Iowa Case Commentaries

ICRA Claims Are Not “Brought Under” the IMTCA: Section 670.4A’s Qualified Immunity, Heightened Pleading, and Immediate Appeal Do Not Apply

Date: Nov 16, 2025

ICRA Claims Are Not “Brought Under” the IMTCA: Section 670.4A’s Qualified Immunity, Heightened Pleading, and Immediate Appeal Do Not Apply Introduction In Benjamin Fogle and Amanda Fogle, on behalf...

Iowa Clarifies: No Overt Act or Interruption Required to Prove Specific Intent Under § 709.11; Single‑Episode Cross‑Victim Conduct Can Establish Intent

Date: Nov 16, 2025

Iowa Clarifies: No Overt Act or Interruption Required to Prove Specific Intent Under § 709.11; Single‑Episode Cross‑Victim Conduct Can Establish Intent Introduction In State of Iowa v. Frederick Lee...

Kepner’s Rule: Generalized Eyewitness-Identification Expertise Is Ordinarily Admissible Under Iowa Rule 5.702, and Corroboration Is Irrelevant to Admissibility

Date: Nov 16, 2025

Kepner’s Rule: Generalized Eyewitness-Identification Expertise Is Ordinarily Admissible Under Iowa Rule 5.702, and Corroboration Is Irrelevant to Admissibility Introduction In State of Iowa v. Pat...

Iowa § 670.4A Does Not Apply to Common-Law Negligence or Nuisance—Even When Duties Are Drawn from Statutes: Immediate Appeals Under § 670.4A(4) Unavailable

Date: Nov 11, 2025

Iowa § 670.4A Does Not Apply to Common-Law Negligence or Nuisance—Even When Duties Are Drawn from Statutes: Immediate Appeals Under § 670.4A(4) Unavailable Introduction The Iowa Supreme Court’s...

Iowa Supreme Court Adopts Whole-File Expungement for Eligible Misdemeanor Convictions Under Iowa Code § 901C.3

Date: Nov 11, 2025

Iowa Supreme Court Adopts Whole-File Expungement for Eligible Misdemeanor Convictions Under Iowa Code § 901C.3 Introduction In J. Doe v. Iowa District Court for Polk County, the Supreme Court of Iowa...

No Appeal Needed, No 30-Day Clock: Iowa Supreme Court Confirms Post-Judgment Attorney Fee Applications Are Collateral and Timely If Filed Without Undue Delay

Date: Nov 11, 2025

No Appeal Needed, No 30-Day Clock: Iowa Supreme Court Confirms Post-Judgment Attorney Fee Applications Are Collateral and Timely If Filed Without Undue Delay Court: Supreme Court of Iowa Date:...

Juvenile Courts May Temporarily Stay HHS Placement Moves Pending Best‑Interests Review Under Iowa Code § 232.102

Date: Nov 2, 2025

Juvenile Courts May Temporarily Stay HHS Placement Moves Pending Best‑Interests Review Under Iowa Code § 232.102 Introduction This commentary analyzes the Iowa Supreme Court’s decision in Iowa...

“Toward Another” Under Iowa’s Assault Statute Does Not Require Pointing a Weapon: State v. Meisheid

Date: Oct 28, 2025

“Toward Another” Under Iowa’s Assault Statute Does Not Require Pointing a Weapon: State v. Meisheid Introduction In State of Iowa v. Matthew James Meisheid, the Iowa Supreme Court addressed whether a...

Functional Impairment Controls When Post-Injury Earnings Are Equal or Greater: Iowa Supreme Court Clarifies § 85.34(2)(v) in Den Hartog Industries v. Dungan

Date: Oct 10, 2025

Functional Impairment Controls When Post-Injury Earnings Are Equal or Greater: Iowa Supreme Court Clarifies § 85.34(2)(v) in Den Hartog Industries v. Dungan Introduction In Den Hartog Industries and...

Retroactive Authentication of Bodycam-Captured Surveillance Video: Iowa Supreme Court Confirms Subsequent Witness Testimony Can Cure Foundational Defects Under Rule 5.901

Date: Oct 10, 2025

Retroactive Authentication of Bodycam-Captured Surveillance Video: Iowa Supreme Court Confirms Subsequent Witness Testimony Can Cure Foundational Defects Under Rule 5.901 Case: State of Iowa v....

