Montana Case Commentaries

Montana Supreme Court Clarifies 'Street Time' Credit Requirements under §46-18-203(7)(b), MCA (2017)

Date: Apr 8, 2020

Montana Supreme Court Clarifies 'Street Time' Credit Requirements under §46-18-203(7)(b), MCA (2017) Introduction In the case of State of Montana v. Charles Edward Jardee, the Supreme Court of...

Montana Supreme Court Reinforces Impartial Jury Requirement in Sexual Assault Case: Ghostbear v. State

Date: Mar 18, 2020

Montana Supreme Court Reinforces Impartial Jury Requirement in Sexual Assault Case: Ghostbear v. State Introduction In the landmark case State of Montana v. Edward Harold Ghostbear, the Montana...

Right to Be Present in Criminal Proceedings: Analysis of State v. Michael Wayne George

Date: Mar 11, 2020

Right to Be Present in Criminal Proceedings: Analysis of State of Montana v. Michael Wayne George Introduction In State of Montana v. Michael Wayne George, the Montana Supreme Court addressed a...

Limitations on Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Claims and Management of Testimonial Materials: Ward v. State of Montana

Date: Feb 12, 2020

Limitations on Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Claims and Management of Testimonial Materials: Ward v. State of Montana Introduction The case of State of Montana v. Shawn Joseph Ward (399 Mont. 16)...

Limitation on Community Caretaker Doctrine: Requiring Particularized Suspicion for DUI Investigatory Stops

Date: Nov 6, 2019

Limitation on Community Caretaker Doctrine: Requiring Particularized Suspicion for DUI Investigatory Stops Introduction The case of City of Missoula v. Bryan Allan Metz serves as a pivotal decision...

Supreme Court of Montana Reinforces State Preemption Over Local Firearm Regulation: Missoula v. Fox

Date: Oct 23, 2019

Supreme Court of Montana Reinforces State Preemption Over Local Firearm Regulation: Missoula v. Fox Introduction Case Citation: City of Missoula, Plaintiff and Appellee, v. Timothy C. Fox, in his...

Montana Supreme Court Establishes Strict Standards for Judicial Disqualification and Sanctions in Probate Litigation

Date: Oct 2, 2019

Montana Supreme Court Establishes Strict Standards for Judicial Disqualification and Sanctions in Probate Litigation Introduction The Montana Supreme Court delivered a pivotal decision in In re the...

Montana Supreme Court Affirms Broad Interpretations of Easement Rights in Religious Property Disputes

Date: Sep 25, 2019

Montana Supreme Court Affirms Broad Interpretations of Easement Rights in Religious Property Disputes Introduction The case of Whitefish Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses, Inc. v. Giuseppe and...

Montana Supreme Court Clarifies Age of Consent Standards in Sexual Offense Cases: State v. Resh

Date: Sep 18, 2019

Montana Supreme Court Clarifies Age of Consent Standards in Sexual Offense Cases: State v. Resh Introduction The case of State of Montana v. Hadley Gene Resh (397 Mont. 254) addressed critical issues...

Balancing Regulatory Roles: PSC's Dual Function in Waste Management Licensing

Date: Aug 21, 2019

Balancing Regulatory Roles: PSC's Dual Function in Waste Management Licensing Introduction The case of ALLIED WASTE SERVICES OF NORTH AMERICA, LLC AND MONTANA WASTE SYSTEMS, INC. d/b/a NORTH VALLEY...

Clarifying Express Easement Creation Through Subdivision Plats: Montana Supreme Court in O'Keefe v. Mustang Ranches HOA

Date: Aug 7, 2019

Clarifying Express Easement Creation Through Subdivision Plats: Montana Supreme Court in O'Keefe v. Mustang Ranches HOA Introduction In the landmark case of Audrey O'Keefe and Tim Beardsley v....

Insurer’s Duty to Defend Precludes Presumed Reasonableness of Unilateral Settlements: Montana Supreme Court Establishes New Precedent

Date: Apr 25, 2019

Insurer’s Duty to Defend Precludes Presumed Reasonableness of Unilateral Settlements: Montana Supreme Court Establishes New Precedent Introduction The case of Draggin' Y Cattle Company, Inc.; and...

Affirmation of Repeat Persistent Felony Offender Sentencing under § 46-18-502(2), MCA

Date: Feb 20, 2019

Affirmation of Repeat Persistent Felony Offender Sentencing under § 46-18-502(2), MCA Introduction In the case of State of Montana v. Zachary Tucker Martin (394 Mont. 351), the Supreme Court of...

Standard for Judicial Disqualification in Parenting Cases: In Re The Parenting of L.R. (2018 MT 294)

Date: Dec 5, 2018

Standard for Judicial Disqualification in Parenting Cases: In Re The Parenting of L.R. (2018 MT 294) Introduction The Supreme Court of Montana addressed a critical issue in judicial procedures...

Affirmation of Lower Court’s Parenting Plan: Establishing Standards for Parental Custody Decisions

Date: Nov 28, 2018

Affirmation of Lower Court’s Parenting Plan: Establishing Standards for Parental Custody Decisions Introduction The case of In re the Parenting of: L.G.L., a Minor Child (2018 MT 283) presents a...

Affirmation of Lower Court Decision in Rorabaugh v. Zelenka: Procedural Compliance and Lack of New Legal Precedent

Date: Nov 28, 2018

Affirmation of Lower Court Decision in Rorabaugh v. Zelenka: Procedural Compliance and Lack of New Legal Precedent Introduction The case of In Re The Marriage of: Jason L. Rorabaugh, Petitioner and...

Affirmation of GAL Testimony Despite Procedural Delays in Custody Proceedings

Date: Nov 28, 2018

Affirmation of GAL Testimony Despite Procedural Delays in Custody Proceedings Introduction In the case of In re the Marriage of Benette Ann Johnson and Eric Michael Johnson (430 P.3d 1006), the...

Succession and Fiduciary Duties: Insights from Valentine E. Weisz Living Trust v. D.A. Davidson Trust Company

Date: Nov 8, 2018

Succession and Fiduciary Duties: Insights from Valentine E. Weisz Living Trust v. D.A. Davidson Trust Company Introduction The case of Valentine E. Weisz Living Trust v. D.A. Davidson Trust Company,...

Affirmation of Lesser Included Offense in Sexual Assault Cases: STATE OF MONTANA v. Kevin Anthony Briggs

Date: Oct 24, 2018

Affirmation of Lesser Included Offense in Sexual Assault Cases STATE OF MONTANA, Plaintiff and Appellee, v. KEVIN ANTHONY BRIGGS, Defendant and Appellant. (2018 MT 261) Introduction The case of State...

Montana Supreme Court Clarifies Application of Plain Error Doctrine in Right of Presence Violations

Date: Sep 19, 2018

Montana Supreme Court Clarifies Application of Plain Error Doctrine in Right of Presence Violations Introduction In the case of State of Montana v. Adam Hatfield (392 Mont. 509), the Supreme Court of...