Texas Case Commentaries

Constitutional Avoidance and the Mandatory ETJ Opt‑Out Remedy: Commentary on Elliott v. City of College Station

Date: May 23, 2025

Constitutional Avoidance and the Mandatory ETJ Opt‑Out Remedy: A Commentary on Shana Elliott & Lawrence Kalke v. City of College Station I. Introduction The Supreme Court of Texas’s decision in Shana...

“Remedies, Not Claims”: Gonzalez v. Texas Medical Board and the Scope of the Redundant-Remedies Doctrine in Texas Administrative Law

Date: May 21, 2025

“Remedies, Not Claims”: Gonzalez v. Texas Medical Board and the Scope of the Redundant-Remedies Doctrine in Texas Administrative Law I. Introduction In Reynaldo "Rey" Gonzalez, Jr., M.D., J.D. v....

Redundant Remedies and Campaign Speech: Gonzalez v. Texas Medical Board and the Scope of Judicial Review of Agency Action

Date: May 20, 2025

Redundant Remedies and Campaign Speech: Gonzalez v. Texas Medical Board and the Scope of Judicial Review of Agency Action Case Overview Case: Reynaldo “Rey” Gonzalez, Jr., M.D., J.D. v. Texas Medical...

Actual Receipt of Citation, Not Mere Knowledge of Suit: The Texas Supreme Court Refines Craddock in Alternative‑Service Default Divorces

Date: May 20, 2025

Actual Receipt of Citation, Not Mere Knowledge of Suit: The Texas Supreme Court Refines Craddock in Alternative‑Service Default Divorces I. Introduction The Supreme Court of Texas’s per curiam...

"Empty Space Is Not a Mineral": Surface Ownership of Subsurface Caverns and In‑Kind Mineral Royalties under Texas Law

Date: May 17, 2025

"Empty Space Is Not a Mineral": Surface Ownership of Subsurface Caverns and In‑Kind Mineral Royalties under Texas Law I. Introduction In Myers-Woodward, LLC v. Underground Services Markham, LLC &...

Extending the TCPA to Negligent Hiring, Training, and Supervision: Commentary on Walgreens v. McKenzie

Date: May 17, 2025

Extending the TCPA to Negligent Hiring, Training, and Supervision: Commentary on Walgreens v. McKenzie I. Introduction In Walgreens v. McKenzie, No. 23‑0955 (Tex. May 16, 2025), the Supreme Court of...

Reining In Post‑Settlement Vacatur in Texas: Commentary on Megatel C90‑2, Inc. v. Bank of Utah

Date: May 17, 2025

Reining In Post‑Settlement Vacatur in Texas: Commentary on Megatel C90‑2, Inc. v. Bank of Utah I. Introduction The concurring opinion by Justice James P. Sullivan in Megatel C90‑2, Inc., et al. v....

“Producing” Evidence Under Rule 166a(i): Nonmovants May Rely on Previously Filed Evidence in No‑Evidence Summary Judgment Practice

Date: May 17, 2025

“Producing” Evidence Under Rule 166a(i): Nonmovants May Rely on Previously Filed Evidence in No‑Evidence Summary Judgment Practice Introduction In The State of Texas v. $3,774.28, $10,176.01,...

Water Quality “As a Whole,” Not Parameter-by-Parameter: The Texas Supreme Court Clarifies Tier 2 Antidegradation Review and APA Fact‑Finding in Save Our Springs Alliance v. TCEQ

Date: May 15, 2025

Water Quality “As a Whole,” Not Parameter-by-Parameter: The Texas Supreme Court Clarifies Tier 2 Antidegradation Review and APA Fact‑Finding in Save Our Springs Alliance v. TCEQ I. Introduction The...

Whole‑Water Antidegradation Review and Limited APA Fact‑Finding: Commentary on Save Our Springs Alliance, Inc. v. TCEQ & City of Dripping Springs

Date: May 13, 2025

Whole‑Water Antidegradation Review and Limited APA Fact‑Finding: Commentary on Save Our Springs Alliance, Inc. v. TCEQ & City of Dripping Springs I. Introduction This decision from the Supreme Court...

