Iowa Case Commentaries

Defective Workmanship Not an “Occurrence” or “Property Damage” Under CGL: Dostart v. Columbia Insurance Group

Date: Apr 19, 2025

Defective Workmanship Not an “Occurrence” or “Property Damage” Under CGL: Dostart v. Columbia Insurance Group Introduction In John Dostart and Deena Dostart v. Columbia Insurance Group, the Supreme...

Substantial Compliance in Employer Random Drug‐Testing Pools: Hampe v. Charles Gabus Motors

Date: Apr 12, 2025

Substantial Compliance in Employer Random Drug‐Testing Pools: Hampe v. Charles Gabus Motors Introduction This commentary examines the Iowa Supreme Court’s April 11, 2025 decision in Scott Hampe v....

Nonviability of Godfrey Constitutional Tort Claims: Supreme Court of Iowa Decision

Date: Apr 5, 2025

Nonviability of Godfrey Constitutional Tort Claims Introduction This commentary examines the Iowa Supreme Court’s per curiam decision in Wagner v. State of Iowa and William L. Spece, No. 22-1625,...

Zoning Appeals under § 335.18 Exempt from MTCA Pleading Rules and Clarified Standing Standards

Date: Apr 5, 2025

Zoning Appeals under § 335.18 Exempt from MTCA Pleading Rules and Clarified Standing Standards Introduction In 1000 Friends of Iowa et al. v. Polk County Board of Supervisors, No. 23-1199 (Iowa Apr....

Only the First Outcry Counts: Iowa Supreme Court Defines “Initial Disclosure” Under § 622.31B as the First Disclosure

Date: Mar 29, 2025

Only the First Outcry Counts: Iowa Supreme Court Defines “Initial Disclosure” Under § 622.31B as the First Disclosure Introduction In State of Iowa v. Allan Robert Sievers, No. 23-0413 (Iowa Mar. 28,...

Post-Remand Ambiguity as Good Cause: Iowa Supreme Court Requires Leniency on § 668.11 Expert Deadlines When Appeals Create Uncertainty

Date: Mar 22, 2025

Post-Remand Ambiguity as Good Cause: Iowa Supreme Court Requires Leniency on § 668.11 Expert Deadlines When Appeals Create Uncertainty Introduction In Jahn Patric Kirlin and Sara Louise Kirlin v. Dr....

Iowa Supreme Court Clarifies: “Any One Loss” in Business Income Coverage Is a Single, Aggregate Limit Across All Covered Locations When the Policy Selects an All-Locations Schedule

Date: Mar 22, 2025

Iowa Supreme Court Clarifies: “Any One Loss” in Business Income Coverage Is a Single, Aggregate Limit Across All Covered Locations When the Policy Selects an All-Locations Schedule Introduction In...

Establishing Rigorous Standards for Client Trust Account Management and Communication

Date: Mar 20, 2025

Establishing Rigorous Standards for Client Trust Account Management and Communication Introduction The Iowa Supreme Court’s recent decision in Iowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board,...

Ineffective PCR Counsel Claims Do Not Extend Statutory Limitations: Affirming the Finality of the Three-Year Postconviction Relief Deadline

Date: Mar 20, 2025

Ineffective PCR Counsel Claims Do Not Extend Statutory Limitations: Affirming the Finality of the Three-Year Postconviction Relief Deadline Introduction The case of Brandon Daniel Ruiz v. State of...

The Public Nature of Use of Force Reports: Expanding Access to Factual Police Records

Date: Mar 20, 2025

The Public Nature of Use of Force Reports: Expanding Access to Factual Police Records Introduction In the case of Harvey L. Harrison, Appellee, v. Lisa Mickey, in her official capacity as Open...

Defining the Completion of Administrative Investigations: The Intersection of Discipline and Procedural Rights under Iowa Code §80F.1

Date: Mar 20, 2025

Defining the Completion of Administrative Investigations: The Intersection of Discipline and Procedural Rights under Iowa Code §80F.1 Introduction The judgment in Antoine Smith v. City of Cedar...

Deferred Judgment Eligibility and Prior Felony Conviction: Definitive Interpretation of Iowa Code § 907.3(1)(a)(1)

Date: Mar 20, 2025

Deferred Judgment Eligibility and Prior Felony Conviction: Definitive Interpretation of Iowa Code § 907.3(1)(a)(1) Introduction In the case of State of Iowa v. Ewaun Connor Gardner Jr., the Supreme...

Disputed Trust Funds Still Require a Prompt Accounting Upon Client Request

Date: Mar 15, 2025

Disputed Trust Funds Still Require a Prompt Accounting Upon Client Request Case: Iowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board v. Carmen Eichmann Court: Supreme Court of Iowa Date: March 14, 2025 I....

Preservation Required to Seek Equitable Tolling of Iowa PCR Limitations; Structural-Error Relief for PCR Counsel’s Silence Not Extended to Time-Bar Dismissals Where § 822.3 Forecloses Tolling

Date: Mar 15, 2025

Preservation Required to Seek Equitable Tolling of Iowa PCR Limitations; Structural-Error Relief for PCR Counsel’s Silence Not Extended to Time-Bar Dismissals Where § 822.3 Forecloses Tolling I....

Iowa Open Records Act: Police Use-of-Force Reports Are Not “Confidential Personnel Records” Under § 22.7(11)

Date: Mar 15, 2025

Iowa Open Records Act: Police Use-of-Force Reports Are Not “Confidential Personnel Records” Under § 22.7(11) I. Introduction In Harvey L. Harrison v. Lisa Mickey, in her official capacity as Open...

“Investigation Completed” Under Iowa Code § 80F.1 Occurs When the Agency Makes Its Discipline Decision

Date: Mar 15, 2025

“Investigation Completed” Under Iowa Code § 80F.1 Occurs When the Agency Makes Its Discipline Decision 1. Introduction In Antoine Smith v. City of Cedar Rapids (Iowa Mar. 14, 2025; amended May 22,...

FARA’s “Any Time” Clause Does Not Create Retroactive Liability Absent Express Retroactivity Language

Date: Mar 15, 2025

FARA’s “Any Time” Clause Does Not Create Retroactive Liability Absent Express Retroactivity Language I. Introduction In Bert Miller and Nancy Duffner v. State of Iowa (Iowa Mar. 14, 2025), the Iowa...

No Retroactive Application of FARA: Statutory Presumptions and Judicial Caution in Fertility Fraud Litigation

Date: Mar 15, 2025

No Retroactive Application of FARA: Statutory Presumptions and Judicial Caution in Fertility Fraud Litigation Introduction In the case of Bert Miller and Nancy Duffner, Appellants, v. State of Iowa,...

Deferred-Judgment Ineligibility Turns on Existing Felony Conviction—Not Offense-Commission Order (Iowa Code § 907.3(1)(a)(1))

Date: Mar 15, 2025

Deferred-Judgment Ineligibility Turns on Existing Felony Conviction—Not Offense-Commission Order (Iowa Code § 907.3(1)(a)(1)) I. Introduction In State of Iowa v. Ewaun Connor Gardner Jr. (Iowa Mar....

Establishing the Harmlessness of Cumulative Hearsay and the Validity of Remote Sentencing: New Precedents from State of Iowa v. Jason Michael Pirie

Date: Mar 13, 2025

Establishing the Harmlessness of Cumulative Hearsay and the Validity of Remote Sentencing: New Precedents from State of Iowa v. Jason Michael Pirie Introduction In the matter of State of Iowa,...