Pennsylvania Case Commentaries

Clarifying Mental Incompetency Exceptions in Post Conviction Relief: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ali

Date: Feb 19, 2014

Clarifying Mental Incompetency Exceptions in Post Conviction Relief: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ali Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Imanuel Bassil Ali, 86 A.3d 173 (Pa. Super. Ct.,...

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Prohibits "Error in Judgment" Instructions in Medical Malpractice Cases

Date: Feb 8, 2014

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Prohibits "Error in Judgment" Instructions in Medical Malpractice Cases Introduction The case of Ste v. Rowena T. Grumbine, M.D. and Blair Medical Associates, Inc.,...

Limits of Brady Materiality: Insights from Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Antidormi

Date: Jan 24, 2014

Limits of Brady Materiality: Insights from Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Antidormi Introduction In the case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Gino Antidormi (84 A.3d 736), the Superior Court of...

Affirmation of Death Sentence and Standards for Evidence Admissibility in Commonwealth v. Hairston

Date: Jan 22, 2014

Affirmation of Death Sentence and Standards for Evidence Admissibility Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kenneth Hairston (84 A.3d 657) Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Date: January 21, 2014 Introduction...

Establishing Liability Beyond Manufacturing Defects: Pennsylvania's Stance on Negligent Design Defects in Pharmaceutical Litigation

Date: Jan 22, 2014

Establishing Liability Beyond Manufacturing Defects: Pennsylvania's Stance on Negligent Design Defects in Pharmaceutical Litigation Introduction The case of Patsy Lance, Administratrix for the Estate...

Reaffirming the Strickland/Pierce Standard for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel under the PCRA: Commonwealth v. Spotz

Date: Jan 18, 2014

Reaffirming the Strickland/Pierce Standard for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel under the PCRA: Commonwealth v. Spotz Introduction In the landmark case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Mark Newton...

Affirmation of Death Penalty Based on Multiple Murder Aggravating Circumstances in Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Diamond

Date: Dec 28, 2013

Affirmation of Death Penalty Based on Multiple Murder Aggravating Circumstances in Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Diamond Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Robert Diamond is a pivotal...

Affirmation of Effective Counsel and Limitations of Post-Conviction Relief in Commonwealth v. Robinson

Date: Dec 28, 2013

Affirmation of Effective Counsel and Limitations of Post-Conviction Relief in Commonwealth v. Robinson Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Robinson (82 A.3d 998), adjudicated by the Supreme...

Expanding Appellate Review: Superior Court Affirms Scope to Examine Discretionary Sentencing Challenges After IPP Revocation

Date: Dec 25, 2013

Expanding Appellate Review: Superior Court Affirms Scope to Examine Discretionary Sentencing Challenges After IPP Revocation Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. John Mitchell Cartrette Jr.,...

Environmental Rights Amendment Violated by Pennsylvania's Act 13: A Comprehensive Legal Commentary

Date: Dec 20, 2013

Environmental Rights Amendment Violated by Pennsylvania's Act 13: A Comprehensive Legal Commentary Introduction The Pennsylvania Supreme Court, in the case of Robinson Township, Washington County,...

Affirmation of Capital Murder Conviction in Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Sanchez

Date: Dec 18, 2013

Affirmation of Capital Murder Conviction in Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Sanchez Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Alfonso Sanchez is a landmark case decided by the Supreme Court of...

Single Subject Rule Violation in Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Neiman

Date: Dec 17, 2013

Single Subject Rule Violation in Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Neiman Introduction The case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Neiman addresses a pivotal constitutional issue concerning the “single...

Exclusivity of Workers' Compensation: Beyond the Statutory Timeframe

Date: Nov 23, 2013

Exclusivity of Workers' Compensation: Beyond the Statutory Timeframe Introduction In the landmark case Kathleen Tooey, Executrix of the Estate of John F. Tooey, Deceased, and Kathleen Tooey in her...

Affirming the Constitutionality of Sentence-Service Requirement in Pennsylvania's Post-Conviction Relief Act: Commonwealth v. Turner

Date: Nov 23, 2013

Affirming the Constitutionality of Sentence-Service Requirement in Pennsylvania's Post-Conviction Relief Act: Commonwealth v. Turner Introduction In the case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Emma...

Enhanced Standards for Substantial Gainful Employment under Section 306(b) of the Workers' Compensation Act

Date: Nov 22, 2013

Enhanced Standards for Substantial Gainful Employment under Section 306(b) of the Workers' Compensation Act Introduction The case of Phoenixville Hospital v. Workers' Compensation Appeal Board...

Reaffirming the Strickland/Pierce Standard: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Elliott Limits Application of Brooks on Ineffective Assistance of Counsel

Date: Nov 22, 2013

Reaffirming the Strickland/Pierce Standard: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Elliott Limits Application of Brooks on Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Introduction The case of Commonwealth of...

Brady Obligations and Ineffective Counsel in Post-Conviction Relief: Analyzing Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Weiss

Date: Nov 1, 2013

Brady Obligations and Ineffective Counsel in Post-Conviction Relief: Analyzing Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Weiss Introduction The case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ronald Lee Weiss...

Affirmation of Death Sentence in Commonwealth v. Padilla Reinforces Standards for Aggravating Factors and Counsel Representation

Date: Nov 1, 2013

Affirmation of Death Sentence in Commonwealth v. Padilla Reinforces Standards for Aggravating Factors and Counsel Representation Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Miguel A. Padilla, 80...

Affirmation of Glenn Lyons' Death Sentence: Upholding Circumstantial Evidence and Aggravating Factors in Capital Murder Cases

Date: Oct 31, 2013

Affirmation of Glenn Lyons' Death Sentence: Upholding Circumstantial Evidence and Aggravating Factors in Capital Murder Cases Introduction The case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Glenn Lyons...

Restricting Appellate Review to Suppression Hearing Record: In the Interest of L.J. Appeal of L.J.

Date: Oct 31, 2013

Restricting Appellate Review to Suppression Hearing Record: In the Interest of L.J. Appeal of L.J. Introduction In the landmark decision of In the Interest of L.J. Appeal of L.J. (2013), the Supreme...