Iowa Case Commentaries

Allocation of Damages and Front Pay Exemption under Employment Discrimination Law: Channon v. United Parcel Service, Inc.

Date: Jul 6, 2001

Allocation of Damages and Front Pay Exemption under Employment Discrimination Law: Channon v. United Parcel Service, Inc. Introduction In the landmark case of Channon v. United Parcel Service, Inc....

Enforcement of Mechanic's Lien in Owner-Occupied Dwellings: Schaffer v. Moyer Construction

Date: Jun 1, 2001

Enforcement of Mechanic's Lien in Owner-Occupied Dwellings: Schaffer v. Moyer Construction Introduction Schaffer v. Moyer Construction, Inc. (628 N.W.2d 11) is a landmark decision by the Supreme...

Reinforcing Statutory Standards for Terminating CINA Orders: Analysis of In the Interest of K.N.

Date: Apr 26, 2001

Reinforcing Statutory Standards for Terminating CINA Orders: Analysis of In the Interest of K.N. Introduction The Supreme Court of Iowa's decision in In the Interest of K.N., 625 N.W.2d 731 (Iowa...

Establishing "Agreement" in Conspiracy Charges: Insights from State v. Speicher

Date: Apr 26, 2001

Establishing "Agreement" in Conspiracy Charges: Insights from State v. Speicher Introduction State of Iowa v. James Daryl Speicher (625 N.W.2d 738) is a pivotal case in Iowa jurisprudence that...

Expanding Standards for Effective Assistance of Counsel: Consular Notification and Interpreter Conduct in Jose Ledezma v. State of Iowa

Date: Apr 26, 2001

Expanding Standards for Effective Assistance of Counsel: Consular Notification and Interpreter Conduct in Jose Ledezma v. State of Iowa Introduction Jose Ledezma v. State of Iowa, 626 N.W.2d 134,...

Strict Criteria for Spoliation Inference in Medical Malpractice: Analysis of Phillips v. Covenant Clinic

Date: Apr 26, 2001

Strict Criteria for Spoliation Inference in Medical Malpractice: Analysis of Phillips v. Covenant Clinic Introduction The case of Janet Phillips, Executor of the Estate of Paul Harvey Phillips v....

Negligent Misrepresentation in Educational Counseling: Sain II v. Cedar Rapids Community School District

Date: Apr 26, 2001

Negligent Misrepresentation in Educational Counseling: Sain II v. Cedar Rapids Community School District Introduction The case of Bruce E. Sain II v. Cedar Rapids Community School District (626...

Clarifying Specific Intent and True Threats in Iowa Harassment Law

Date: Feb 15, 2001

Clarifying Specific Intent and True Threats in Iowa Harassment Law Introduction In the landmark case of State of Iowa vs. Dennis E. Button, the Supreme Court of Iowa addressed pivotal issues...

Interpretation of "Violating This Subsection": Enhanced Sentencing in Iowa v. DeCamp

Date: Feb 15, 2001

Interpretation of "Violating This Subsection": Enhanced Sentencing in Iowa v. DeCamp Introduction State of Iowa v. Gary Dean DeCAMP (622 N.W.2d 290) is a landmark decision by the Supreme Court of...

Strict Adherence to Evidentiary Rules and the Confrontation Clause: An Analysis of State v. Castaneda

Date: Jan 19, 2001

Strict Adherence to Evidentiary Rules and the Confrontation Clause: An Analysis of State of Iowa v. John Castaneda (621 N.W.2d 435) Introduction The case of State of Iowa v. John Castaneda, decided...

Establishing Legal Malice in Workers' Compensation Bad Faith Claims: Insights from Gibson v. ITT Hartford Insurance Company

Date: Jan 19, 2001

Establishing Legal Malice in Workers' Compensation Bad Faith Claims: Insights from Gibson v. ITT Hartford Insurance Company Introduction In Gibson v. ITT Hartford Insurance Company, the Supreme Court...

Judicial Review Authority in Consolidated Disability Proceedings: Insights from IBP, Inc. v. Harpole

Date: Jan 19, 2001

Judicial Review Authority in Consolidated Disability Proceedings: Insights from IBP, Inc. v. Harpole Introduction In the landmark case of IBP, Inc. v. Linda Harpole, the Supreme Court of Iowa...

Custody Modification Burden of Proof Affirmed in Long-Distance Relocation: In re The Marriage of Thielges

Date: Dec 23, 2000

Custody Modification Burden of Proof Affirmed in Long-Distance Relocation: In re The Marriage of Thielges Introduction The case of In re The Marriage of Elnora R. Thielges and Brian Thielges (623...

Affirmation of the Sexually Violent Predator Act as a Civil Commitment Mechanism

Date: Dec 21, 2000

Affirmation of the Sexually Violent Predator Act as a Civil Commitment Mechanism Introduction In the case of IN RE THE DETENTION OF DANIEL E. GARREN, Appellant, decided by the Supreme Court of Iowa...

Affirmation of Proper Consideration of Pre-Sentence Information in Sentencing Decisions: State of Iowa v. Christopher R. Grandberry

Date: Nov 17, 2000

Affirmation of Proper Consideration of Pre-Sentence Information in Sentencing Decisions: State of Iowa v. Christopher R. Grandberry, 619 N.W.2d 399 (Iowa 2000) Introduction In the landmark case State...

Iowa Supreme Court Establishes Broader Interpretation of Reasonable Cause in Terry Stops

Date: Nov 17, 2000

Iowa Supreme Court Establishes Broader Interpretation of Reasonable Cause in Terry Stops Introduction In the landmark case of State of Iowa v. Keith Heminover, the Supreme Court of Iowa addressed...

Municipal Recycling Programs Do Not Violate Iowa Competition Laws

Date: Oct 12, 2000

Municipal Recycling Programs Do Not Violate Iowa Competition Laws Introduction The case of Donald Crippen, Joan Crippen, and Barbara Maitland, d/b/a HMR Home and Business Recyclers v. City of Cedar...

Admissibility of Settlement Evidence: Graber v. City of Ankeny

Date: Sep 8, 2000

Admissibility of Settlement Evidence: Graber v. City of Ankeny Introduction Graber v. City of Ankeny, 616 N.W.2d 633 (Iowa 2000) is a landmark case adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Iowa that...

Iowa Supreme Court Establishes Limits on Search Incident to Citation and Rejects Good Faith Exception

Date: Sep 8, 2000

Iowa Supreme Court Establishes Limits on Search Incident to Citation and Rejects Good Faith Exception Introduction In State of Iowa v. Heather M. Cline, 617 N.W.2d 277 (2000), the Supreme Court of...

Affirmation of Aiding and Abetting in Second-Degree Murder: State v. Tangie

Date: Sep 8, 2000

Affirmation of Aiding and Abetting in Second-Degree Murder: State of Iowa v. Evelyn Lou Tangie Introduction State of Iowa v. Evelyn Lou Tangie is a significant judicial decision rendered by the...