Iowa Supreme Court Declares: “No Guns While Criming” – State v. Woods and the Constitutional Limits on Firearm Possession During Criminal Conduct

Date: Jun 28, 2025

Iowa Supreme Court Declares: “No Guns While Criming” – State v. Woods and the Constitutional Limits on Firearm Possession During Criminal Conduct 1. Introduction State v. Kevin Dwayne Woods, Jr. (No....

“Sovereign Immunity After Burnett” – Sikora v. State of Iowa and the Closing of Iowa’s Common-Law Door to Wrongful-Imprisonment Damages

Date: Jun 28, 2025

“Sovereign Immunity After Burnett” – Sikora v. State of Iowa and the Closing of Iowa’s Common-Law Door to Wrongful-Imprisonment Damages 1. Introduction On 27 June 2025 the Iowa Supreme Court,...

State v. Cole: Waiver of Firearm Rights Through Consent Protective Orders & Limits on Consecutive Sentencing After Probation Revocation

Date: Jun 28, 2025

State v. Cole: Waiver of Firearm Rights Through Consent Protective Orders & Limits on Consecutive Sentencing After Probation Revocation 1. Introduction In State of Iowa v. Jordan Kevin Cole,...

Refining Iowa’s “Honest-Belief” Rule and the Disability Threshold under the ICRA: A Commentary on McClure v. Corteva Agriscience (Iowa 2025)

Date: Jun 23, 2025

Refining Iowa’s “Honest-Belief” Rule and the Disability Threshold under the ICRA: A Commentary on McClure v. Corteva Agriscience (Supreme Court of Iowa, 2025) 1. Introduction The Supreme Court of...

“On-Body Containers” and the Search-Incident-to-Arrest Exception: State of Iowa v. Patrick Scullark

Date: Jun 23, 2025

“On-Body Containers” and the Search-Incident-to-Arrest Exception: A Commentary on State of Iowa v. Patrick Scullark Introduction State of Iowa v. Patrick Wayman Scullark, Jr., No. 23-1218, decided by...

From “Drowning Machines” to Duty of Care: Iowa Supreme Court Narrows Qualified Immunity and Re-defines Public-Duty Limits for Recreational Water-Trail Claims

Date: Jun 18, 2025

From “Drowning Machines” to Duty of Care: Iowa Supreme Court Narrows Qualified Immunity and Re-defines Public-Duty Limits for Recreational Water-Trail Claims 1. Introduction In Estate of Kahn &...

Lucas v. Warhol: Due-Process Boundaries on Alternative Service & “Good-Cause” Extensions When a Defendant Has No Fixed Address

Date: Jun 18, 2025

Lucas v. Warhol: Due-Process Boundaries on Alternative Service & “Good-Cause” Extensions When a Defendant Has No Fixed Address 1. Introduction Rhonda C. Lucas sued Peter J. Warhol for injuries...

Iowa Supreme Court Revives Warrantless “Trash Pulls”: The Constitutional Validation of Iowa Code § 808.16(3) in State v. Amble & Mandracchia

Date: Jun 18, 2025

Iowa Supreme Court Revives Warrantless “Trash Pulls” The Constitutional Validation of Iowa Code § 808.16(3) in State v. Amble & Mandracchia Introduction The Supreme Court of Iowa’s decision in State...

Rheeder v. Gray (Iowa 2025): Clarifying the “Severe-or-Pervasive” Harassment Standard and the “Materially Adverse” Retaliation Threshold under the Iowa Civil Rights Act

Date: Jun 7, 2025

Rheeder v. Gray, City of Marion, Slagle & McHale – Iowa Supreme Court (2025) Clarifying the “Severe-or-Pervasive” Harassment Standard and the “Materially Adverse” Retaliation Threshold under the Iowa...

“No Fixed-Route” Natural Drainage Easements: Robinson v. Central Iowa Power Cooperative (Iowa 2025)

Date: Jun 7, 2025

“No Fixed-Route” Natural Drainage Easements: Robinson v. Central Iowa Power Cooperative (Iowa 2025) Introduction In Robinson v. Central Iowa Power Cooperative, the Iowa Supreme Court squarely...