Mississippi Case Commentaries

Rule 702 Gatekeeping in Medical Malpractice: Trial Courts May Exclude Experts Whose Affidavits Fail to Demonstrate Specialty Familiarity, Even When Critiquing “Non-Surgical” Alternatives

Date: Apr 20, 2026

Rule 702 Gatekeeping in Medical Malpractice: Trial Courts May Exclude Experts Whose Affidavits Fail to Demonstrate Specialty Familiarity, Even When Critiquing “Non-Surgical” Alternatives 1....

Known Pothole Nonresponse Is Not a Discretionary-Function Policy Choice Under the MTCA

Date: Apr 9, 2026

Known Pothole Nonresponse Is Not a Discretionary-Function Policy Choice Under the MTCA 1. Introduction City of Jackson, Mississippi v. Lawson (Miss. Apr. 2, 2026) is a Mississippi Tort Claims Act...

Attorney “Sanctions” Treated as Constructive Criminal Contempt: Rule 81(d) Notice and Mandatory Judicial Recusal

Date: Apr 9, 2026

Attorney “Sanctions” Treated as Constructive Criminal Contempt: Rule 81(d) Notice and Mandatory Judicial Recusal 1. Introduction Jones v. Jones (Miss. Apr. 2, 2026) arose from a long-running...

Circumstantial Proof of “Deliberate Design”: Digital Location Data, Threats, and an Extrajudicial Confession Sustain a Mississippi First-Degree Murder Conviction

Date: Mar 29, 2026

Circumstantial Proof of “Deliberate Design”: Digital Location Data, Threats, and an Extrajudicial Confession Sustain a Mississippi First-Degree Murder Conviction Introduction In Phillip Shane House...

Rescission of First Chancery Court District Local Rule 1: Ending the District-Specific Case-Assignment Regime Effective July 1, 2026

Date: Mar 29, 2026

Rescission of First Chancery Court District Local Rule 1: Ending the District-Specific Case-Assignment Regime Effective July 1, 2026 Court: Supreme Court of Mississippi (en banc) Matter: In Re: Local...

Direct-Benefits Estoppel Requires Legal Dependence on Contract Terms—not Mere “But-For” Treatment—to Compel Arbitration

Date: Mar 29, 2026

Direct-Benefits Estoppel Requires Legal Dependence on Contract Terms—not Mere “But-For” Treatment—to Compel Arbitration Case: Andrew Mallette, M.D. and The Surgical Clinic Associates, P.A. v. Nitkia...

Mississippi COVID-19 Emergency Immunity Extends to Treatment of COVID-Caused Conditions During the Emergency

Date: Mar 29, 2026

Mississippi COVID-19 Emergency Immunity Extends to Treatment of COVID-Caused Conditions During the Emergency 1. Introduction In James H. Secrist and Dawn Secrist v. Rush Medical Foundation d/b/a Rush...

Gardner v. State (Miss. 2026): Specific Objection Requirement for Rule 609/Peterson Challenges and Rejection of “Tilt” in Evidence Balancing

Date: Mar 29, 2026

Gardner v. State (Miss. 2026): Specific Objection Requirement for Rule 609/Peterson Challenges and Rejection of “Tilt” in Evidence Balancing I. Introduction In Jimmie Leshaun Gardner a/k/a Jimmie L....

Harmless-Error Exception for Conflicting “Deliberate Design” and Manslaughter Instructions When Manslaughter Is Unwarranted

Date: Mar 25, 2026

Harmless-Error Exception for Conflicting “Deliberate Design” and Manslaughter Instructions When Manslaughter Is Unwarranted Case: McDaniel v. State of Mississippi | Court: Supreme Court of...

Retroactive Reciprocal Suspension When Attorney Is Inactive and Not Practicing: Mississippi Bar v. Newcomb

Date: Mar 25, 2026

Retroactive Reciprocal Suspension When Attorney Is Inactive and Not Practicing Case: The Mississippi Bar v. Andrew M. Newcomb (Miss. 2026-03-19) Court: Supreme Court of Mississippi (en banc)...

