounds already mentioned above. The respondents have also raised
the same objections, which have been stated above.
9. Considering the entire facts and circumstances of the case and the
materials on record, it is not in dispute that the writ petitioner had filed a
representation on 25.01.2000, which was decided by the authority concerned on
29.03.2000 and there were two gradation lists; one supporting the claim of the
writ petitioner and the other supporting the claim of the respondents. Furthermore,
the materials produced by both the parties have to be examined by the authorities
giving opportunity to both the parties to contradict the claims of each other and to
show the validity of the materials produced by the parties concerned. However,
the impugned order shows that neither any such opportunity was afforded to the
Patna High Court LPA No.372 of 2008 dt.02-07-2013 4
writ petitioner nor any enquiry had been held in that regard by the authorities
concerned in presence of the writ petitioner.
11. In the said circumstances, the principle of equity and natural
justice demands that the impugned order be set aside, the writ petition bearing
C.W. J.C. No. 12880 of 2000 be allowed to the extent that order dated 29.03.2000
passed by the Additional Secretary, Department of Health and Family Welfare,
Government of Bihar be quashed and the respondents be directed to hold an
enquiry with respect to the representation of the writ petitioner dated 25.01.2000
afresh and pass an appropriate order after holding an enquiry in presence of the
parties giving opportunities to them to place their materials and it is so ordered.
The entire exercise must be completed within six months from the date of
receipt/production of a copy of this order. It goes without saying that the writ
petitioner must co-operate in the said proceeding.