Texas Case Commentaries

Strict Standing Requirements for Class Actions: Texas Supreme Court Dismisses DaimlerChrysler Seatbelt Buckle Class Action

Date: Feb 2, 2008

Strict Standing Requirements for Class Actions: Texas Supreme Court Dismisses DaimlerChrysler Seatbelt Buckle Class Action Introduction In DaimlerChrysler Corporation v. Bill Inman, 252 S.W.3d 299...

Supreme Court of Texas Establishes Strict Interpretation of Annexation Arbitration Rights in Rockwall v. Hughes

Date: Jan 26, 2008

Supreme Court of Texas Establishes Strict Interpretation of Annexation Arbitration Rights in Rockwall v. Hughes Introduction The landmark case, City of Rockwall, Texas, Petitioner, v. Vester T....

Enforcement of Discovery Agreements in Apex Depositions: In re BP Products North America, Inc.

Date: Jan 26, 2008

Enforcement of Discovery Agreements in Apex Depositions: In re BP Products North America, Inc. Introduction The case In re BP Products North America, Inc. (244 S.W.3d 840) adjudicated by the Supreme...

Strengthening Standards on Improper Jury Arguments: Insights from Living Centers of Texas v. Peñalver

Date: Jan 26, 2008

Strengthening Standards on Improper Jury Arguments: Insights from Living Centers of Texas, Inc. v. Peñalver Introduction The case of Living Centers of Texas, Inc., Cyndi Brown, LNFA, and Kimberly...

Arkoma v. FMF: Differentiating Fact and Opinion in Fraudulent Reserve Estimates

Date: Jan 26, 2008

Arkoma v. FMF: Differentiating Fact and Opinion in Fraudulent Reserve Estimates Introduction The case of Arkoma Basin Exploration Company, Inc., et al., v. FMF Associates 1990-A, Ltd., et al. (249...

Notice-Prejudice Rule in Insurance Coverage: Insurer Cannot Deny Coverage for Untimely Notice Without Prejudice

Date: Jan 12, 2008

Notice-Prejudice Rule in Insurance Coverage: Insurer Cannot Deny Coverage for Untimely Notice Without Prejudice Introduction The Supreme Court of Texas, in PAJ, Inc. d/b/a Prime Art Jewel v. The...

Limitations on Successive Motions for New Trial Under Texas Rule 329b: In re BROOKSHIRE GROCERY COMPANY

Date: Jan 5, 2008

Limitations on Successive Motions for New Trial Under Texas Rule 329b: In re BROOKSHIRE GROCERY COMPANY Introduction In re BROOKSHIRE GROCERY COMPANY, Relator. (250 S.W.3d 66) is a pivotal judgment...

Enhanced Legal Standards for Manufacturing Defects and Producing Cause in Product Liability Cases: FORD MOTOR CO. v. LEDESMA

Date: Dec 22, 2007

Enhanced Legal Standards for Manufacturing Defects and Producing Cause in Product Liability Cases: FORD MOTOR CO. v. LEDESMA Introduction In the landmark case of Ford Motor Company v. Tiburcio...

Final Judicial Review Denied: Supreme Court of Texas Limits Judicial Oversight of Pension Board Decisions

Date: Dec 1, 2007

Final Judicial Review Denied: Supreme Court of Texas Limits Judicial Oversight of Pension Board Decisions Introduction The case of Houston Municipal Employees Pension System (HMEPS) v. Craig E....

Supreme Court of Texas Limits Employer Liability under Respondeat Superior and Negligent Entrustment: Goodyear Tire Co. v. Patrick Mayes

Date: Dec 1, 2007

Supreme Court of Texas Limits Employer Liability under Respondeat Superior and Negligent Entrustment: Goodyear Tire Co. v. Patrick Mayes Introduction Goodyear Tire and Rubber Company v. Patrick Mayes...

Interlocutory Appeal Limitations in Health Care Liability Claims: Ogletree v. Matthews

Date: Dec 1, 2007

Interlocutory Appeal Limitations in Health Care Liability Claims: Ogletree v. Matthews Introduction Ogletree v. Matthews (262 S.W.3d 316) is a landmark decision by the Supreme Court of Texas that...

Texas Supreme Court Allows Separate Recoupment of Authority Fees by Insurers Under Article 21.35B

Date: Dec 1, 2007

Texas Supreme Court Allows Separate Recoupment of Authority Fees by Insurers Under Article 21.35B Introduction In the landmark case of Mid-Century Insurance Company of Texas and Texas Farmers...

Limits of Trial Court Discretion in Forum Non Conveniens: Insights from In re PIRELLI TIRE, L.L.C.

Date: Nov 3, 2007

Limits of Trial Court Discretion in Forum Non Conveniens: Insights from In re PIRELLI TIRE, L.L.C. Introduction In re PIRELLI TIRE, L.L.C., Relator (247 S.W.3d 670) is a pivotal case decided by the...

Statute of Limitations Applied to Quiet Title Actions in Fraudulent Real Estate Easement Disputes: Ford v. ExxonMobil

Date: Nov 3, 2007

Statute of Limitations Applied to Quiet Title Actions in Fraudulent Real Estate Easement Disputes: Ford v. ExxonMobil Introduction The case of Robert F. Ford, Jr. v. ExxonMobil Chemical Company...

Open Courts Guarantee Upheld in Application of Two-Year Statute of Limitations for Healthcare Liability Claims

Date: Oct 20, 2007

Open Courts Guarantee Upheld in Application of Two-Year Statute of Limitations for Healthcare Liability Claims Introduction In the landmark case Eula Yancy, as Guardian of the Person and the Estate...

Texas Supreme Court Establishes No Reimbursement Duty Between Co-Primary Insurers with Pro Rata Clauses in Liberty Mutual v. Mid-Continent

Date: Oct 13, 2007

No Reimbursement Duty Between Co-Primary Insurers: Liberty Mutual v. Mid-Continent Introduction The case of Mid-Continent Insurance Company v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Company (236 S.W.3d 765) serves...

Reaffirming the Sufficiency of Cumulative Circumstantial Evidence: CLAYTON v. STATE

Date: Oct 11, 2007

Reaffirming the Sufficiency of Cumulative Circumstantial Evidence: CLAYTON v. STATE Introduction CLAYTON v. STATE, 235 S.W.3d 772 (Cot.Crim.App. Tex. 2007), presents a pivotal examination of the...

Supreme Court of Texas Sets Precedent on Fiduciary Duties of Third-Party Administrators in Insurance Contracts

Date: Sep 29, 2007

Supreme Court of Texas Sets Precedent on Fiduciary Duties of Third-Party Administrators in Insurance Contracts Introduction In the landmark case of National Plan Administrators, Inc. and CRS...

Supreme Court of Texas Establishes Strict Limitations on Sovereign Immunity Appeals

Date: Sep 8, 2007

Supreme Court of Texas Establishes Strict Limitations on Sovereign Immunity Appeals Introduction The case of TEXAS A M UNIVERSITY SYSTEM, Texas Engineering Experiment Station, and Dr. Mark McLellan,...

PUC's Exclusive Jurisdiction Over TUSF Surcharge Disputes Affirmed by Texas Supreme Court

Date: Sep 1, 2007

PUC's Exclusive Jurisdiction Over TUSF Surcharge Disputes Affirmed by Texas Supreme Court Introduction The case of IN RE SOUTHWESTERN BELL TELEPHONE COMPANY, L.P., Relator. (235 S.W.3d 619)...