Pennsylvania Case Commentaries

Reinforcing Limits on Admissibility of Prior Criminal Acts in Capital Sentencing: Commonwealth v. Louis Billa

Date: Mar 7, 1989

Reinforcing Limits on Admissibility of Prior Criminal Acts in Capital Sentencing: Commonwealth v. Louis Billa Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Louis Billa, 521 Pa. 168 (1989), adjudicated...

Enhancing Attorney Fiduciary Duties in Settlement Negotiations: RIZZO v. HAINES Establishes Standards for Legal Malpractice

Date: Mar 7, 1989

Enhancing Attorney Fiduciary Duties in Settlement Negotiations: RIZZO v. HAINES Establishes Standards for Legal Malpractice Introduction In the landmark case of Frank L. Rizzo and Lena Rizzo v....

Punitive Damages Not Required to Be Proportionate to Compensatory Damages in Pennsylvania

Date: Mar 4, 1989

Punitive Damages Not Required to Be Proportionate to Compensatory Damages in Pennsylvania Introduction The case of Edward Kirkbride and Carole KIRKBRIDE v. LISBON CONTRACTORS, INC. addressed a...

Establishing Union Standing to Challenge Quota Policies: South Whitehall Township Police Service v. South Whitehall Township

Date: Mar 4, 1989

Establishing Union Standing to Challenge Quota Policies: South Whitehall Township Police Service v. South Whitehall Township Introduction South Whitehall Township Police Service v. South Whitehall...

Revisiting Governmental Immunity and Implied Warranties: Insights from Gall v. Allegheny County Health Department

Date: Mar 4, 1989

Revisiting Governmental Immunity and Implied Warranties: Insights from Gall v. Allegheny County Health Department Introduction The case of Gall v. Allegheny County Health Department, decided by the...

Enhanced Duty of Insurance Companies to Inform Insureds of Legal Rights: Dercoli v. Pennsylvania National Mutual and Grange Mutual

Date: Mar 4, 1989

Enhanced Duty of Insurance Companies to Inform Insureds of Legal Rights: Dercoli v. Pennsylvania National Mutual and Grange Mutual Introduction The case of Dercoli v. Pennsylvania National Mutual...

Miranda Rights and Police Inducements: Insights from Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Gibbs

Date: Feb 3, 1989

Miranda Rights and Police Inducements: Insights from Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Gibbs Introduction In the landmark case Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Gibbs, 520 Pa. 151 (1989), the Supreme...

Penn Center House v. Hoffman: Reaffirming the Nanty-Glo Rule in Summary Judgment

Date: Jan 31, 1989

Penn Center House v. Hoffman: Reaffirming the Nanty-Glo Rule in Summary Judgment Introduction Penn Center House, Inc. v. Hoffman (520 Pa. 171), adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania on...

Capricious Disregard of Competent Evidence in Workers' Compensation: Da v. Russell

Date: Dec 3, 1988

Capricious Disregard of Competent Evidence in Workers' Compensation: Da v. Russell Introduction Da v. Russell, Petitioner (121 Pa. Commw. 436) is a landmark decision rendered by the Commonwealth...

Withdrawal of Counsel in Post Conviction Hearing Act Proceedings: Insights from COMMONWEALTH of PENNSYLVANIA v. FINLEY

Date: Nov 1, 1988

Withdrawal of Counsel in Post Conviction Hearing Act Proceedings: Insights from COMMONWEALTH of PENNSYLVANIA v. FINLEY Introduction The case COMMONWEALTH of Pennsylvania v. Dorothy Finley (379 Pa....

Constitutional Mandates for Judicial Elections: SPRAGUE v. CASEY (1988)

Date: Oct 26, 1988

Constitutional Mandates for Judicial Elections: SPRAGUE v. CASEY (1988) Introduction The case of Richard A. Sprague v. Robert P. Casey is a landmark decision by the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania,...

Commonwealth v. Blystone: Affirmation of Consent-Based Surveillance and Capital Sentencing

Date: Oct 18, 1988

Commonwealth v. Blystone: Affirmation of Consent-Based Surveillance and Capital Sentencing Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Scott Wayne Blystone is a landmark decision rendered by the...

Establishing Finality in Criminal Sentences: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Bobby Joe Lawson

Date: Oct 18, 1988

Establishing Finality in Criminal Sentences: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Bobby Joe Lawson Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Bobby Joe Lawson is a landmark decision by the Supreme Court...

Balancing Peremptory Challenges and Capital Sentencing: Insights from Commonwealth v. Hardcastle

Date: Aug 11, 1988

Balancing Peremptory Challenges and Capital Sentencing: Insights from Commonwealth v. Hardcastle Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Donald Hardcastle is a pivotal case decided by the...

Probable Cause Affirmed via Counsel's Advice in Malicious Prosecution: Kelley v. Teamsters

Date: Jul 29, 1988

Establishing Probable Cause Through Counsel's Advice in Malicious Prosecution: Kelley v. Teamsters Introduction The case of Nancy Kelley v. General Teamsters, Chauffeurs, and Helpers, Local Union 249...

Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Devers: Clarifying Sentencing Disclosure Requirements

Date: Jul 28, 1988

Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Devers: Clarifying Sentencing Disclosure Requirements Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Joseph Francis Devers is a pivotal case adjudicated by the Supreme...

Strict Liability Limited: Pennsylvania Supreme Court's Decision on Liquor License Liability

Date: Jul 28, 1988

Strict Liability Limited: Pennsylvania Supreme Court's Decision on Liquor License Liability Introduction Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board v. TLK, Inc., t/a Peter P's, 518 Pa. 500 (1988), presents a...

Spang v. United States Steel: Establishing New Precedent on Damages in Breach of Contract Cases

Date: Jul 13, 1988

Spang v. United States Steel: Establishing New Precedent on Damages in Breach of Contract Cases Introduction The case of Spang Company v. United States Steel Corporation (519 Pa. 14) addressed...

Valuation Date for Marital Assets and Standard of Proof in Equitable Distribution: SUTLIFF v. SUTLIFF

Date: Jun 2, 1988

Valuation Date for Marital Assets and Standard of Proof in Equitable Distribution: SUTLIFF v. SUTLIFF Introduction SUTLIFF v. SUTLIFF is a landmark decision by the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania,...

Operation of Motor Vehicles Under Political Subdivision Tort Claims Act: Insights from Catherine Love v. City of Philadelphia

Date: Jun 2, 1988

Operation of Motor Vehicles Under Political Subdivision Tort Claims Act: Insights from Catherine Love v. City of Philadelphia Introduction Catherine Love v. City of Philadelphia (518 Pa. 370, 1988)...