Territorial Limits on Texas Civil Barratry Claims: The Supreme Court’s Focus-Based Approach in Pohl v. Cheatham and Justice Busby’s Dissent

Date: May 12, 2025

Territorial Limits on Texas Civil Barratry Claims: The Supreme Court’s Focus-Based Approach in Pohl v. Cheatham and Justice Busby’s Dissent I. Introduction Michael A. Pohl, et al. v. Mark Kentrell...

Texas Supreme Court Narrows TCPA “Legal Action”: Discovery Motions for Sanctions Are Outside the Statute

Date: May 10, 2025

Texas Supreme Court Narrows TCPA “Legal Action”: Discovery Motions for Sanctions Are Outside the Statute I. Introduction In Sadok Ferchichi and Martina Coronado v. Whataburger Restaurants LLC and...

Limitations, Notice, and Equity in Collateral Attacks on Tax Foreclosure Sales: Thompson v. Landry (Tex. 2025)

Date: May 10, 2025

Limitations, Notice, and Equitable Defenses in Collateral Attacks on Tax Foreclosure Sales: A Commentary on Cindy Thompson v. Mae Landry, Supreme Court of Texas (May 9, 2025) I. Introduction This...

Roxo v. Baxsto and the Limits of Reliance on Oral “No‑Flip” and Bonus Promises in Texas Oil-and-Gas Deals

Date: May 10, 2025

Roxo v. Baxsto: Texas Supreme Court Further Restricts Fraud Claims Based on Oral “No‑Flip,” Bonus, and Recording Promises Contrary to Oil-and-Gas Leases I. Introduction In Roxo Energy Company, LLC;...

Private Employers, Off-Duty Police, and Vicarious Liability: Justice Busby’s Framing of an Open Question in Texas Law

Date: May 10, 2025

Private Employers, Off-Duty Police, and Vicarious Liability: Justice Busby’s Framing of an Open Question in Texas Law I. Introduction The concurring opinion by Justice Brett Busby in Chad Seward,...

Actual Knowledge Means Subjective Awareness: Email Notice and Deadline Extensions Under Texas Rule 306a After Red Bluff, LLC v. Tarpley

Date: May 10, 2025

Actual Knowledge Means Subjective Awareness: Email Notice and Deadline Extensions Under Texas Rule 306a After Red Bluff, LLC v. Tarpley I. Introduction The Supreme Court of Texas’s per curiam...

Legislative Self‑Help Before Constitutional Adjudication: The ETJ Opt‑Out Regime in Elliott v. City of College Station

Date: May 10, 2025

Legislative Self‑Help Before Constitutional Adjudication: The ETJ Opt‑Out Regime in Elliott v. City of College Station I. Introduction The Supreme Court of Texas’s decision in Shana Elliott and...

Discovery Motions and Sanctions Requests Are Not “Legal Actions” Under the Texas Citizens Participation Act

Date: May 10, 2025

Discovery Motions and Sanctions Requests Are Not “Legal Actions” Under the Texas Citizens Participation Act I. Introduction The Supreme Court of Texas’s consolidated decision in Sadok Ferchichi &...

Pohl v. Cheatham and the Territorial Reach of Texas’s Civil Barratry Statute

Date: May 10, 2025

Pohl v. Cheatham and the Territorial Reach of Texas’s Civil Barratry Statute I. Introduction The Supreme Court of Texas’s decision in Michael A. Pohl v. Mark Kentrell Cheatham, Sr., No. 23‑0045 (May...

Huynh v. Blanchard and the Limits of Nuisance Injunctions: Narrow Tailoring and Deference to Texas’s Poultry-Odor Regulatory Regime

Date: May 8, 2025

Huynh v. Blanchard and the Limits of Nuisance Injunctions: Narrow Tailoring and Deference to Texas’s Poultry-Odor Regulatory Regime I. Introduction This commentary analyzes Justice Rebeca Huddle’s...