Kentucky Case Commentaries

Reinforcement of Constitutional Protections in Criminal Trials: Analysis of Winstead v. Commonwealth of Kentucky

Date: May 22, 2009

Reinforcement of Constitutional Protections in Criminal Trials: Analysis of Winstead v. Commonwealth of Kentucky Introduction The case of Jerry Bernard Winstead, Jr. v. Commonwealth of Kentucky (283...

Clarifying Jury Instructions in Multiple Sexual Offense Charges: MILLER v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky

Date: May 22, 2009

Clarifying Jury Instructions in Multiple Sexual Offense Charges: MILLER v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky Introduction Frederick MILLER v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, 283 S.W.3d 690 (Ky. 2009), is a...

Revisiting the Rape Shield: Admission of Prior Sexual Conduct in Civil Cases Under KRE 412 – Ten Broeck Dupont, Inc. v. Artemecia Brooks

Date: May 22, 2009

Revisiting the Rape Shield: Admission of Prior Sexual Conduct in Civil Cases Under KRE 412 Introduction In the landmark case of Ten Broeck Dupont, Inc. d/b/a Ten Broeck Hospital v. Artemecia Brooks,...

Supreme Court of Kentucky Establishes Non-Retroactive Rule for Ineffective Assistance Claims in Collateral Proceedings

Date: Apr 24, 2009

Supreme Court of Kentucky Establishes Non-Retroactive Rule for Ineffective Assistance Claims in Collateral Proceedings Introduction In the landmark case of Jeffrey Leonard v. Commonwealth of Kentucky...

Affirmation of Death Penalty and Clarification on Aggravating Circumstances in FURNISH v. COMMONWEALTH

Date: Dec 16, 2008

Affirmation of Death Penalty and Clarification on Aggravating Circumstances in FURNISH v. COMMONWEALTH Introduction Fred Furnish, a 66-year-old appellant, was convicted of the brutal murder of a...

Revolutionizing Jury Instruction Requirements in Sexual Abuse Cases: Harp v. Commonwealth of Kentucky

Date: Oct 28, 2008

Revolutionizing Jury Instruction Requirements in Sexual Abuse Cases: Harp v. Commonwealth of Kentucky Introduction In Wilbert Harp v. Commonwealth of Kentucky (266 S.W.3d 813, 2008), the Supreme...

Framework for Custody and Visitation Modification in Parental Relocation Cases: Pennington v. Marcum

Date: Oct 25, 2008

Framework for Custody and Visitation Modification in Parental Relocation Cases: Pennington v. Marcum Introduction Pennington v. Marcum, 266 S.W.3d 759, is a pivotal case decided by the Supreme Court...

Best Interests Standard in Child Custody Determinations: Maria Regina Frances v. Bobby Gene Frances

Date: Oct 24, 2008

Best Interests Standard in Child Custody Determinations: Maria Regina Frances v. Bobby Gene Frances Introduction Maria Regina Frances v. Bobby Gene Frances, 266 S.W.3d 754, decided by the Supreme...

Equitable Estoppel Not Applicable in Zoning Regulation Enforcement: Analysis of SEBASTIAN-VOOR PROPERTIES v. LEXINGTON-FAYETTE URBAN COUNTY GOVERNMENT

Date: Sep 19, 2008

Equitable Estoppel Not Applicable in Zoning Regulation Enforcement: Analysis of SEBASTIAN-VOOR PROPERTIES v. LEXINGTON-FAYETTE URBAN COUNTY GOVERNMENT Introduction This commentary examines the...

Affirming Effective Assistance of Counsel: Insights from BROWN v. COMmonwealth of Kentucky

Date: Jun 20, 2008

Affirming Effective Assistance of Counsel: Insights from BROWN v. COMmonwealth of Kentucky Introduction BROWN v. COMmonwealth of Kentucky, 253 S.W.3d 490 (Ky. 2008), is a pivotal case that delves...

Affirming Judicial Discretion in Sentencing: Kentucky Supreme Court Overrules Smith in Benet Case

Date: May 23, 2008

Affirming Judicial Discretion in Sentencing: Kentucky Supreme Court Overrules Smith in Benet Case Introduction The case of Benjamin Cole Benet v. Commonwealth of Kentucky, 253 S.W.3d 528 (Ky. 2008),...

Reconstruction of Sentencing Guidelines under KRS 533.060(2) in Appellant v. Commonwealth of Kentucky

Date: May 23, 2008

Reconstruction of Sentencing Guidelines under KRS 533.060(2) in Appellant v. Commonwealth of Kentucky Introduction In the case of Christopher Shaheid Peyton, Appellant v. Commonwealth of Kentucky,...

Affirmation of Joint Trial Conviction: Key Insights from Shepherd v. Commonwealth of Kentucky

Date: May 23, 2008

Affirmation of Joint Trial Conviction: Key Insights from Shepherd v. Commonwealth of Kentucky Introduction In the case of Michael Merrall Shepherd v. Commonwealth of Kentucky, the Supreme Court of...

Enhanced Discovery Obligations for Incriminating Oral Statements: Chestnut v. Commonwealth of Kentucky

Date: Apr 25, 2008

Enhanced Discovery Obligations for Incriminating Oral Statements: Chestnut v. Commonwealth of Kentucky Introduction Chestnut v. Commonwealth of Kentucky, 250 S.W.3d 288 (Ky. 2008), is a landmark...

Reversing Morgan: Kentucky Supreme Court Establishes Peremptory Challenges as Substantial Rights

Date: Apr 10, 2008

Reversing Morgan: Kentucky Supreme Court Establishes Peremptory Challenges as Substantial Rights Introduction In Timothy Carl Shane v. Commonwealth of Kentucky, the Supreme Court of Kentucky...

Supreme Court of Kentucky Establishes Franchisor Vicarious Liability Standards

Date: Jan 25, 2008

Supreme Court of Kentucky Establishes Franchisor Vicarious Liability Standards 1. Introduction The case of PAPA JOHN'S INTERNATIONAL, INC. and RWT, Inc., d/b/a Papa John's Pizza, Appellants v. Gary...

Enforceability of Exculpatory Clauses in Coal Mining Contracts: Insights from Cumberland Valley Contractors, Inc. v. Bell County Coal Corporation

Date: Dec 21, 2007

Enforceability of Exculpatory Clauses in Coal Mining Contracts: Insights from Cumberland Valley Contractors, Inc. v. Bell County Coal Corporation Introduction The legal landscape surrounding the...

Steel Technologies v. Congleton: Kentucky Supreme Court Clarifies Punitive Damages Standards and Upholds the Impact Rule for Emotional Distress

Date: Nov 2, 2007

Steel Technologies v. Congleton: Kentucky Supreme Court Clarifies Punitive Damages Standards and Upholds the Impact Rule for Emotional Distress Introduction The case of Steel Technologies, Inc. v....

Kentucky Supreme Court Establishes Requirement for Lesser-Included Offense Instructions in Drug Cultivation Cases

Date: Nov 2, 2007

Kentucky Supreme Court Establishes Requirement for Lesser-Included Offense Instructions in Drug Cultivation Cases 1. Introduction In the landmark case Commonwealth of Kentucky v. Anthony Wayne Swift,...

Revisiting Marital and Nonmarital Property Classification: A Two-Tiered Review Standard Established in Smith v. Vish

Date: Oct 25, 2007

Revisiting Marital and Nonmarital Property Classification: A Two-Tiered Review Standard Established in Smith v. Vish Introduction James R. Smith and David L. Vish v. Carolyn King Smith is a pivotal...