Montana Case Commentaries

Reaffirming Prescriptive Easement Requirements: Warnack v. Coneen Family Trust

Date: Aug 17, 1994

Reaffirming Prescriptive Easement Requirements: Warnack v. Coneen Family Trust Introduction In the landmark decision of A.C. Warnack, Trustee of the A.C. Warnack Trust, and Kenneth R. McDonald v. The...

Clark v. Dussault: Upholding Grievance Procedures and Limiting Judicial Immunity for Court Officials

Date: Jul 13, 1994

Clark v. Dussault: Upholding Grievance Procedures and Limiting Judicial Immunity for Court Officials Introduction Clark v. Dussault, 265 Mont. 479 (1994), is a landmark case in the Supreme Court of...

Coercion in Consent and Custodial Interrogations: Insights from Montana v. Rushton

Date: Mar 23, 1994

Coercion in Consent and Custodial Interrogations: Insights from Montana v. Rushton Introduction The Supreme Court of Montana's decision in State of Montana v. Richard T. Rushton, 264 Mont. 248...

Equitable Distribution in Marital Dissolution: Insights from In Re Marriage of Maedje

Date: Feb 2, 1994

Equitable Distribution in Marital Dissolution: Insights from In Re Marriage of Maedje Introduction The case of In Re the Marriage of Rick A. Maedje and Kim A. Maedje (263 Mont. 262) adjudicated by...

Proper Jury Instructions on Negligence Per Se: A Commentary on Hall v. Big Sky Lumber Supply

Date: Nov 3, 1993

Proper Jury Instructions on Negligence Per Se: A Commentary on Hall v. Big Sky Lumber Supply Introduction The case of Leonard J. Hall v. Big Sky Lumber Supply, Inc. (261 Mont. 328) adjudicated by the...

Palmer by Diacon v. Farmers Insurance Exchange: Reinforcement of Attorney-Client Privilege and Work-Product Protections in Bad Faith Actions

Date: Oct 19, 1993

Palmer by Diacon v. Farmers Insurance Exchange: Reinforcement of Attorney-Client Privilege and Work-Product Protections in Bad Faith Actions Introduction Palmer by Diacon v. Farmers Insurance...

Limits on Double Recovery Against Government Entities and Employees: Insights from Mark STORY v. CITY OF BOZEMAN

Date: Jun 25, 1993

Limits on Double Recovery Against Government Entities and Employees: Insights from Mark STORY v. CITY OF BOZEMAN Introduction Mark Story d/b/a Mark Story Construction versus the City of Bozeman and...

Montana v. Anderson: Reinforcing the Particularized Suspicion Standard for Vehicle Stops

Date: Jun 2, 1993

Montana v. Anderson: Reinforcing the Particularized Suspicion Standard for Vehicle Stops Introduction Case Citation: The State of Montana v. Robert Duane Anderson, 258 Mont. 510 (1993) In State of...

Laches Bar Equitable Easement Claims: Analysis of Murray v. Countryman Creek Ranch

Date: Sep 30, 1992

Laches Bar Equitable Easement Claims: Analysis of Murray v. Countryman Creek Ranch Introduction Murray v. Countryman Creek Ranch is a pivotal 1992 decision by the Supreme Court of Montana that...

Montana Supreme Court Upholds Forfeiture of Water Rights under §85-2-226 MCA

Date: May 8, 1992

Montana Supreme Court Upholds Forfeiture of Water Rights under §85-2-226 MCA: A New Precedent Introduction The case In the Matter of the Adjudication of the Existing Rights to the Use of all the...

Balancing Privacy and State Interest: Montana v. Burns

Date: Apr 18, 1992

Balancing Privacy and State Interest: Montana v. Burns Introduction In State of Montana v. George Burns, 253 Mont. 37 (1992), the Supreme Court of Montana addressed a pivotal issue concerning the...

Knight v. City of Missoula: Reinforcing the Viability of Inverse Condemnation and Nuisance Claims Against Municipal Actions

Date: Mar 11, 1992

Knight v. City of Missoula: Reinforcing the Viability of Inverse Condemnation and Nuisance Claims Against Municipal Actions Introduction In Knight v. City of Missoula, the Supreme Court of Montana...

Tax-Exempt Status of Charitable Institutions: Steer, Inc. v. Department of Revenue of Montana

Date: Dec 12, 1990

Tax-Exempt Status of Charitable Institutions: Steer, Inc. v. Department of Revenue of Montana Introduction Steer, Inc., Plaintiff and Respondent, v. The Department of Revenue of the State of Montana,...

Implied Covenant of Good Faith Limited to Contract Damages: MARK STORY v. CITY OF BOZEMAN

Date: May 4, 1990

Implied Covenant of Good Faith Limited to Contract Damages: MARK STORY v. CITY OF BOZEMAN Introduction The case of Mark Story, d/b/a Mark Story Construction, Plaintiff and Respondent, v. City of...

Balancing Public Transparency and Individual Privacy: Insights from Robert Flesh v. Joint School District #2

Date: Jan 30, 1990

Balancing Public Transparency and Individual Privacy: Insights from Robert Flesh v. Joint School District #2 Introduction Robert Flesh v. The Board of Trustees of Joint School District #2, Mineral...

Tolling of Statute of Limitations in Temporary Continuing Nuisance: Graveley Ranch v. Scherpings

Date: Nov 18, 1989

Tolling of Statute of Limitations in Temporary Continuing Nuisance: Graveley Ranch v. Scherpings Introduction Graveley Ranch v. Thomas Scherping and Anita Scherping is a landmark case decided by the...

Montana Supreme Court Clarifies State Sovereign Immunity in Implied Contract Cases

Date: Jul 20, 1989

Montana Supreme Court Clarifies State Sovereign Immunity in Implied Contract Cases Introduction The case of Michael Peretti, Henri Hodnik, et al. v. The State of Montana; The Board of Public...

Mandating Equitable Apportionment Standard in Absence of Separation Agreement: Analysis of In re Marriage of Mary Lou Miller

Date: Jul 19, 1989

Mandating Equitable Apportionment Standard in Absence of Separation Agreement: Analysis of In re Marriage of Mary Lou Miller Introduction In re the Marriage of Mary Lou Miller and Dale Lee Miller,...

Supreme Court of Montana Clarifies Appealability of Interlocutory Orders in Water Rights Adjudication

Date: Oct 12, 1988

Supreme Court of Montana Clarifies Appealability of Interlocutory Orders in Water Rights Adjudication Introduction The Supreme Court of Montana delivered a landmark decision on October 11, 1988,...

Defining Acceptable Use of Easements: Limits on Parking and Storage Under Sampson v. Grooms

Date: Jan 20, 1988

Defining Acceptable Use of Easements: Limits on Parking and Storage Under Sampson v. Grooms Introduction The case Elmer O. Sampson v. Ralph G. Grooms and Gertrude Grooms (230 Mont. 190), adjudicated...