Gibson v. State of Mississippi — Excusable-Homicide Instruction Required When Evidence Supports § 97-3-17, Even if Defendant Acted Intentionally

Date: Mar 25, 2026

Excusable-Homicide Instruction Required When Evidence Supports Mississippi Code § 97-3-17—Intentional Push/Strike Is Not a Per Se Bar Introduction In Gibson v. State of Mississippi (Miss. Mar. 19,...

Hewitt v. TJM Properties, Inc.: No Standing or Construction-Lien Rights from Expired Redevelopment Expectations; Senior Foreclosure Extinguishes Subordinate Claims

Date: Mar 25, 2026

Hewitt v. TJM Properties, Inc.: No Standing or Construction-Lien Rights from Expired Redevelopment Expectations; Senior Foreclosure Extinguishes Subordinate Claims Introduction Hewitt v. TJM...

Youth-Court Restitution Orders Are Not Final and Require Interlocutory Review Under Mississippi Code § 43-21-651

Date: Mar 25, 2026

Youth-Court Restitution Orders Are Not Final and Require Interlocutory Review Under Mississippi Code § 43-21-651 1. Introduction In the Interest of R.H., A Minor (Miss. Mar. 19, 2026) arose from...

Randle v. Ivy: Preprimary Qualification Appeals Under § 23-15-961 Become Moot After Elections and Cannot Yield a Special Election

Date: Mar 18, 2026

Randle v. Ivy: Preprimary Qualification Appeals Under § 23-15-961 Become Moot After Elections and Cannot Yield a Special Election Introduction Randle v. Ivy (Miss. Mar. 12, 2026) arises from a...

Vance v. State of Mississippi: Unholstered, Loaded Firearm Handling Can Justify a Culpable-Negligence Manslaughter Instruction; Lay “Abuse” Opinions Require First-Hand Knowledge

Date: Mar 8, 2026

Vance v. State of Mississippi: Unholstered, Loaded Firearm Handling Can Justify a Culpable-Negligence Manslaughter Instruction; Lay “Abuse” Opinions Require First-Hand Knowledge 1. Introduction In...

Recent Annexation History and Unfinished Service Obligations Are Proper “Totality” Factors in Mississippi Annexation Reasonableness Review

Date: Mar 5, 2026

Recent Annexation History and Unfinished Service Obligations Are Proper “Totality” Factors in Mississippi Annexation Reasonableness Review Case: In The Matter of The Enlarging, Extending and Defining...

Mississippi Adopts Evidentiary Limits on “Reptile Theory” Safety Appeals and Reaffirms New-Trial-Motion Preservation for Weight-of-the-Evidence Review

Date: Feb 22, 2026

Mississippi Adopts Evidentiary Limits on “Reptile Theory” Safety Appeals and Reaffirms New-Trial-Motion Preservation for Weight-of-the-Evidence Review I. Introduction Vickie Greer v. Michael C. Key...

Optional Nursing-Home Arbitration Clauses Are Not “Health-Care Decisions” a Surrogate May Make Under Mississippi’s Uniform Health-Care Decisions Act

Date: Feb 22, 2026

Optional Nursing-Home Arbitration Clauses Are Not “Health-Care Decisions” a Surrogate May Make Under Mississippi’s Uniform Health-Care Decisions Act Case: Manhattan Nursing and Rehabilitation Center,...

Goods v. State of Mississippi: Autopsy Photos Admissible When Manner of Death Is Disputed; Culpable-Negligence Instruction Not “Civil” If It First States the Criminal-Grade Standard

Date: Feb 16, 2026

Goods v. State of Mississippi: Autopsy Photos Admissible When Manner of Death Is Disputed; Culpable-Negligence Instruction Not “Civil” If It First States the Criminal-Grade Standard I. Introduction...

Supreme Court Approval of Sixth Chancery District Local Rules Establishing Random E-Filing Case Assignment and Structured Motion-Day Practice

Date: Feb 10, 2026

Supreme Court Approval of Sixth Chancery District Local Rules Establishing Random E-Filing Case Assignment and Structured Motion-Day Practice I. Introduction In Re: Local Rules (Supreme Court of...