Tennessee Case Commentaries

Supreme Court of Tennessee Upholds Workers' Compensation Reform Act of 2004

Date: Aug 31, 2006

Supreme Court of Tennessee Upholds Workers' Compensation Reform Act of 2004 Introduction In the landmark case Jerry Wayne Lynch v. City of Jellico, et al. (Da 205 S.W.3d 384), the Supreme Court of...

Imposing Bad Faith Liability on Insurers for Failure to Settle Within Policy Limits

Date: Aug 29, 2006

Imposing Bad Faith Liability on Insurers for Failure to Settle Within Policy Limits Introduction The case of Robert Steven Johnson v. Tennessee Farmers Mutual Insurance Company serves as a pivotal...

Notice of Enhanced Punishment Sufficient on Initial Indictment Despite Superseding Indictments: State v. Livingston

Date: Jul 29, 2006

Notice of Enhanced Punishment Sufficient on Initial Indictment Despite Superseding Indictments: State v. Livingston Introduction State of Tennessee v. Daniel W. Livingston, 197 S.W.3d 710 (Tenn....

Establishing Civil Competency Standards in Post-Conviction Actions: Reid v. State of Tennessee

Date: Jul 21, 2006

Establishing Civil Competency Standards in Post-Conviction Actions: Paul Dennis Reid, Jr. v. State of Tennessee Introduction Paul Dennis Reid, Jr. v. State of Tennessee is a landmark case decided by...

Standing Doctrine Affirmed in ACLU of Tennessee v. Darnell

Date: Jul 15, 2006

Standing Doctrine Affirmed in ACLU of Tennessee v. Darnell Introduction The case of American Civil Liberties Union of Tennessee, et al. v. Riley C. Darnell, et al. was adjudicated by the Supreme...

Emotional Distress Claims in Property Tort Actions and the Applicable Statute of Limitations

Date: Jul 15, 2006

Emotional Distress Claims in Property Tort Actions and the Applicable Statute of Limitations Introduction The case of Forrest L. Whaley and Margaret Ann Whaley v. Jim Ann Perkins, et al., adjudicated...

Reinterpreting "Party to be Charged" in Tennessee's Statute of Frauds: Insights from Blair v. Brownson

Date: Jul 12, 2006

Reinterpreting "Party to be Charged" in Tennessee's Statute of Frauds: Insights from Blair v. Brownson Introduction The case of Rena Mae Blair v. Rollin C. Brownson and Mary Ann Brownson (197 S.W.3d...

Including Immediate Family Death as 'Other Disability' for Judge Substitution under TCRCP 25(a) in State v. Young

Date: Jul 1, 2006

Including Immediate Family Death as 'Other Disability' for Judge Substitution under TCRCP 25(a) in State v. Young Introduction In State of Tennessee v. Leonard J. Young (196 S.W.3d 85, Supreme Court...

Reaffirmation of Denial of Alternative Sentencing Based on Offense Seriousness in Class B Felonies: STATE v. Trotter and Sheriff

Date: Jun 30, 2006

Reaffirmation of Denial of Alternative Sentencing Based on Offense Seriousness in Class B Felonies: STATE v. Trotter and Sheriff Introduction STATE of Tennessee v. Jessica Trotter and Andrew Sheriff...

Enforceability of Marital Dissolution Agreements Post-Repudiation: Insights from Barnes v. Barnes (193 S.W.3d 495)

Date: May 18, 2006

Enforceability of Marital Dissolution Agreements Post-Repudiation: Insights from Barnes v. Barnes (193 S.W.3d 495) Introduction Randy Alan Barnes v. Amy Robertson Barnes, 193 S.W.3d 495, adjudicated...

Enlargement of Time in Medical Malpractice Litigation: Williams v. Baptist Memorial Hospital

Date: Apr 20, 2006

Enlargement of Time in Medical Malpractice Litigation: Williams v. Baptist Memorial Hospital Introduction The case of Mae Ellen Williams, et al. v. Baptist Memorial Hospital, et al. (193 S.W.3d 545)...

Supreme Court of Tennessee Clarifies Modification Standards for Child Support Including Extraordinary Educational Expenses

Date: Apr 14, 2006

Supreme Court of Tennessee Clarifies Modification Standards for Child Support Including Extraordinary Educational Expenses Introduction In the landmark case of Brendi Erin Kaplan (formerly Bugalla)...

Supreme Court of Tennessee Upholds Standards for Effective Assistance of Counsel and Validity of Package Plea Agreements in Howell v. State of Tennessee

Date: Mar 17, 2006

Supreme Court of Tennessee Upholds Standards for Effective Assistance of Counsel and Validity of Package Plea Agreements in Howell v. State of Tennessee Introduction Howell v. State of Tennessee, 185...

Affirmation of Proper Use of Peremptory Challenges Under Batson: STATE of Tennessee v. Stephen Lynn Hugueley

Date: Mar 16, 2006

Affirmation of Proper Use of Peremptory Challenges Under Batson: STATE of Tennessee v. Stephen Lynn Hugueley Introduction In the landmark case of STATE of Tennessee v. Stephen Lynn Hugueley, the...

Establishing Causation in Workers' Compensation: Glisson v. Mohon International and the Invalidation of Local Deposition Rules

Date: Mar 14, 2006

Establishing Causation in Workers' Compensation: Glisson v. Mohon International and the Invalidity of Local Deposition Rules Introduction Misty Michelle Glisson v. Mohon International, Inc./Campbell...

STATE of Tennessee v. Charles Rice: Affirmation of Death Penalty Based on Aggravated Murder and Evidentiary Standards

Date: Feb 23, 2006

STATE of Tennessee v. Charles Rice: Affirmation of Death Penalty Based on Aggravated Murder and Evidentiary Standards Introduction In the pivotal case of STATE of Tennessee v. Charles Rice, the...

Prospective Application of Statute of Repose in Medical Malpractice Cases Established

Date: Feb 22, 2006

Prospective Application of Statute of Repose in Medical Malpractice Cases Established Introduction The case of Kaitlyn CALAWAY ex rel. Kathleen CALAWAY v. Jodi SCHUCKER, M.D. addresses a pivotal...

Reaffirmation of Defendant's Right to Jury Instructions on Lesser-Included Offenses under Tennessee Code § 40-18-110(c)

Date: Feb 9, 2006

Reaffirmation of Defendant's Right to Jury Instructions on Lesser-Included Offenses under Tennessee Code § 40-18-110(c) Introduction State of Tennessee v. Robert Page, 184 S.W.3d 223, adjudicated by...

State v. Wiley: Supreme Court of Tennessee Reaffirms Standards for Lesser-Included Offense Instructions and Counsel Effectiveness

Date: Jan 27, 2006

State v. Wiley: Supreme Court of Tennessee Reaffirms Standards for Lesser-Included Offense Instructions and Counsel Effectiveness Introduction The case of William Glenn Wiley v. State of Tennessee...

After-Acquired Evidence in Employment Contracts: Tennessee Supreme Court Establishes Preponderance Standard

Date: Nov 30, 2005

After-Acquired Evidence in Employment Contracts: Tennessee Supreme Court Establishes Preponderance Standard Introduction The case of Eric Teter v. Republic Parking System, Inc. (181 S.W.3d 330)...