South Dakota Case Commentaries

Sanctions for Improper Pursuit of Punitive Damages: Smizer v. Drey

Date: Jan 7, 2016

Sanctions for Improper Pursuit of Punitive Damages: Smizer v. Drey Introduction In the landmark case of Smizer v. Drey, 873 N.W.2d 697 (Sup. Ct. S.D. 2016), the Supreme Court of South Dakota...

Negligence Per Se Requires Proximate Cause: Analysis of Stensland v. Harding County

Date: Nov 25, 2015

Negligence Per Se Requires Proximate Cause: Analysis of Stensland v. Harding County Introduction In Ryan Stensland v. Harding County, 872 N.W.2d 92 (2015), the Supreme Court of South Dakota addressed...

Enforceability of Oral Guaranties and Statute of Limitations in Estate Claims: In the Matter of the Estate of Robert L. Cullum

Date: Nov 5, 2015

Enforceability of Oral Guaranties and Statute of Limitations in Estate Claims: In the Matter of the Estate of Robert L. Cullum Introduction The Supreme Court of South Dakota addressed critical issues...

Clarifying Statute of Limitations for Multi-Faceted Construction Defect Claims: East Side Lutheran Church v. NEXT, Inc.

Date: Aug 7, 2014

Clarifying Statute of Limitations for Multi-Faceted Construction Defect Claims: East Side Lutheran Church v. NEXT, Inc. Introduction The case of East Side Lutheran Church of Sioux Falls, South Dakota...

No Implied Duty of Care Without Custodial Control: Commentary on Prudence Millea v. Jolyn Erickson and Kelly Laughlin

Date: Jun 19, 2014

No Implied Duty of Care Without Custodial Control: Commentary on Prudence Millea v. Jolyn Erickson and Kelly Laughlin Introduction Prudence Millea, as Special Administrator of the Estate of Kimimila...

Immunity of Fire Departments Under SDCL 20–9–4.1: Comprehensive Analysis of Gabriel v. Bauman

Date: May 22, 2014

Immunity of Fire Departments Under SDCL 20–9–4.1: Comprehensive Analysis of Gabriel v. Bauman Introduction The case of Areyman E. Gabriel v. Tim J. Bauman, decided by the Supreme Court of South...

STATE v. PIPER: Upholding Remand Procedures and Affirming Proportional Death Sentencing

Date: Jan 9, 2014

STATE v. PIPER: Upholding Remand Procedures and Affirming Proportional Death Sentencing Introduction State of South Dakota v. Briley W. Piper, 842 N.W.2d 338 (2014), is a pivotal case adjudicated by...

Clarifying the Standards for Reviewing Ineffective Assistance of Counsel on Direct Appeal: State v. Hannemann

Date: Nov 21, 2012

Clarifying the Standards for Reviewing Ineffective Assistance of Counsel on Direct Appeal: State v. Hannemann Introduction State of South Dakota v. Dawn Hannemann (823 N.W.2d 357) is a pivotal 2012...

Affirmation of Judicial Discretion in Withdrawing Guilty Pleas: State of South Dakota v. Schmidt

Date: Nov 8, 2012

Affirmation of Judicial Discretion in Withdrawing Guilty Pleas: State of South Dakota v. Schmidt Introduction The case of State of South Dakota v. Sarah Elizabeth Schmidt addresses critical issues...

Ass Kickin Ranch v. North Star Mutual Insurance: Clarifying Coverage Exclusions for Unassembled Property

Date: Oct 18, 2012

Ass Kickin Ranch v. North Star Mutual Insurance: Clarifying Coverage Exclusions for Unassembled Property Introduction The case of Ass Kickin Ranch, LLC v. North Star Mutual Insurance Company...

Judicial Impartiality and Conditional Visitation in Family Law: Insights from Allison Marko v. James Marko

Date: Jun 28, 2012

Judicial Impartiality and Conditional Visitation in Family Law: Insights from Allison Marko v. James Marko Introduction The case of Allison Marko v. James Marko, adjudicated by the Supreme Court of...

Uninsured Motorist Coverage in Single-Vehicle Accidents: Insights from Cornelius v. National Casualty Company

Date: Apr 19, 2012

Uninsured Motorist Coverage in Single-Vehicle Accidents: Insights from Cornelius v. National Casualty Company Introduction The case of James E. Cornelius v. National Casualty Company (813 N.W.2d 167)...

Emotional Distress in Abuse of Process: South Dakota Supreme Court Sets New Standard

Date: Dec 1, 2011

Emotional Distress in Abuse of Process: South Dakota Supreme Court Sets New Standard Introduction The case of Rita FIX v. FIRST STATE BANK OF ROSCOE et al. (807 N.W.2d 612) adjudicated by the Supreme...

Impact of Testing Procedures in Contractual Disputes: Bowes Construction v. South Dakota Department of Transportation

Date: Dec 23, 2010

Impact of Testing Procedures in Contractual Disputes: Bowes Construction v. South Dakota Department of Transportation An In-Depth Legal Analysis of Testing Standards and Their Implications in...

Restrictive Covenant Enforcement and Equitable Balancing: South Dakota Supreme Court in New Leaf LLC v. FD Development & Family Dollar

Date: Dec 23, 2010

Restrictive Covenant Enforcement and Equitable Balancing: South Dakota Supreme Court in New Leaf LLC v. FD Development & Family Dollar Introduction The case New Leaf LLC, Robert J. Dvorak, and Vianna...

Equitable Tolling and Attorney Misconduct: South Dakota's Stance in Anson v. Star Brite Inn Motel

Date: Sep 9, 2010

Equitable Tolling and Attorney Misconduct: South Dakota's Stance in Anson v. Star Brite Inn Motel Introduction The case of Jonette Anson v. Star Brite Inn Motel (788 N.W.2d 822) addresses pivotal...

Tortious Interference with Business Relationships: Insights from Selle v. Tozser

Date: Jul 29, 2010

Tortious Interference with Business Relationships: Insights from Selle v. Tozser Introduction In the landmark case of James E. Selle and Rosemary A. Selle v. James Tozser, adjudicated by the Supreme...

Affirmation of Child Abuse Conviction: Clarifying Criminal Intent and Prosecutorial Boundaries

Date: Jun 24, 2010

Affirmation of Child Abuse Conviction: Clarifying Criminal Intent and Prosecutorial Boundaries Introduction The case of STATE of South Dakota v. Stacy Lynn Beck presents a significant judicial...

Establishing Duty of Good Faith in UM Claims: Commentary on Dakota, Minnesota & Eastern Railroad Corp. v. Acuity

Date: Aug 6, 2009

Establishing Duty of Good Faith in UM Claims: Commentary on Dakota, Minnesota & Eastern Railroad Corp. v. Acuity Introduction The case of Dalota, Minnesota & Eastern Railroad Corporation v. Acuity...

Invalid Waiver of Jury Sentencing in Death Penalty Cases: Piper v. Weber

Date: Jul 30, 2009

Invalid Waiver of Jury Sentencing in Death Penalty Cases: Piper v. Weber Introduction Briley Piper v. Douglas Weber, Warden, South Dakota State Penitentiary is a landmark decision by the Supreme...